The Barmen Theological Declaration and Freedom of Action
In May 1934, representatives of Protestant churches meeting in Barmen declare that the church is bound to Jesus Christ alone. With this one commitment, they secure a space that the Nazi state may not occupy.
A golden dot stands on a surface with four bright lines running from it, and opposite it is a teal dot with just as many; the teal dot offers a small shiny circle, the golden one takes it, and one of its lines goes out in mist-blue. The picture rewinds: this time all the golden lines stay bright, and the golden dot places short crossbars on the other’s lines until the other has only one path left, and the teal dot glides inevitably to where a golden frame awaits it.
Principle #40
Freedom of Action: Keep your own options open and narrow those of the other side, for if you can decide freely, you stay in control.
4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
Freedom of action sounds like having many options. Sometimes, though, it arises precisely from a clear commitment. If you know to whom you are bound, you can resist other claims. The Barmen Theological Declaration is an example of this. It also shows where the freedom gained in this way was used and where it was not.
A uniform grid fills the surface; only one round clearing stays free, held open by a golden line – like the Barmen Declaration.
01
A church in the state’s grip
Situation
After the Nazis come to power in 1933, the state tries to bring the Protestant churches into line. With Adolf Hitler’s support, the German Christians faith movement wins the church elections in July 1933. In September 1933, Ludwig Müller becomes Reich Bishop. The German Christians want to introduce an Aryan paragraph in the church as well. In the same month, Martin Niemöller founds the Pastors’ Emergency League as a countermovement.
Link to the principle
Step by step, the state restricts the church’s freedom of action: through elections, through its leadership, through its teaching. If you put up no resistance, in the end you lose the ability to decide anything for yourself at all.
02
The synod in Barmen
Situation
At the end of May 1934, representatives of Lutheran, Reformed and United churches gather in Wuppertal-Barmen for the first Confessing Synod. On May 31, the 138 delegates unanimously adopt a declaration with six theses. Its main authors are the theologian Karl Barth, together with Thomas Breit and Hans Asmussen.
Link to the principle
The synod acts before the state’s takeover of the church is complete. If you want to secure your freedom, you have to do it while you still have it. Unanimity gives the declaration weight, precisely because the churches involved disagreed about much else.
03
A commitment that sets free
Situation
The first thesis declares Jesus Christ to be the one Word of God to which the church is to listen. It rejects the teaching that the church could recognize other events, powers or figures alongside him as revelation. The second thesis states that there are no areas of life in which Christians belong to lords other than Christ.
Link to the principle
This is the core. By binding itself to Christ alone, the church withdraws from every other claim, including that of the state and its ideology. A single, clear commitment preserves freedom with regard to all others.
04
A limit for the state
Situation
The fourth thesis states that offices in the church do not establish the rule of some over others. It rejects leaders with powers of rule in the church. The fifth thesis acknowledges that the state has the task of providing for justice and peace. But it rejects the teaching that the state should become the total order of human life, and equally the idea that the church should itself take on the character of the state.
Link to the principle
Freedom of action has two sides. Your own freedom is secured, and the other side’s is limited. The declaration draws a line for the state: this far and no further. It denies the state’s claim to the whole of life.
05
What followed and what was missing
Situation
At the second Confessing Synod in Berlin-Dahlem in October 1934, the Confessing Church adopts an emergency church law and forms its own leadership. In doing so, it separates from the church governments of the German Christians. But the declaration mentions neither the Jews nor their persecution. Nor does it explicitly address the Aryan paragraph in the church, and public opposition to the Nazi state remains rare. In 1948, the Evangelical Church in Germany includes the declaration in its constitution.
Link to the principle
The declaration secured the church a space of its own in which to act. How it used that space is a second question. Freedom is a precondition for acting rightly; it does not replace it. The greatest gap concerned, of all people, those who most urgently needed protection.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Be clear about to whom you are bound; then you can resist other claims.
02
Secure your freedom while you still have it.
03
Draw a clear line where others want to occupy your space.
04
Use the freedom you gain for others too, not just for yourself.
05
Check honestly where your silence leaves a gap.
Summary
In 1934, the Nazi state threatened to take over the Protestant churches completely. The Confessing Synod in Barmen bound the church to Jesus Christ alone and drew a line for the state. In doing so, it secured a space for independent action and limited the regime’s total claim. The declaration shows the principle of Freedom of Action in both directions, and it shows its limit: freedom that has been secured carries the obligation to use it for the weakest as well.