Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. John D. Rockefeller, the Cleveland Massacre and the Four Means

Example of the principleFour Means (#53)

Business

John D. Rockefeller, the Cleveland Massacre and the Four Means

In early 1872, in less than six weeks, John D. Rockefeller buys 22 of the 26 competing refineries in Cleveland. He offers arguments, shares or cash, secures secret freight rebates and lets the doubters feel what awaits them otherwise. All four means mesh.

Four steps of lines lead to a gate of two arcs; a dot descends step by step. On the first, the gate opens in gold and stays open; on the second, it swings half open and back; on the third, a crack runs through the frame; on the fourth, it bursts open, and the frame falls apart into mist-blue splinters.
Principle #53

Four Means: Try persuasion first, then gifts, only after that division and force last, because each later means costs more and destroys more.

3 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

The four means of the Arthashastra come from statecraft, but they also describe how power arises in markets. If you want to win other companies over, you can persuade them, offer them something, separate them from one another or put them under pressure. The wave of takeovers in Cleveland in the spring of 1872, which became known as the Cleveland Massacre, shows all of the Four Means in a single campaign.

Of 26 tanks, 22 hang on a golden line to the railroad; four stand alone – as with Rockefeller in Cleveland in 1872.
Of 26 tanks, 22 hang on a golden line to the railroad; four stand alone – as with Rockefeller in Cleveland in 1872.

An overcrowded market

Situation
On January 10, 1870, John D. Rockefeller and his partners found the Standard Oil Company in Cleveland, Ohio. Numerous refineries operate in the city; by the end of the Civil War there were already around 30. The industry is young and fiercely contested.
Link to the principle
Rockefeller wants to bring order to the industry, under his own leadership. An open price war against everyone would be expensive and uncertain. So he needs means that will get his competitors to sell, voluntarily or semi-voluntarily.

Persuading: the case for consolidation

Situation
How the individual talks went is known only from later accounts, some of them embellished. According to these, Rockefeller calmly makes the case for consolidation: whoever joins becomes part of the whole and profits from its success, instead of standing alone in a price war.
Link to the principle
This is sama, persuasion. It is the cheapest means, and it has a kernel of truth: in Cleveland, many refineries were fighting over the same business. But Rockefeller does not rely on it alone. The argument becomes compelling only through the other means.

Giving: shares or cash

Situation
Rockefeller offers the sellers a choice between cash and Standard Oil shares. He usually advises them to take the shares. Those who do often become very rich later on. Many who take the cash later regret it.
Link to the principle
This is dana, giving. The offer turns opponents into stakeholders. Those who hold shares have an interest in the winner’s success. In this way, Rockefeller buys not only plants but also loyalty.

Dividing: secret rebates

Situation
As a preferred customer, Standard Oil negotiates a secret discount with the Atlantic and Great Western Railroad: instead of the official rate of $2.40 per barrel, it pays $1.65. In late 1871, under the leadership of Tom Scott, president of the Pennsylvania Railroad, the South Improvement Company is formed, a secret alliance of railroads and large refineries. Members are to receive rebates, while nonmembers pay higher freight rates, from which the members also profit.
Link to the principle
This is bheda, division. The competitors are cut off from their most important partner, the railroad. Whoever stays outside pays more for the same transport and thus indirectly finances the members. The industry splits into the favored and the disadvantaged.

Forcing: the threat of ruin

Situation
Between February and March 1872, in less than six weeks, Rockefeller buys out 22 of his 26 competitors in Cleveland. The threat of the new alliance works. He is also accused of undercutting prices until competitors had to sell. In April 1872, the Pennsylvania legislature revokes the charter of the South Improvement Company before it has completed a single transaction. By then, Rockefeller already has Cleveland in his hands.
Link to the principle
This is danda, force. It does not even have to be fully applied. The credible threat is enough to make the argument and the offer suddenly seem very persuasive. Here the four means do not work one after another but as a package. The price comes later: Ida Tarbell’s 1904 book on Standard Oil shapes the image of a ruthless monopoly, and in 1911 the U.S. Supreme Court orders the company broken up.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. A good argument carries more weight when the other side knows its alternatives.
  2. Turn opponents into stakeholders, and they will share your interest.
  3. If you cut competitors off from their partners, you weaken them without an open fight.
  4. A credible threat often replaces the deed.
  5. What you win through pressure can later cost you your reputation and your freedom.
Summary

In the spring of 1872, John D. Rockefeller took over almost all the refineries in Cleveland within a few weeks. He made the case for consolidation, offered shares or cash, cut competitors off from the railroads through secret freight rebates and let them feel the threat of ruin. The four means worked as a package. They built an empire and, decades later, led to its breakup.

Sources
  • Ida M. Tarbell: The History of the Standard Oil Company. New York: McClure, Phillips & Co. 1904.
  • Kautilya: Arthashastra. Translated by Rudrapatna Shamasastry. Bangalore: Government Press 1915.
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind the Four Means: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: John D. Rockefeller, the Cleveland Massacre and the Four Means.