From 1579 to 1581, Elizabeth I negotiates a marriage with Francis, Duke of Anjou. She leaves the question open as long as it serves her, and in this way keeps France as a partner against Spain without ever binding herself.
Three circles carry small closed frames; across from them stand mist-blue circles. The first opens all its frames at once and is hemmed in by lines; the second opens a gold frame at the right moment, and a gate swings open; the third shows frames that are not what they seem, and the lines to it break off until it stands alone.
Principle #87
Worldly Wisdom: Never show everything, keep your options open and choose with care how you present yourself, without giving up your integrity.
4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
In “The Art of Worldly Wisdom” of 1647, the Spanish Jesuit Baltasar Gracián advises not revealing your intentions completely and keeping matters in suspense. Hardly any ruler practiced this as masterfully as Elizabeth I of England. For decades, her marriage policy was a game with open options. The negotiations with the Duke of Anjou are the last and perhaps the most artful chapter of that game – a case of Worldly Wisdom at the highest level.
Between two dots hovers an open golden ring that never closes over a long timeline – like Elizabeth I and Anjou.
01
A queen without a husband
Situation
Elizabeth becomes queen in 1558. From the start, Parliament and her advisers press her to marry in order to secure an heir. Numerous suitors from all over Europe court her. Elizabeth rarely says a clear yes and rarely a clear no. Marriage plans become an instrument of foreign policy.
Link to the principle
An unmarried queen has something every married one loses: the prospect of a marriage. As long as the question is open, every European court has a reason to seek England’s favor. Elizabeth understands that an open option is often worth more than one that has been used.
02
The new suitor
Situation
In 1578, the French king Henry III puts forward his younger brother Francis, Duke of Anjou, as a suitor. He is 23, Elizabeth 45. In early 1579, Anjou sends his confidant Jean de Simier to London. In the summer of 1579, he visits Elizabeth himself. She seems genuinely to like him and calls him her “frog.” A French marriage promises an ally against Spain, influence on the war in the Netherlands and protection against plots in favor of Mary, Queen of Scots.
Link to the principle
Elizabeth shows affection without committing herself. Whether her feelings were genuine cannot be said with certainty even today. That is precisely part of worldly wisdom: others should not know exactly how far you will go.
03
Resistance at home
Situation
In England, marriage to a Catholic French prince is highly unpopular. Elizabeth’s secretary of state, Francis Walsingham, warns against it. In 1579, the lawyer John Stubbs publishes a pamphlet against the marriage. He is convicted, and his right hand is cut off. The poet Philip Sidney also writes to the queen against the marriage and has to leave court. The majority of the Privy Council advises against it.
Link to the principle
Elizabeth holds on to the negotiations, but she lets her advisers argue openly. The opponents later give her a reason not to marry; the negotiations give her a reason to keep France in good humor. The punishment of Stubbs shows the dark side: anyone who tries to pin the queen down in public disrupts her game.
04
Delay as policy
Situation
The negotiations drag on for two years. In the fall of 1581, Anjou comes to England a second time. According to contemporary reports, in November 1581 Elizabeth kisses him in front of witnesses, puts a ring on his finger and declares that she will marry him. Shortly afterward, she backs away again. In early 1582, Anjou travels to the Netherlands with English support to fight against Spain.
Link to the principle
Even the seemingly final yes remains reversible. Elizabeth gives enough to keep France in the game and little enough to keep England free. In the end, a French prince fights against Spain with English money, without England itself having to go to war or enter into a marriage.
05
What the game cost
Situation
Anjou’s campaign in the Netherlands fails in 1583. Elizabeth ends the engagement. In June 1584, Anjou dies at the age of 29. Elizabeth never marries. A poem attributed to her about the departure of “Monsieur,” usually taken to refer to Anjou, speaks of pain and hidden feelings. The question of succession remains open until her death in 1603.
Link to the principle
Worldly wisdom has a price. If you keep all your options open, some questions never get resolved. Elizabeth gained room to maneuver in foreign policy, but her country lived for decades with uncertainty about who would succeed her. And perhaps she also gave up something she really wanted.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
An open option can be worth more than one that has been used.
02
Show interest without committing yourself prematurely.
03
Don’t let others know exactly how far you will go.
04
Check which questions you never answer by keeping things open.
05
Holding off is a tool, not a permanent state.
Summary
From 1579 to 1581, Elizabeth I negotiated a marriage with the Duke of Anjou. She showed affection, even gave a promise of marriage and then took it back. In this way she kept France as a partner against Spain without binding herself. This matches Baltasar Gracián’s worldly wisdom: don’t show everything, keep matters in suspense, keep your options open. The price was a question of succession that remained unresolved until her death.
Baltasar Gracián: Oráculo manual y arte de prudencia. Huesca 1647. German translation by Arthur Schopenhauer: Handorakel und Kunst der Weltklugheit (in German), published 1862.
Back to the basics
Read what lies behind Worldly Wisdom: with explanation, animation, video and research.