Brownie Wise, the Tupperware Party and the Principles of Influence
Tupperware languished on department store shelves. Brownie Wise moved its sales into friends’ living rooms and, starting in 1951, turned liking and reciprocity into a sales system.
A dot stands in front of two gates; above it an empty frame slowly fills with small dots. Before it is full, six small shapes light up in a circle around the dot, and from each a line leads past the frame to the left gate; then everything runs backward, the dot stops, and the frame fills to the brim in gold.
Principle #83
Principles of Influence: People often decide not on the basis of arguments but on a few social shortcuts: reciprocity, consistency, social proof, liking, authority and scarcity.
4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
In his book “Influence,” the psychologist Robert B. Cialdini describes six shortcuts people use to make decisions in everyday life – the Principles of Influence. One of his best-known examples is the Tupperware party. He did not invent it. It was invented, or at least turned into a system, by a divorced woman from Miami who had previously worked as a secretary and advice columnist: Brownie Wise.
On the left, a shelf of dusty containers; on the right, nine dots sit in a circle around a table with a golden container – as with Brownie Wise and the Tupperware party.
01
A good product nobody buys
Situation
In the 1940s, the inventor Earl Tupper developed containers made of a new plastic with an airtight lid. In 1946, the first bowl, the Wonder Bowl, came onto the market for 39 cents, and in 1947 Tupper received a patent for the seal. But in department stores, the products sold poorly. Plastic was unfamiliar in the household, and a glance at the shelf did not tell you how the lid worked.
Link to the principle
The product was good, and the arguments were there. Still, hardly anyone bought it. This illustrates the starting point of the principles of influence: good reasons alone rarely move people. They need occasions, trust and role models.
02
Parties instead of shelves
Situation
In the late 1940s, Brownie Wise lived in Miami with her mother and her son and supported the family. She founded a sales business of her own called Patio Parties and recruited women who sold Tupperware at gatherings in private homes. According to Smithsonian Magazine, one woman sold more than 56 bowls in a single week in 1949.
Link to the principle
Wise moved the sale to a place where the strongest social forces are already at work: a friend’s living room. There, you don’t buy from a stranger but in a circle of people you like. Liking is one of Cialdini’s six principles, and here it is built into the structure.
03
The hostess system
Situation
In 1951, Earl Tupper made Brownie Wise vice president of marketing, an unusual position for a woman at the time. She ran the new division for selling at home parties. The pattern was always the same: a hostess invites friends to her home, a dealer demonstrates the products, there are games, and the hostess receives free merchandise as a thank-you. Part of the demonstration was to throw a sealed Wonder Bowl full of grape juice across the room to prove that it did not leak.
Link to the principle
Several principles interlock in this routine. Reciprocity: the guests have been invited, served refreshments and entertained, and many feel that buying something is an appropriate response. Liking: if you buy nothing, you let the hostess down. Social proof: when the first guests order, others follow. The grape juice demonstration replaces the argument with an experience.
04
Influence on the inside
Situation
Wise led not only customers but a network of saleswomen. She motivated them with rallies and awards for the top sellers. In 1954, Tupperware had sales of about $25 million, and the network comprised some 20,000 dealers, distributors and managers. Wise was the first woman to appear on the cover of Business Week magazine.
Link to the principle
The same forces worked on the inside. Public recognition makes success visible and creates social proof: if she can do it, so can I. If you commit to goals in front of others, you are more likely to stick to them. That is the principle of consistency.
05
The end and the legacy
Situation
Tupper and Wise clashed again and again over how the company should be run. In January 1958, Tupper and the board fired her. She had no formal employment contract and received a one-time payment equal to one year’s salary, about $30,000. Tupper sold the company in early 1958. Wise’s model, however, survived and became the template for many later direct-sales businesses.
Link to the principle
The story has a twist: Wise was a master at influencing customers and saleswomen, but she lost her influence over the one person who decided her position. The principles of influence do not work automatically. They have to be cultivated anew in every relationship.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Good arguments are rarely enough; create occasions where people experience something instead of just hearing about it.
02
Ask yourself in what setting your message arrives: on the shelf or in the living room.
03
Make other people’s successes visible so that they give courage.
04
Use reciprocity honestly: give first, without keeping score.
05
Don’t neglect your relationship with those who make decisions about you.
Summary
Tupperware sold poorly in department stores. Brownie Wise moved sales into friends’ living rooms and, starting in 1951, built a system in which liking, reciprocity, social proof and consistency worked together. Sales grew quickly, and the model became a template. Robert B. Cialdini later used the Tupperware party as a textbook example of the principles of influence.