In 1962, the car rental company Avis is the perennial number two behind Hertz and is losing money. Instead of hiding the weakness, Avis talks about it openly and turns it into a promise: if you’re only number two, you try harder. Soon afterward, the company is back in the black.
A gold dot in the middle stands for an event, surrounded by many resting mist-blue dots. A line draws a frame with arrows around it, the dots align and stream to the left; the frame dissolves, another one forms, the crowd turns and streams to the right, and the gold dot remains unchanged.
Principle #55
Strategic Narrative: If you shape the story people use to interpret a situation, you help decide whom they blame, what they consider possible and what they do next.
3 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
Most companies tell you they are the best. In 1962, Avis did the opposite. The example shows that the Strategic Narrative does not dispute the facts; it interprets them. Avis changed not its situation but the story about that situation. We’re smaller became that’s why we’re better for you. And because this story was told inside the company as well, it held.
A golden dot stands on the lower step of a podium, with angles of effort rising from it – like Avis, the number two.
01
The number two is losing money
Situation
In the early 1960s, Hertz dominates the U.S. rental car market. Avis lags well behind. Hertz’s advertising radiates size, security and reliability. Attempts by Avis to present itself in the same style only underline that Avis is smaller. Avis has been losing money for years.
Link to the principle
If you play in the same story as the market leader, you lose. In the story size means quality, the number two can only ever be the second-best choice. What Avis needed was not better advertising within the old frame but a new frame.
02
The honest question
Situation
In 1962, Robert Townsend takes the helm at Avis. The company works with the New York agency Doyle Dane Bernbach (DDB), which had made its name with the “Think Small” campaign for Volkswagen. As the story is often told, while searching for a message, the team faces a simple question: why does anyone rent from you at all? The answer, in essence: because we try harder; we have to.
Link to the principle
A sound narrative begins with an honest diagnosis. It does not invent a strength; it finds the strength already contained in the situation. The answer “we have to” is not an excuse but a motive customers can understand.
03
Weakness turned into a promise
Situation
The ads say openly: Avis is only number two in rental cars. That’s why Avis tries harder. They promise very concrete things: clean ashtrays, full tanks, fast service, friendly staff. Hertz is not named, but everyone understands the comparison. The slogan “We try harder” is written by the copywriter Paula Green. Avis uses it for about 50 years, until a repositioning of the brand in 2012.
Link to the principle
The narrative turns the meaning of second place on its head. Suddenly size sounds like complacency, and second place like commitment. And the concrete promises make the story verifiable. That matters: a narrative that customers can experience at the rental counter earns trust.
04
Told on the inside
Situation
The message does not stay in the advertising. Avis also carries it into the company, for example with buttons for its employees. Townsend leads with a great deal of trust in his people and gives them responsibility. In this way, Avis connects the story for customers with the culture inside the company. Avis begins to turn a profit while Townsend is still in charge; his tenure ends in 1965.
Link to the principle
A strategic narrative is most effective when it tells the same story outside and inside. The employees at the counter became carriers of the promise. If you tell customers something your own people don’t believe, you produce disappointment.
05
The limit: the promise has to be true
Situation
The campaign highlighted concrete services, not abstract values. Any customer who got a dirty car from Avis would have refuted the story instantly. So its success depended on the company living up to the claim every day.
Link to the principle
This is where the difference from manipulation lies. A narrative can interpret a situation, but it cannot replace it in the long run. Good advertising for a bad product only makes customers notice sooner. Avis shows that a narrative is strong when it sharpens a true story.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Don’t play a part in your stronger competitor’s story.
02
Look for the strength already contained in your weakness.
03
Make your narrative verifiable, with concrete promises.
04
Tell the same story inside as outside.
05
Don’t mistake a good narrative for good performance. You need both.
Summary
In 1962, Avis was number two behind Hertz and was losing money. With Doyle Dane Bernbach, the company spoke openly about this situation and reframed it: if you’re number two, you try harder. Concrete promises made the story verifiable, and it was also told to the company’s own employees. Soon afterward, Avis was making a profit. The example shows a strategic narrative that does not lie but interprets, and holds precisely because of that.