In the early 15th century, three men claim at the same time to be the rightful pope. The Council of Constance ends the split by disposing of all three claims and, in 1417, electing a single head again in Martin V.
A ring of six dots is the boat; a golden dot sits at the front and another at the back, and from both, arrows point in opposite directions at the same time. The dots in the ring pull apart, and the ring spins in front of a mist-blue edge. Then only one dot stays golden; the second moves alongside it in teal and points to a map with a line, all the dots move in one direction, and the ring glides through a gate to the shore.
Principle #23
Unity of Command: For every objective, exactly one person or body bears responsibility, so that forces do not work against each other.
4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
An organization with three chiefs, each declaring the others illegitimate: it sounds like a caricature. For the Western Church, it was reality for almost four decades. How this split arose and how it ended shows what it costs when leadership is ambiguous, and how hard it is to reunite it. It is a lesson in Unity of Command.
Three dashed rings dissolve; on the right, an assembly of arcs of dots closes around a single golden head – as in Constance in 1417.
01
A schism that will not end
Situation
In 1378, the Western Church splits. After a disputed papal election, there are two lines of popes, one in Rome and one in Avignon. Each has its own cardinals, its own administration and its own supporters among the kings of Europe. The period until 1417 is known as the Western Schism. In 1409, a council in Pisa tries to resolve the dispute. It deposes both popes and elects a new one. But the two deposed popes don’t recognize this. In the end there are three popes: Gregory XII of the Roman line, Benedict XIII of the Avignon line and John XXIII of the Pisan line.
Link to the principle
Without unity of command, forces work against each other. Each pope fills offices, levies dues and hands down judgments that the others don’t recognize. Pisa shows a typical mistake: if you install a new head without really resolving the old claims, you multiply the problem instead of solving it.
02
A king pushes for a solution
Situation
On the initiative of Sigismund, King of the Romans, a new council is convened. It opens in November 1414 in Constance on Lake Constance. Cardinals, bishops, abbots, scholars and envoys travel there from all over Western Christendom. Sigismund wants to restore the unity of the Church and acts as its protector.
Link to the principle
A dispute over who leads can rarely be resolved by those in dispute. It takes an authority that brings everyone to the table and stands above the camps. In Constance, that is at first the council itself, backed by the political weight of the king.
03
Three popes, three ways
Situation
In March 1415, John XXIII promises to resign but then secretly flees Constance. On April 6, 1415, in the decree “Haec sancta,” the council declares that its authority comes directly from Christ, and on May 29, 1415, it deposes John. Gregory XII has the council formally convoked once more in his own name through an envoy and, on July 4, 1415, announces his resignation through his representative Carlo Malatesta. He then becomes a cardinal. Benedict XIII refuses to resign and is deposed on July 26, 1417. His supporters largely abandon him.
Link to the principle
Unity comes about only when all competing claims have been disposed of. And each one needs a different way: deposition after flight, honorable resignation with a new role, deposition against resistance. Gregory’s case shows something important: people who are supposed to go find it easier to leave if they can save face.
04
One pope for all
Situation
On November 8, 1417, a conclave meets in the Kaufhaus, the merchants’ hall in Constance: 23 cardinals and six representatives from each of the five nations of the council. On November 11, Oddone Colonna is elected; he takes the name Martin V. It is the only papal election ever held on German soil. With him, the Western Church has a generally recognized head again for the first time in almost 40 years. The council ends on April 22, 1418.
Link to the principle
Unity of command needs legitimacy. A head recognized by only one party does not end the dispute. That is why it was crucial that the election was backed by a broad assembly and that the previous claims had been settled beforehand. Only then could a single head speak for everyone again.
05
What unity does not solve
Situation
The same council condemns the Bohemian theologian Jan Hus. He is burned at the stake outside the gates of Constance in 1415 and is often seen today as a forerunner of the Reformation. The council also decides that councils are to be held regularly in the future. The question of whether pope or council holds the higher authority remains disputed for a long time afterward.
Link to the principle
Unity of command removes blockages and duplicate structures. It does not guarantee that the leadership decides well. The same assembly that reunited the Church sentenced a critic to death. And it left open who holds the one head accountable. Clear responsibility is a precondition of good leadership, not a substitute for it.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Don’t install a new head without settling the old claims.
02
Bring in an authority above the camps when those in dispute can’t agree.
03
Give the person who is to leave a way out that lets them save face.
04
Make sure the new leadership is recognized by all sides.
05
Don’t mistake clear responsibility for a good decision.
Summary
In the early 15th century, three popes at once paralyzed the Western Church. The Council of Constance resolved the split by disposing of each claim individually and electing, in Martin V, a broadly recognized head. The case shows how much strength divided leadership costs, and that unity alone does not yet make for good leadership.