In 1961, at Yale University, the psychologist Stanley Milgram has participants give a stranger what appear to be electric shocks. Almost two-thirds go all the way to the highest level because a man in a lab coat demands it.
A dot stands in front of two gates; above it an empty frame slowly fills with small dots. Before it is full, six small shapes light up in a circle around the dot, and from each a line leads past the frame to the left gate; then everything runs backward, the dot stops, and the frame fills to the brim in gold.
Principle #83
Principles of Influence: People often decide not on the basis of arguments but on a few social shortcuts: reciprocity, consistency, social proof, liking, authority and scarcity.
4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
Of the Principles of Influence that Robert B. Cialdini describes, authority is the most unsettling. His most important evidence for it is an experiment that remains one of the best known in psychology. It shows not only the power of authority but also how it interacts with other principles and how it can be broken.
Thirty switches with rising levels, almost all pressed; from above, a golden dot points to the next one – as in Stanley Milgram’s experiment.
01
The Eichmann question
Situation
In April 1961, the trial of Adolf Eichmann, one of the organizers of the Holocaust, began in Jerusalem. All over the world, people asked how ordinary people could take part in such crimes. About three months later, in the summer of 1961, the young psychologist Stanley Milgram began a series of experiments at Yale University. He wanted to know whether perfectly normal people would harm another person simply because an authority ordered them to.
Link to the principle
Milgram studied obedience not in dictatorships but in the everyday setting of a university. The authority had no weapon and no power to punish. It had only a lab coat, a title and a calm voice. That is exactly what makes the experiment so telling for the principle.
02
The setup
Situation
Men between the ages of 20 and 50 were recruited through newspaper ads, supposedly for a study on learning. Each participant became the “teacher,” and an actor played the “learner.” The teacher was to give an electric shock for every mistake and raise the voltage each time, up to the highest level of 450 volts. In reality, no current flowed; the learner’s reactions came from a tape. If a teacher wanted to stop, the experimenter urged him to continue, using a fixed sequence of four prods.
Link to the principle
Experts and students had previously estimated that hardly anyone would go all the way. The result: 26 of 40 men, or 65%, gave the highest shock. Many sweated, trembled and protested, and kept going anyway. Authority works even when conscience objects.
03
Small steps
Situation
The voltage rose in small increments. No single step was much bigger than the one before. Anyone who had continued at one level had little reason to stop at the next.
Link to the principle
Here a second principle is at work: consistency. Once you have said yes, you want to stay true to yourself. Stopping would mean admitting that the previous step was already wrong. In this way, authority draws people step by step further than they would ever have gone all at once. Many wrong turns in organizations follow this pattern.
04
What breaks obedience
Situation
Milgram varied the experiment many times and described 19 variations in his 1974 book. When the teachers had to press the learner’s hand onto a plate themselves, only 30% went all the way. When the experimenter gave his instructions only by telephone, the figure dropped to 21%. Another factor had the strongest effect: when two other “teachers,” who were in fact confederates, refused, only 4 of 40 participants continued to the end.
Link to the principle
Authority is strong, but it does not act alone. Social proof can cancel it out. As soon as others say no, saying no becomes possible. For leadership and community, this means: if you have the courage to be the first to object, you give others permission to do the same.
05
Criticism and limits
Situation
Milgram published the first results in 1963. The experiment sparked fierce debate. The participants were under great stress and, by today’s standards, were not adequately informed. According to Milgram’s own survey, 84% later said they were glad to have taken part. Later researchers have critically questioned parts of the procedure and the direct application to the Nazi era. The psychologist Gina Perry examined Milgram’s archive and concluded in 2012 that the published descriptions do not match the actual procedure in every respect.
Link to the principle
The experiment does not prove that people obey everywhere and always. It shows that under certain conditions, authority works much more strongly than we believe. Knowing these conditions is the best protection.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Don’t underestimate how powerful lab coats, titles and calm voices are.
02
Watch out for small steps that take you further than you wanted to go.
03
If you have authority, use it with an awareness of its effect.
04
Be the first to say no when something is wrong; others are often waiting for it.
05
Ask yourself: would I do this if nobody asked me to?
Summary
In experiments beginning in 1961, Stanley Milgram showed that 65% of his participants, on the instructions of an experimenter, gave a stranger what appeared to be the strongest electric shock. The experiment demonstrates the power of authority and shows how consistency draws people further step by step. But it also shows that social proof can break obedience: when others refuse, almost everyone refuses.