Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. Movie: Wag the Dog

Example of the principleStrategic Narrative (#55)

MediaGovernment & Politics

Movie: Wag the Dog

Shortly before the election, the U.S. president is caught up in a scandal. A crisis consultant and a Hollywood producer then invent a war that does not exist. The satire shows, in exaggerated form, how strongly a story about a situation can steer people’s actions.

A gold dot in the middle stands for an event, surrounded by many resting mist-blue dots. A line draws a frame with arrows around it, the dots align and stream to the left; the frame dissolves, another one forms, the crowd turns and streams to the right, and the gold dot remains unchanged.
Principle #55

Strategic Narrative: If you shape the story people use to interpret a situation, you help decide whom they blame, what they consider possible and what they do next.

3 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

“Wag the Dog” opened in U.S. theaters in December 1997. Barry Levinson directed, and Hilary Henkin and David Mamet wrote the screenplay, based on Larry Beinhart’s novel “American Hero.” Dustin Hoffman plays the producer Stanley Motss, Robert De Niro the crisis consultant Conrad Brean and Anne Heche the presidential aide Winifred Ames. The film is a satire. It exaggerates on purpose, and that is precisely why it shows the mechanics of the Strategic Narrative so clearly.

A small golden arc swings, and the large mass of dots beside it swings along – as in “Wag the Dog,” where an invented story steers.
A small golden arc swings, and the large mass of dots beside it swings along – as in “Wag the Dog,” where an invented story steers.

The situation: a scandal shortly before the election

Situation
Less than two weeks before the presidential election, the president is accused of sexually molesting an underage schoolgirl. The presidential aide Winifred Ames brings in Conrad Brean, a fixer for difficult cases. He does not want to refute the accusation. He wants nobody to talk about it anymore.
Link to the principle
Brean understands: the question is not what is true but what story people are telling right now. Whoever offers a stronger story pushes out the weaker one. Here the narrative becomes a substitute for an answer.

A war made of rumors

Situation
Brean decides to invent a war for the media to cover instead of the scandal. Albania is chosen as the enemy because the public knows next to nothing about the country. Soon the news is reporting a threat from Albanian terrorists. The scandal fades into the background.
Link to the principle
A narrative does not need proof to work. It needs an occasion that everyone talks about, and a role for everyone: the threat, the hero, the worried audience. The film shows how easily an interpretation takes hold where people know little.

Images that never existed

Situation
Brean brings in the Hollywood producer Stanley Motss. Motss stages the crisis like a movie. In the studio, fake footage of a frightened refugee girl is produced, along with a patriotic song. The president’s poll numbers rise.
Link to the principle
Strong narratives work with images and symbols, not with arguments. A single moving image carries more weight than any explanation. The film exaggerates, but the question remains relevant: who supplies the images you use to interpret a situation?

When reality gets in the way

Situation
When the CIA and the president’s opponent announce that the war is over, the media turn back to the scandal. Motss invents a sequel: an American soldier has been left behind enemy lines. A song and a campaign for his homecoming follow. But the man the military names for the role is a mentally ill prisoner, and the staging spins out of control.
Link to the principle
A false narrative has to be fed constantly. Every new twist requires the next one. A true narrative sustains itself; an invented one eats up energy and creates new risks.

The price of controlling the story

Situation
The plan works, and the president is reelected. But Motss wants to be publicly recognized as the author of the success. In doing so, he threatens the story he himself built. The film ends darkly: whoever endangers the story becomes a problem himself.
Link to the principle
The film shows the moral limit of the principle. A strategic narrative is powerful. Without truth, it becomes manipulation that turns people into extras. For leadership, this means: use the power of story, but tell only what is true.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. Ask not only what is true but also what story is being told right now.
  2. Pay attention to who supplies the images you use to interpret a situation.
  3. Where people know little, a story takes hold easily.
  4. Invented narratives have to be fed constantly; true ones sustain themselves.
  5. Use the power of story, but never against the truth.
Summary

Barry Levinson’s “Wag the Dog” tells how a crisis consultant and a producer invent a war to cover up a scandal. The satire shows the components of a strategic narrative: an occasion, roles, images, symbols. It also shows the price. An invented narrative has to be fed constantly and turns people into extras. The film is both a warning and an object lesson.

Sources
  • Wag the Dog. Directed by Barry Levinson. Screenplay: Hilary Henkin, David Mamet. U.S.: New Line Cinema 1997.
  • Larry Beinhart: American Hero. New York: Pantheon Books 1993.
  • Lawrence Freedman: Strategy: A History. New York: Oxford University Press 2013.
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind the Strategic Narrative: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Movie: Wag the Dog.