Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. Disney, Steamboat Willie and Valuable, Rare Resources

Example of the principleValuable, Rare Resources (#74)

Arts, Entertainment & SportsGovernment & Politics

Disney, Steamboat Willie and Valuable, Rare Resources

A character like Mickey Mouse is valuable because only its owner may use it. Copyright creates this rarity, and copyright has an expiration date. Disney is regarded as an advocate of longer copyright terms; in 1998, 20 years were added. Not until January 1, 2024, did “Steamboat Willie” enter the public domain.

Four gates made of teal lines stand one behind the other; many mist-blue dots move toward them, and at each gate more of them stop. At the turning point, a single dot makes it through the fourth gate, turns gold and stands alone on a short line as a pedestal; in the final image, its glow slowly fades, and next to it a new dot begins to fill with gold.
Principle #74

Valuable, Rare Resources: A lead lasts only if it rests on resources that are valuable, rare, hard to imitate and non-substitutable.

4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

Some resources are rare by nature, such as a raw material or a location. Others are rare because a law protects them. A patent, a license or a copyright prohibits others from imitating something they could easily copy technically. Jay B. Barney names being hard to imitate as a condition for a lasting lead. The example of Mickey Mouse shows how much this condition is worth when it depends on the law, and what a company does to extend it – a case of Valuable, Rare Resources.

A gold dot under a long protective roof that is extended and yet ends; behind it, freely scattered copies – as with “Steamboat Willie.”
A gold dot under a long protective roof that is extended and yet ends; behind it, freely scattered copies – as with “Steamboat Willie.”

A short film from 1928

Situation
On November 18, 1928, the cartoon “Steamboat Willie” premieres in New York. It is considered Mickey Mouse’s official debut; before that, the character had been seen only at a test screening of the film “Plane Crazy.” It is produced between July and September 1928, at a cost of just under $5,000 according to notes by Roy O. Disney. The film is a success. Its music includes the folk song “Turkey in the Straw,” a work that no longer belonged to anyone.
Link to the principle
Anyone can draw a mouse with round ears. What makes the character valuable is not the technique but the exclusive right to use it. Disney builds an empire of films, parks and merchandise on it. The resource is valuable and rare as long as no one else may use it.

The law as a protective wall

Situation
Under the U.S. Copyright Act of 1909, protection initially lasts 28 years and can be renewed for another 28 years. “Steamboat Willie” would thus have become free in the mid-1980s. The 1976 act extends protection for existing works to a maximum of 75 years. The film would now have become free in 2003.
Link to the principle
With a legally protected resource, imitability is a question of time. With every year that passes, the day draws closer when anyone may use the character. If you build on such a resource, you have a strong reason to raise the wall higher.

1998: 20 more years

Situation
In 1998, the U.S. Congress passes the Sonny Bono Copyright Term Extension Act. It extends the term of protection by another 20 years, to 95 years for works owned by companies. Critics attribute the extensions to intensive lobbying by Disney and mockingly call the law the Mickey Mouse Protection Act. In 2003, the U.S. Supreme Court upholds the extension in Eldred v. Ashcroft.
Link to the principle
Here strategy turns into politics. When a resource derives its value from a law, the law itself becomes a field of competition. Disney defends not only a character but the rarity that makes it valuable.

January 1, 2024

Situation
On January 1, 2024, “Steamboat Willie” enters the public domain in the United States, just over 95 years after its premiere. However, only this early version of the character is free. Later versions of the character remain protected for now. Then there is trademark law: it applies independently of copyright and can be renewed indefinitely as long as the trademark is in use.
Link to the principle
The case shows how companies protect a resource in layers. If one layer falls, others continue to hold: newer versions, trademark rights, the fame of the brand itself. According to Barney, the more reasons there are why a resource is hard to imitate, the safer it is.

The downside

Situation
Disney itself has built many successes on public domain material, including fairy tales by Hans Christian Andersen such as “The Little Mermaid” and “The Snow Queen,” which became “Frozen.” Critics point out that long terms of protection slow down precisely the cycle from which Disney, too, has drawn.
Link to the principle
Rarity is an advantage for the owner and a limit for everyone else. The principle explains why companies fight so hard for their resources. Whether this is good for society is another question, one the principle does not answer.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. Ask whether your resource is rare by nature or only because of a rule.
  2. A protected resource often has an expiration date; plan for it.
  3. Protect what is valuable in several layers, not just one.
  4. If your advantage depends on a law, politics becomes part of your strategy.
  5. Don’t forget what you yourself once benefited from.
Summary

Mickey Mouse is valuable because copyright makes the character rare. Disney is regarded as an advocate of longer copyright terms. Thanks to the 1998 extension, “Steamboat Willie” remained protected until the end of 2023. Since 2024, this version has been free, but newer drawings and trademark rights continue to protect the character. The example shows a resource whose rarity comes not from nature but from the law.

Sources
  • Jay B. Barney: Firm Resources and Sustained Competitive Advantage. In: Journal of Management 17 (1991), no. 1, pp. 99–120.
  • Wikipedia: Steamboat Willie
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind Valuable, Rare Resources: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Disney, Steamboat Willie and Valuable, Rare Resources.