Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. Series: House of Cards

Example of the principleFour Means (#53)

Government & Politics

Series: House of Cards

In “House of Cards,” Congressman Frank Underwood works his way up using all four means: he persuades, he hands out favors, he plays people off against one another and he blackmails. The series shows how effective the four means are and what happens when no limit applies anymore.

Four steps of lines lead to a gate of two arcs; a dot descends step by step. On the first, the gate opens in gold and stays open; on the second, it swings half open and back; on the third, a crack runs through the frame; on the fourth, it bursts open, and the frame falls apart into mist-blue splinters.
Principle #53

Four Means: Try persuasion first, then gifts, only after that division and force last, because each later means costs more and destroys more.

3 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

The Arthashastra describes the Four Means soberly, as tools of statecraft. Its first question is not whether they are good but when they work. The Netflix series “House of Cards” asks the same question in Washington, only without the sober distance. Its main character, Frank Underwood, is a study in how to move people when any means will do.

A house of slanted cards grows four stories high, the top glowing golden, a card slipping at the bottom – as in “House of Cards.”
A house of slanted cards grows four stories high, the top glowing golden, a card slipping at the bottom – as in “House of Cards.”

A broken promise

Situation
Beau Willimon’s series premieres on Netflix on February 1, 2013. It is based on a 1989 novel by Michael Dobbs and a 1990 British television series. Frank Underwood, played by Kevin Spacey, is a congressman from South Carolina and House Majority Whip. He has been promised the post of secretary of state. The new president breaks the promise. With his wife, Claire (Robin Wright), Frank plots his revenge.
Link to the principle
Frank has a clear goal and little formal power to achieve it. What he has is knowledge of people. He knows whom he can persuade, whom he can buy, whom he can play off against whom and whom he has to force. The first season is essentially a sequence of these four means.

Persuading and giving

Situation
Frank pushes an education bill through Congress to make himself indispensable to the new administration. Along the way, he negotiates, flatters and argues. At the same time, he takes Congressman Peter Russo of Pennsylvania, who is struggling with addiction, under his wing. He makes Russo dependent on him and later steers his campaign for governor of Pennsylvania.
Link to the principle
Here sama and dana are at work. Frank persuades where arguments are enough. And he hands out favors where he needs dependence. His help for Russo is not kindness but an investment. Whoever receives something owes something.

Dividing

Situation
Frank uses his relationship with the young reporter Zoe Barnes to steer the coverage. He leaks information to her that damages his opponents. In this way he hastens the downfall of people who stand in his way and gets others to work against one another without being seen himself.
Link to the principle
This is bheda, division. Frank rarely fights in the open. He makes sure that others weaken one another. The means is powerful because it remains invisible. It is dangerous because it creates people who are in the know, above all Zoe.

Forcing

Situation
When Peter Russo becomes a danger to him after a relapse, Frank kills him himself and disguises the act as suicide. Later he also kills Zoe Barnes, who is getting too close to the truth. In the second season he becomes vice president, and by its end, president.
Link to the principle
This is danda in its most extreme form. The series takes a logic that the Arthashastra knows and pushes it to the extreme: every means creates accomplices and dependents, and each of them becomes a risk that demands new violence. If you use force without limits, you have to use it again and again.

What the series teaches about the order

Situation
Frank almost always starts with the gentle means. Only when persuading and giving are not enough, or when someone steps out of line, does he resort to division and force. The series runs for six seasons and 73 episodes in all.
Link to the principle
It is precisely because Frank keeps to the order that he seems so credible. But the series also makes visible what Kautilya’s teaching does not supply by itself: a measure. The four means tell you how to move people. They do not tell you to what end or how far. That question has to be answered by ethics, not by technique.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. Start with the gentle means; they are cheaper and last longer.
  2. Recognize when a gift is really meant to be a tie.
  3. If you divide in secret, you create people who know too much.
  4. Force without limits keeps demanding more force.
  5. The four means tell you how, not whether. That question stays with you.
Summary

“House of Cards” shows Frank Underwood reaching for power with all four means after a broken promise. He persuades, makes people dependent on him, plays them off against one another through the press and in the end does not shrink from murder. The series shows how effective the sequence is and, at the same time, how dangerous: without a moral limit, it leads into a spiral of force.

Sources
  • Michael Dobbs: House of Cards. London 1989.
  • Kautilya: Arthashastra. Translated by Rudrapatna Shamasastry. Bangalore: Government Press 1915.
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind the Four Means: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Series: House of Cards.