Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. Louis Gallois, EADS and Unity of Command

Example of the principleUnity of Command (#23)

Business

Louis Gallois, EADS and Unity of Command

Since its founding, the aerospace group EADS has been run by a Franco-German dual leadership. After costly delays to the Airbus A380, it abolishes this arrangement in July 2007, and Louis Gallois runs the group alone.

A ring of six dots is the boat; a golden dot sits at the front and another at the back, and from both, arrows point in opposite directions at the same time. The dots in the ring pull apart, and the ring spins in front of a mist-blue edge. Then only one dot stays golden; the second moves alongside it in teal and points to a map with a line, all the dots move in one direction, and the ring glides through a gate to the shore.
Principle #23

Unity of Command: For every objective, exactly one person or body bears responsibility, so that forces do not work against each other.

4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

Dual leadership is popular when two sides come together that don’t trust each other. It looks fair, because neither stands above the other. At EADS, the parent company of Airbus, this fairness proved expensive. The case shows why Unity of Command applies even where politics and national interests are in play.

Two halves of a fuselage meet, their wiring out of line; above the seam stands just one golden head – as at EADS in 2007.
Two halves of a fuselage meet, their wiring out of line; above the seam stands just one golden head – as at EADS in 2007.

A group with two heads

Situation
EADS is formed in 2000 from the merger of major German, French and Spanish aerospace companies. To preserve the balance between Germany and France, the group gets two chairmen and two CEOs, one German and one French in each case. In 2006, the CEOs are Thomas Enders and Louis Gallois, and the French co-chairman is Arnaud Lagardère.
Link to the principle
The dual leadership is a political compromise. It is meant to ensure that neither side is put at a disadvantage. But when two people are responsible for the same thing, in the end no one is solely responsible. Decisions require agreement; conflicts move upward and get stuck there.

The A380 crisis

Situation
Starting in 2006, the A380 wide-body aircraft runs into considerable delays. According to the Associated Press (AP), a report by the French Senate attributes the problems in part to disputes between managers and teams at German and French sites. AP reports that the delays wipe out more than €5 billion in expected profits for the years 2006 to 2010. Gallois, also head of Airbus since October 2006, announces 10,000 job cuts.
Link to the principle
When responsibility is divided along national lines, problems at the interfaces easily fall through the cracks. Each side optimizes its own part; no one leads the whole. That is exactly what unity of command is meant to prevent: there has to be one place that answers for the overall result and can settle conflicts between the parts.

The decision of July 2007

Situation
On July 16, 2007, the new structure is announced. Louis Gallois becomes sole CEO of EADS. Rüdiger Grube, a German formerly of DaimlerChrysler, becomes sole chairman of the board. Thomas Enders gives up his post as co-CEO and becomes head of Airbus, reporting to Gallois. Arnaud Lagardère gives up the co-chairmanship. The three top posts are to rotate between the countries every five years.
Link to the principle
The solution is remarkable. The national balance is preserved, but no longer by having two people share the same office. Instead, each side gets different offices with clear responsibilities. There is one line from the group CEO to the head of Airbus. Fairness comes from distribution, not duplication.

Politics at the table

Situation
The change coincides with a meeting between French President Nicolas Sarkozy and German Chancellor Angela Merkel. At the time, the French state holds 15% of EADS, the Lagardère group 7.5%, and DaimlerChrysler and German banks together 22.5%. Sarkozy says, in essence, that it was not France or Germany that had won, but EADS. Merkel calls the change a very important step. The shareholders still have to approve the new structure.
Link to the principle
Unity of command can’t be brought about from below when real power lies elsewhere. At EADS, the owners and the governments that had once wanted the dual leadership had to agree. Only when the costs of division had become visible were they ready to give up power. Often it takes a crisis for divided leadership to be dissolved.

What remained

Situation
The stock market reacts cautiously; the share price rises 0.6% in Paris that day. The new structure does not end all tensions between German and French interests. In the years that follow, the group’s leadership is restructured further. In 2014, EADS renames itself Airbus Group; today the company is called Airbus.
Link to the principle
Abolishing the dual leadership was a first step. It created clear responsibility at the top. The conflicting interests did not disappear, but they now had a place where they could be decided. That is the real value of unity of command: conflicts are not avoided, but they become decidable.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. Share power through different offices, not through shared offices.
  2. Watch for interfaces where no one answers for the whole.
  3. Make sure someone is allowed to settle conflicts between the parts.
  4. Win over those who hold the power for the new structure.
  5. Don’t wait for a crisis to dissolve a dual leadership.
Summary

Starting in 2000, EADS was run by two CEOs and two chairmen in order to treat Germany and France equally. After the costly delays to the A380, the group abolished the dual leadership in 2007. Louis Gallois ran the company alone, and the national balance was preserved through different offices. The case shows that unity of command makes conflicts decidable.

Back to the basics

Read what lies behind Unity of Command: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Louis Gallois, EADS and Unity of Command.