Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. Women’s Suffrage in Germany in 1918 and the Potential of the Situation

Example of the principlePotential of the Situation (#91)

Government & Politics

Women’s Suffrage in Germany in 1918 and the Potential of the Situation

For 70 years, women in Germany demand the right to vote, and for 70 years it is withheld. Then, in November 1918, the old order collapses, and within three days what had seemed out of reach is decided.

A large circle lies on a horizontal teal line; mist-blue dots push from the side, and it barely moves. Then the line tilts into a slope, a single dot gives a light push, the circle lights up in gold, rolls down and opens a gate at the bottom; in the final image gentle arcs lie there, with small circles kept ready beside them.
Principle #91

Potential of the Situation: If you recognize the dynamics of a situation and position yourself within them, you achieve with little force what could hardly be forced against the situation.

4 min read4 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

The Chinese strategist Sun Tzu describes efficacy with an image. A round stone on level ground does not move. The same stone on a steep slope rolls with great momentum. The force lies not only in the stone but in the situation. The French philosopher François Jullien calls this the Potential of the Situation. The history of women’s suffrage in Germany shows how long a stone can lie on level ground and how quickly it rolls once the slope appears.

Many small arrows run against a wall whose top is tipping over, and beside it a gold ballot drops into the ballot box – like women’s suffrage in 1918.
Many small arrows run against a wall whose top is tipping over, and beside it a gold ballot drops into the ballot box – like women’s suffrage in 1918.

A demand without a slope

Situation
In 1849, Louise Otto-Peters argues for women’s right to vote, among other places in her Frauen-Zeitung (Women’s Newspaper). In 1876, Hedwig Dohm makes the case for women’s suffrage in her essay “Der Frauen Natur und Recht” (Women’s Nature and Rights). In 1891, the Social Democratic Party (SPD), in which Clara Zetkin in particular campaigns for it, adds women’s suffrage to its platform. In 1902, women around Anita Augspurg and Lida Gustava Heymann found the German Association for Women’s Suffrage in Hamburg. But until 1908, laws on associations in several states of the German Empire make political work difficult for women, and shortly before 1914, the movement splits into three organizations in a dispute over the right course.
Link to the principle
The arguments are there, and so are the associations. What is missing is a situation that carries the demand. In the German Empire, every effort works against the slope. If you fight like this, you use up a great deal of strength for little movement. That is not a failure on the part of the women. It is the situation.

The ground begins to tilt

Situation
In the First World War, women on the “home front” carry the burden of supplies, work and families. In his Easter message of 1917, Emperor Wilhelm II holds out the prospect of electoral reform but does not mention women. In response, middle-class and Social Democratic women join forces in a broad alliance. In October 1918, they ask Reich Chancellor Prince Max of Baden for a meeting. It never takes place, because the old order is already falling apart.
Link to the principle
The women’s movement does not create this situation. War, hunger and defeat create it. But the women join forces at precisely the moment when the situation begins to tilt. That is the real strategic achievement: not building the slope but standing ready when it appears – and then speaking with one voice.

Three days in November

Situation
On November 9, 1918, the republic is proclaimed in Berlin. On November 12, 1918, the Council of the People’s Deputies, the new revolutionary government, announces in an appeal to the German people that from now on all elections are to be equal, secret, direct and universal, for men and women aged 20 and over. With this, Prussia’s three-class franchise also falls. Women now have the right to vote and to stand for election throughout Germany.
Link to the principle
What decades failed to achieve happens in three days. The arguments have not gotten any better. But a government that claims to speak for the people cannot exclude half of the people. The demand now points in the direction events are moving. It no longer has to be pushed uphill. It rolls.

Ready when the stone rolled

Situation
On January 19, 1919, women in Germany vote for the first time, in the election to the National Assembly. They can also be elected. Thirty-seven women take their seats, just under 10% of the members. Turnout is 83%, and women use their new right about as often as men. On February 19, 1919, Marie Juchacz becomes the first woman to speak in a German parliament.
Link to the principle
The potential of the situation does not mean waiting passively for the right moment. The women could use the situation only because they were prepared: with networks, with experienced speakers, with candidates who could run immediately. Seventy years of groundwork were the energy in the stone. The revolution was the slope. Only the two together produced the momentum.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. Check whether you are working against the situation or with it.
  2. In calm times, build up what you will need at the decisive moment.
  3. Join forces as soon as the situation begins to tilt.
  4. Don’t count on better arguments alone to move anything.
  5. Be ready for the breakthrough to come quickly when it comes.
Summary

Women’s suffrage in Germany was not won in a long debate but decided in three days. That was possible because two things came together: a movement that had been building arguments, associations and experience since 1849, and a revolution that swept away the old order. This shows the potential of the situation: the force lies in the situation, but only those who are prepared can use it.

Sources
  • Sun Tzu: Die Kunst des Krieges (in German). Edited by James Clavell. Munich: Droemer Knaur, 1988.
  • François Jullien: Über die Wirksamkeit (in German). Berlin: Merve, 1999 (French original: Traité de l’efficacité, Paris: Grasset, 1996).
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind the Potential of the Situation: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Women’s Suffrage in Germany in 1918 and the Potential of the Situation.