In Disney’s 1998 animated movie “Mulan,” a small band of Chinese soldiers faces a superior army. Mulan wins not through greater strength but because she sees what is hanging over the enemies’ heads: a wall of snow that needs only a push.
A large circle lies on a horizontal teal line; mist-blue dots push from the side, and it barely moves. Then the line tilts into a slope, a single dot gives a light push, the circle lights up in gold, rolls down and opens a gate at the bottom; in the final image gentle arcs lie there, with small circles kept ready beside them.
Principle #91
Potential of the Situation: If you recognize the dynamics of a situation and position yourself within them, you achieve with little force what could hardly be forced against the situation.
4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
Directed by Tony Bancroft and Barry Cook, the movie draws on an old Chinese ballad about a young woman who goes to war in her father’s place. The scene on the mountain is an invention of the movie. But it shows vividly what Sun Tzu means by the Potential of the Situation: the momentum comes not from your own arm but from the situation you cleverly set in motion.
Down in the valley stands a large army, up on the slope a wall of snow bears down, and a small gold push is enough – as in “Mulan.”
01
An army that is too small
Situation
The Huns under their leader Shan Yu invade China. The emperor has one man from every family conscripted. Mulan, the daughter of an old war veteran, cuts off her hair, takes her father’s armor and, disguised as a man, sets off in his place. In the training camp under Captain Li Shang, she painstakingly learns what a soldier needs to be able to do. When the troop follows the main army into the mountains, the soldiers find it destroyed by the Huns.
Link to the principle
By any calculation of forces, the situation is hopeless: a small, inexperienced troop against an army that has just wiped out another army. If you count only man against man, you have already lost. That is the starting point of the principle: if your own strength is not enough, you have to look for a force that lies within the situation.
02
Looking up
Situation
In a snowy mountain pass, Shan Yu attacks the troop with his army. Mulan grabs a rocket and aims not at Shan Yu but at the wall of snow on the slope. The explosion sets off an avalanche that buries the army of the Huns.
Link to the principle
Mulan does not ask how she can hit the enemy. She asks what force is already lying ready in this situation. The answer is hanging over everyone’s heads. A rocket against an army is nothing. A rocket against a wall of snow that is only waiting for a push is everything. That is Sun Tzu’s image of the stone on a steep slope in its purest form.
03
The force belongs to no one
Situation
The avalanche also puts Mulan’s own side in danger, and Shang owes his life to her. Mulan herself is badly wounded. When her wound is dressed, the others discover that she is a woman. By law, she ought to die. Shang spares her, a life for a life, but expels her from the army and leaves her behind.
Link to the principle
You don’t fully control a force you set off. The avalanche does not distinguish between friend and foe. If you use the potential of a situation, you have to consider beforehand where the movement will go and whom it will carry along. The movie shows this side honestly: her greatest success puts Mulan herself in danger.
04
A second slope in the city
Situation
Shan Yu and some of his warriors have survived and occupy the imperial palace. Mulan, who has noticed this, hurries to the city. Her comrades disguise themselves as women and get into the palace that way. Mulan lures Shan Yu onto the roof. In the end, with her help, the little dragon Mushu fires a large firework rocket that hurls Shan Yu into a tower full of fireworks.
Link to the principle
For the second time, Mulan works with what the situation offers: with her opponents’ expectations and with the fireworks of a festival day. She is not stronger than Shan Yu. She reads her surroundings better. That makes the difference.
05
What the movie simplifies
Situation
In the movie, a flash of inspiration in the direst need is enough. In Sun Tzu and in François Jullien’s interpretation, by contrast, the potential of the situation is usually the result of long groundwork: choosing the terrain, observing the situation, positioning your own forces so that victory follows as if by itself.
Link to the principle
The avalanche is a powerful image, but not a recipe. In real life, you rarely spot the wall of snow at the last moment. You find it because you looked beforehand.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Don’t just ask how strong you are; ask what is lying ready in the situation.
02
Aim at the point that sets off a larger movement.
03
Consider beforehand whom the movement you set off will sweep along.
04
Use the expectations of the other side as part of the terrain.
05
Keep watch before necessity forces you to.
Summary
In “Mulan,” a small band defeats a superior army because Mulan aims a single rocket not at the enemy but at the wall of snow above it. The avalanche shows what the potential of the situation means: the greatest force often lies not in you but in the situation. The movie also shows the downside, because the force that is set off puts Mulan’s own side in danger as well.