Alexander Fleming, Penicillin and Fortuna and Virtù
In September 1928, Alexander Fleming finds a contaminated culture dish in his London laboratory in which a mold has killed the bacteria. Chance provides the discovery, and Fleming’s trained eye recognizes it. But only the drive of others turns it into a medicine.
A teal line flows calmly; beside it, golden dots build a dam of arches and a narrow side channel. The line swells, sweeps away unprotected mist-blue dots, is diverted into the channel at the dam and makes a golden circle light up there; at the end, a small arc drifts past, and a golden dot on the bank links up with it at just the right moment.
Principle #48
Fortuna and Virtù: You cannot control chance, but you can be prepared and agile enough to recognize it and seize it when it comes.
3 min read4 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
In Chapter 25 of “The Prince,” Niccolò Machiavelli writes that fortuna, luck or chance, governs about half of our actions. The other half is up to us, to our virtù: drive, shrewdness and resolve. A good 300 years later, in 1854, the French chemist Louis Pasteur said in a lecture in Lille that in the field of observation, chance favors only the prepared mind. The discovery of penicillin brings both ideas together in a single story of Fortuna and Virtù.
In a culture dish full of colonies lies a golden spot, surrounded by an empty ring – as in Alexander Fleming’s discovery of penicillin.
01
A forgotten dish
Situation
Alexander Fleming is a bacteriologist at St Mary’s Hospital in London. In the summer of 1928, he goes on vacation and leaves cultures of staphylococci on his workbench. When he returns on September 3, one of the dishes has been contaminated by a mold. All around the mold, the bacteria have died. Later research in 1966 traced the spores to a laboratory directly below, where the mycologist C. J. La Touche worked.
Link to the principle
This is fortuna in its purest form. Nobody ordered the mold. It probably drifted in on the air from another laboratory, onto a dish that could actually have been thrown away long before.
02
An eye that does not look away
Situation
Many people would have thrown out the contaminated dish as a failed experiment. Fleming takes a closer look. In the early 1920s, also by chance, he had discovered the enzyme lysozyme, which dissolves bacteria. Ever since his experiences with wound infections in the First World War, he had been looking for substances that kill bacteria without harming the body. A colleague later remarked that if Fleming had been as tidy as he himself was, he would not have made his two great discoveries.
Link to the principle
This is where virtù comes in. Chance helps only those who know what they are looking for. Fleming’s prior knowledge turned a mishap into an observation. That is Pasteur’s prepared mind.
03
A paper hardly anyone reads
Situation
On March 7, 1929, Fleming names the active substance penicillin, and in the same year he publishes his results in the British Journal of Experimental Pathology. The paper attracts little attention. Attempts to produce and purify the substance in usable quantities fail. In the 1930s, penicillin is largely left on the shelf.
Link to the principle
Fortuna opens a door, but she does not walk through it herself. Fleming had the eye but not the means and perhaps not the tenacity to turn the discovery into a medicine. Virtù also means following an opportunity through to the end.
04
The drive in Oxford
Situation
At the end of the 1930s, Howard Florey and Ernst Chain in Oxford take up Fleming’s work. Norman Heatley develops a process for extracting the active substance. In 1940, the team publishes its first results, which show that penicillin works against infections in animal experiments. After clinical trials, penicillin is used on a large scale in the Second World War. In 1945, Fleming, Florey and Chain share the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.
Link to the principle
The discovery of penicillin was the work of many minds. Fortuna brought the mold to Fleming. Fleming’s virtù recognized it. The virtù of Florey, Chain and Heatley made it usable. Here, Machiavelli’s half that is up to us is the work of an entire team.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Know what you are looking for. Then you will recognize chance when it comes.
02
Don’t be quick to throw away the unexpected; take a look at it.
03
A discovery is only the beginning. Follow it through to its application.
04
Bring others in when you lack the resources or the stamina.
05
Share the success with those who made the lucky break usable.
Summary
In 1928, a mold happened to land on a culture dish in Alexander Fleming’s laboratory. Fleming recognized what he was seeing because he had been looking for bacteria-killing substances for years. But only Howard Florey, Ernst Chain and Norman Heatley turned it into a medicine, starting in 1940. The story shows Machiavelli’s idea: fortuna provides the opportunity, but only virtù makes something of it, and sometimes that takes more than one person.