German Soccer’s Youth Academies and Preparation in Peacetime
After Germany’s group-stage exit at the 2000 European Championship, the German Football Association (DFB) and the professional league require the professional clubs to run youth academies. The players trained there starting in the early 2000s win the 2009 Under-21 European Championship and are in the squad that wins the 2014 World Cup.
A circle like a yearly clock, half bright in teal, half dark in mist-blue; in the bright half, one dot gathers golden dots into a supply and runs the same line again and again, while a second dot rests. The hand moves into the dark, a fog of dots rolls in, the practiced line glows golden and holds, and the second dot wanders about without supplies.
Principle #45
Preparation in Peacetime: What carries you in an emergency is built in calm times, because once the crisis is here, it is too late to build it.
3 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
In elite sports, the moment of truth comes on a single evening. But the team that takes the field that night was formed 10 or 15 years earlier, in youth teams, training centers and boarding schools. After a humiliation, German soccer took this long lead time seriously. Its path shows how Preparation in Peacetime becomes binding in an organization.
Over the years, fine lines grow from many small beds into a lineup of 11 dots, one of them golden – as with Germany’s youth academies.
01
The debacle of 2000
Situation
At the 2000 European Championship in Belgium and the Netherlands, the German national team is eliminated in the group stage. After a 1–1 tie with Romania, it loses 1–0 to England and 3–0 to Portugal. It seems to have lost touch with the international elite.
Link to the principle
The crisis exposes what was neglected in calmer years. The answer could have been a new coach, a quick fix for the next tournament. Instead, the association and the clubs turn to player development, whose returns will become visible only years later.
02
A requirement for every professional club
Situation
The DFB and the Bundesliga clubs form a working group and develop a youth development plan. Since 2001, Bundesliga clubs have had to run their own youth academy as a condition for their license, and since 2002 the same has applied to the 2. Bundesliga, the second division. In addition, the DFB sets up a talent development program with regional training bases for players from Under-12 to Under-15. By the mid-2020s, there are around 350 of these bases.
Link to the principle
Preparation becomes binding when it does not depend on the goodwill of individuals. The license requirement ensures that every professional club invests, even in years when the money for the next star would be more tempting.
03
Patience without results
Situation
The first years bring no visible success. At the 2004 European Championship in Portugal, Germany is again eliminated in the group stage. The work in the youth academies continues, with coaches, schools and boarding schools, without the public noticing much of it.
Link to the principle
Preparation in Peacetime has a long lead time without returns. That makes it vulnerable: if you demand results after two years, you stop before it can take effect. Here, the association and the league hold out.
04
The first harvest
Situation
In 2008, the Under-19 team wins the European Championship, and in 2009 the Under-17 and Under-21 teams follow. This makes the DFB the first association to hold all three youth titles at the same time. The 2009 Under-21 team includes Manuel Neuer, Jérôme Boateng, Benedikt Höwedes, Mats Hummels, Sami Khedira and Mesut Özil.
Link to the principle
Nine years after the debacle, what was built in the calm years becomes visible. The success has many causes: talent, coaches, a strong generation. But it also rests on a system that was created long before.
05
The title and what came after
Situation
In 2014, Germany wins the World Cup in Brazil. All six of the 2009 Under-21 European champions named above are in the squad. Four years later, the defending champion is eliminated in the group stage at the 2018 World Cup. In early 2019, Norbert Elgert, youth coach at FC Schalke 04, criticizes the overregulation of young talent: they need to be allowed to dribble more again and make their own decisions. The DFB’s new head of youth development, Meikel Schönweitz, points out that children in other countries play in smaller teams and therefore get more touches on the ball.
Link to the principle
Preparation is never finished. A system built for the last crisis ages. If you prepare in peacetime, you have to keep reviewing and renewing the system itself; otherwise you are preparing for yesterday’s game.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Use a defeat to work on the roots, not just at the top.
02
Make preparation binding so that it does not depend on moods.
03
Be prepared for years without visible returns, and hold out.
04
Review your system regularly, before it becomes outdated.
05
Also measure success by what will be on the field in 10 years.
Summary
After Euro 2000, German soccer did not bet on a quick fix but on player development. Since 2001, professional clubs have had to run youth academies. After years without visible success came the youth titles in 2008 and 2009 and the World Cup title in 2014. The exit in 2018 showed that even a good system has to be renewed. Preparation in Peacetime is a standing task, not a project.