In 1980, IBM urgently needs an operating system for its first personal computer. Microsoft supplies it, but keeps the right to sell the software to other manufacturers as well. This contract clause becomes the foundation of Microsoft’s rise.
A golden dot stands on a surface with four bright lines running from it, and opposite it is a teal dot with just as many; the teal dot offers a small shiny circle, the golden one takes it, and one of its lines goes out in mist-blue. The picture rewinds: this time all the golden lines stay bright, and the golden dot places short crossbars on the other’s lines until the other has only one path left, and the teal dot glides inevitably to where a golden frame awaits it.
Principle #40
Freedom of Action: Keep your own options open and narrow those of the other side, for if you can decide freely, you stay in control.
3 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
In negotiations, most people look at the price. Often more important is what a contract still allows you to do after you sign it – a question of Freedom of Action. The contract between IBM and the then small software company Microsoft is one of the best-known examples of this in business history. One partner won a big order; the other kept its freedom.
A golden building block sits in the wall of a large frame and connects outward to many small computers – like Microsoft at IBM.
01
IBM in a hurry
Situation
In the late 1970s, smaller companies such as Apple are successfully selling home computers. IBM, the world’s largest computer maker, wants to follow with a personal computer of its own, and quickly. For the operating system, IBM first talks to Digital Research, the maker of the widely used CP/M system. These talks fail; accounts of exactly how still differ today.
Link to the principle
If you are under time pressure, you easily give away room to maneuver. Above all, IBM wanted to get a product onto the market fast. The question of who would control the software in the long run took a back seat.
02
A purchased system
Situation
Microsoft, founded in 1975 and known for its BASIC programming language, has no operating system of its own. So in December 1980, the company acquires a license for the 86-DOS system from Seattle Computer Products, which the programmer Tim Paterson had developed in 1980. In July 1981, Microsoft buys all the rights to it. Figures for the amounts vary; most often, $25,000 is cited for the license and $50,000 for the purchase. 86-DOS becomes MS-DOS.
Link to the principle
Microsoft first secures ownership of the software. Only if you own the rights completely can you dispose of them freely later. The freedom in the contract with IBM depends on this first safeguard.
03
The decisive clause
Situation
In its contract with IBM, Microsoft reserves the right to sell the operating system to other manufacturers as well. In August 1981, IBM brings its PC onto the market with the system under the name PC DOS. Microsoft sells the same system under its own name as MS-DOS.
Link to the principle
This is freedom of action in the form of a contract. Microsoft does not tie itself exclusively to its biggest customer. It accepts the order without letting its future be blocked. IBM, by contrast, does not secure for itself alone the very software that makes its machine usable in the first place.
04
The market for clones
Situation
Other manufacturers begin building computers that are compatible with the IBM PC. Because they can license MS-DOS from Microsoft, the same programs run on their machines. Within a year, Microsoft licenses MS-DOS to more than 70 other companies. Compaq brings out its own version in 1983.
Link to the principle
With every new manufacturer, Microsoft’s room to maneuver grows, and IBM’s shrinks. IBM has set the standard but can no longer control it. Whoever owns the interface on which everyone else depends keeps the choice. Whoever builds just one machine among many loses it.
05
What followed
Situation
In the years that followed, Microsoft became the leading maker of software for personal computers. IBM lost its dominance of the PC market to the makers of compatible machines. Whether IBM underestimated the importance of the clause or deliberately bet on speed is judged in different ways.
Link to the principle
A contract is not just a deal for today but a decision about future room to maneuver. If you keep your options open, you can later respond to developments that nobody sees yet today. If you give them away, you have to rely on others not to use them.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
In every contract, pay attention to what it will still allow you to do later.
02
Secure the rights to what you sell.
03
Don’t tie yourself down exclusively if you don’t have to.
04
Don’t let time pressure push you into permanent concessions.
05
Ask who owns the interface on which everyone depends.
Summary
In 1980, IBM urgently needed an operating system. Microsoft bought an existing system, licensed it to IBM and kept the right to sell it to others as well. When clones of the IBM PC conquered the market, almost all of them ran MS-DOS. The contract shows the principle of Freedom of Action in its purest form: Microsoft kept its paths open, while IBM gave its own away.