Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. Lenore Skenazy, the New York Subway and Mission Command

Example of the principleMission Command (#22)

Family

Lenore Skenazy, the New York Subway and Mission Command

In 2008, the New York columnist Lenore Skenazy lets her nine-year-old son ride the subway home alone. She gives him the objective, a map, a fare card and money; he finds the way himself.

At the top, a large circle as headquarters; at the bottom, a small group of dots; between them, a band of teal lines as a river with a bridge of two strokes. In the first version, a dashed line leads step by step across the bridge; the bridge breaks, the dots stand still, and a signal shuttles up and back. In the second, only a golden arc comes down from the top to the goal on the far bank; the bridge breaks again, the dots look for a crossing themselves and reach the goal.
Principle #22

Mission Command: Set the objective and intent clearly and leave the way open, so that the people on the ground can act correctly on their own.

4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

Mission Command sounds like something for the general staff. Yet anyone raising children runs into it. At some point, parents have to decide whether to prescribe every step or to name the objective and trust the child with the way. In 2008, Lenore Skenazy answered this question in public. In doing so, she sparked a debate that continues to this day.

On a network map of four lines, a golden ride with one transfer leads from the white starting ring to home – as with Lenore Skenazy’s son.
On a network map of four lines, a golden ride with one transfer leads from the white starting ring to home – as with Lenore Skenazy’s son.

A department store, a map, a fare card

Situation
At the time, Lenore Skenazy writes a column for the newspaper The New York Sun. Her son is nine years old. She leaves him on his own at the Bloomingdale’s department store in Manhattan. He has a subway map, a fare card and $20 with him. He rides home alone and arrives safe and sound. On April 1, 2008, her column appears under the title “Why I Let My 9-Year-Old Ride the Subway Alone.”
Link to the principle
This is a mission in its purest form. The objective is clear: get home. The means are there. The route, the transfers and the decision about whom to ask if in doubt, she leaves to him. She doesn’t prescribe how he does it. She makes sure that he can do it.

Preparation instead of prescription

Situation
The means Skenazy gives her son are not chosen at random. With the map, he can find his way. With the fare card, he gets through the turnstile. With the money, he can help himself if something goes wrong. What he doesn’t get: someone to go with him, step-by-step instructions, surveillance along the way.
Link to the principle
The principle that an order should contain what the person carrying it out cannot determine for themselves, and nothing more, is traced back to Helmuth von Moltke. That is exactly how Skenazy proceeds. Mission command requires preparation. Freedom without the ability to use it would be recklessness. Ability without freedom would be paternalism.

“America’s Worst Mom”

Situation
The column sets off a wave of reactions, in the United States and around the world. Many accuse Skenazy of endangering her child and of being a bad mother. Before long, the media are calling her “America’s Worst Mom.” In an interview with the radio network NPR, she stands by her decision. She argues that overprotection is itself a danger: a child who is never trusted with anything may one day really be unable to do anything alone.
Link to the principle
In organizations, too, mission command has its opponents. If you give freedom, you take a risk, and if something goes wrong, it falls back on the leader. Detailed control feels safer. Skenazy counters: the greater risk is that people never learn to judge for themselves. If you have never been allowed to walk a path alone, you are helpless when the plan no longer fits.

From one ride to a movement

Situation
Skenazy starts the blog Free Range Kids. In 2009, her book “Free-Range Kids” is published. In 2012, she hosts the TV series “World’s Worst Mom.” Later, together with Daniel Shuchman, Peter Gray and Jonathan Haidt, she founds the organization Let Grow. Its aim is to make it easy, normal and legal to give children independence. In 2018, Utah becomes the first U.S. state to pass a law assuring parents that they may give their children a certain degree of independence without this being considered neglect. Colorado, Oklahoma and Texas, among others, later follow with similar laws.
Link to the principle
A family decision becomes a question of the overall conditions. Mission command needs an environment that does not punish independence. If laws, neighbors or superiors treat every deviation as a breach of duty, no one dares to give freedom anymore. Then all that remains is instructions down to the last detail.

Room to move grows with ability

Situation
Skenazy does not demand that every nine-year-old ride the subway alone. In her view, parents should decide according to the child’s maturity and the local situation, not out of vague fear. Her son lived in a city where the subway is part of everyday life. For another child in another place, the right first step may be a different one.
Link to the principle
Mission command is not letting go at any price. How much of the way you leave open depends on what the other person can do and how well they understand the intent. Newcomers get a narrower mission. Those who have proven themselves get more room. The goal is to widen that room step by step.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. Name the objective and provide the necessary means; leave the way open.
  2. Prepare instead of prescribing.
  3. Be prepared for others to find your trust reckless.
  4. Measure the room you give by ability, not by your fear.
  5. Expand freedom step by step.
Summary

In 2008, Lenore Skenazy gave her nine-year-old son a clear objective and the necessary means and let him find his way home himself. The fierce reactions show how unfamiliar this kind of trust is. Her case makes visible what mission command means in the family: preparation instead of prescription, room to move according to ability and an environment that allows independence.

Sources
  • Lenore Skenazy: Free-Range Kids: Giving Our Children the Freedom We Had Without Going Nuts with Worry. John Wiley & Sons 2009.
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind Mission Command: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Lenore Skenazy, the New York Subway and Mission Command.