Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. Benjamin Franklin, Silence Dogood and Worldly Wisdom

Example of the principleWorldly Wisdom (#87)

MediaFamily

Benjamin Franklin, Silence Dogood and Worldly Wisdom

In 1722, 16-year-old Benjamin Franklin wants to write for his brother’s newspaper, but his brother won’t let him. So he invents a widow named Silence Dogood and slips her letters under the print shop door at night. They are printed and praised.

Three circles carry small closed frames; across from them stand mist-blue circles. The first opens all its frames at once and is hemmed in by lines; the second opens a gold frame at the right moment, and a gate swings open; the third shows frames that are not what they seem, and the lines to it break off until it stands alone.
Principle #87

Worldly Wisdom: Never show everything, keep your options open and choose with care how you present yourself, without giving up your integrity.

4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

Benjamin Franklin was a printer, inventor, diplomat and one of the Founding Fathers of the United States. He owed his first publication to a mask. The story shows one side of the Worldly Wisdom that Baltasar Gracián describes: if you are wise, you choose how you present yourself so that your cause gets a hearing. But it also shows what happens when the mask slips.

At night, a golden letter slides through the gap under a door and finds its way onto a printed page – like Franklin’s Silence Dogood.
At night, a golden letter slides through the gap under a door and finds its way onto a printed page – like Franklin’s Silence Dogood.

An apprentice without a voice

Situation
Benjamin Franklin is an apprentice in the Boston print shop of his older brother, James Franklin. Since 1721, James has been publishing the newspaper The New-England Courant. Benjamin wants to write himself, but his brother rejects his pieces. To James, he is the little brother and apprentice, not an author.
Link to the principle
Benjamin’s problem is not the quality of his writing but his role. When people say something, they are often judged by who they are. Gracián advises taking into account the circumstances in which you appear. Benjamin realizes that under his own name he has no chance.

An invented widow

Situation
In 1722, Benjamin invents a character: Silence Dogood, a middle-aged widow. In the first letter, she tells her life story, from her father, who died at sea, to her marriage to a country minister. Benjamin disguises his handwriting and slips the letters under the print shop door at night. James and his friends read them, praise them and guess which educated man in town might be behind them.
Link to the principle
The mask removes the label “by the apprentice” from the writing. Suddenly, it is judged by its content. Franklin does not show who he is and gains a hearing precisely because of that. This is worldly wisdom in Gracián’s sense: deliberately shaping how you present yourself so that the cause can have its effect.

Fourteen letters

Situation
In 1722, a total of 14 Silence Dogood letters appear, roughly every two weeks. They poke fun at fashions such as the hoop petticoat, at vanity and hypocrisy and at the education offered at Harvard, and they argue for freedom of speech. Readers are delighted. Some men even propose marriage to the widow.
Link to the principle
The character allows Franklin to say things a boy could not have said. A widow may write about vanity and morals; an apprentice may not. The choice of mask is therefore not a game of hide-and-seek but a consideration of the position from which an idea will land best.

The mask slips

Situation
Eventually, it becomes known that Benjamin wrote the letters. His acquaintances begin to take him more seriously. His brother, by contrast, is annoyed. As Franklin later recalled, James feared that the success would make the boy vain. The tensions between the brothers grow. In 1723, Benjamin leaves his apprenticeship without permission and goes to Philadelphia.
Link to the principle
The mask achieved its goal, but it came at a price. If you leave others in the dark about your identity, you risk their trust when the truth comes out. That is especially true in a family. Worldly wisdom therefore has to take into account how others will react when they learn what you have concealed.

The later lesson

Situation
Franklin later uses many pseudonyms, most famously Richard Saunders, the supposed author of “Poor Richard’s Almanack,” which Franklin published starting in 1732. In his autobiography, he also describes how he got into the habit of presenting his own opinions modestly and avoiding words like “certainly” or “undoubtedly.” This, he says, won him more agreement and provoked less opposition.
Link to the principle
The mature Franklin has refined the lesson. He no longer needs a mask to be heard; he needs a tone that does not put others on the defensive. That is worldly wisdom without deception: not saying everything with full force but saying it in a way that gets through.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. How you are seen often helps decide whether people listen to you.
  2. Choose the role from which your idea will land best.
  3. Assume that a mask will slip at some point, and consider the consequences.
  4. In a family, concealment costs trust faster than anywhere else.
  5. State your opinion modestly, and it is more likely to be accepted.
Summary

In 1722, 16-year-old Benjamin Franklin invented the widow Silence Dogood because his brother would not print his writing. Behind the mask, his 14 letters were printed, praised and taken for the work of an educated man. When the truth came out, he gained respect and lost the peace with his brother. Later, he refined his worldly wisdom into a modest tone that persuaded without a mask.

Sources
  • Benjamin Franklin: Autobiography. Begun in 1771; first complete English edition 1868.
  • Baltasar Gracián: Handorakel und Kunst der Weltklugheit (in German). Huesca 1647, German translation by Arthur Schopenhauer.
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind Worldly Wisdom: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Benjamin Franklin, Silence Dogood and Worldly Wisdom.