Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. The Hare Krishna Flower and the Principles of Influence

Example of the principlePrinciples of Influence (#83)

Faith & Religion

The Hare Krishna Flower and the Principles of Influence

In the 1970s, members of the Hare Krishna movement press a flower into the hands of travelers at U.S. airports and only then ask for a donation. The small gift creates a feeling of indebtedness that is stronger than people’s dislike of the movement.

A dot stands in front of two gates; above it an empty frame slowly fills with small dots. Before it is full, six small shapes light up in a circle around the dot, and from each a line leads past the frame to the left gate; then everything runs backward, the dot stops, and the frame fills to the brim in gold.
Principle #83

Principles of Influence: People often decide not on the basis of arguments but on a few social shortcuts: reciprocity, consistency, social proof, liking, authority and scarcity.

4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

Of the six Principles of Influence that Robert B. Cialdini describes, reciprocity is the oldest. If you receive something, you feel obliged to give something back. This rule holds communities together. But it can also be triggered deliberately. In his book “Influence,” Cialdini describes an example he observed himself, one that has appeared in almost every textbook on persuasion ever since.

From a stream of travelers, one dot stops with a golden flower in hand, and a coin travels back – like the Hare Krishna flower.
From a stream of travelers, one dot stops with a golden flower in hand, and a coin travels back – like the Hare Krishna flower.

A young movement needs money

Situation
The International Society for Krishna Consciousness was founded in New York in 1966 by A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada. Its members stood out with their saffron robes, shaved heads and public chanting of their mantra. In the 1970s, they collected donations in the United States at places with heavy foot traffic, especially airports. At the time, many travelers regarded the movement as strange or were hostile to it. What is described here concerns this fundraising practice, not the community as a whole.
Link to the principle
The starting position was difficult. A request for money from strangers you don’t like is normally refused. Liking and authority were completely absent. If money flowed nonetheless, another principle had to be at work.

First the flower, then the request

Situation
According to Cialdini’s account, the members approached travelers and gave them a gift: a flower, a book or one of the movement’s magazines. Anyone who tried to give it back was told it was a gift and they should keep it. Only then came the request for a donation.
Link to the principle
The order is decisive. The request comes not before the gift but after it. The gift was unsolicited, and yet it creates an obligation. That is the core of reciprocity: it does not require that you wanted the gift. It is enough that you accepted it.

Why it works even without liking

Situation
A 1971 experiment by the psychologist Dennis Regan shows why the method worked. A confederate of the experimenter bought some participants a drink without being asked and later asked them to buy raffle tickets from him. Without a gift, the number of tickets bought depended on how likable the confederate was. After the gift, liking no longer played a major role: those who had received something bought more tickets.
Link to the principle
Reciprocity is stronger than liking. That is why a movement that many travelers viewed with suspicion was able to raise money with a flower. The feeling of owing something overrides people’s dislike of the giver.

The flowers in the trash can

Situation
Cialdini describes a detail that lays the mechanism bare. Many travelers threw the flower into the nearest trash can shortly after the conversation. The members collected the discarded flowers and handed them out again.
Link to the principle
The gift had no value to those who received it. What worked was solely the obligation at the moment it was handed over. This is how you recognize a manipulative use of reciprocity: the gift does not serve the recipient but only the request that comes afterward.

The pushback

Situation
Over time, many travelers learned to avoid the members. Airports tried to restrict the fundraising. In 1988, the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey banned repetitive solicitation of money in the terminals of its three airports. In 1992, in International Society for Krishna Consciousness v. Lee, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that this ban was permissible. Handing out literature, on the other hand, could not be banned completely.
Link to the principle
A principle of influence loses its power as soon as people recognize it as a technique. Then reciprocity is no longer experienced as a gift but as a trap, and people avoid the giver. Short-term successes achieved through pressure cost trust and reputation in the long run.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. Keep in mind that a small gift can create a big obligation.
  2. Accept gifts, but weigh the request that follows on its own merits.
  3. Reciprocity works even without liking.
  4. Give in order to serve, not to trigger something in return.
  5. If you use influence as a trick, you lose it as soon as the trick is recognized.
Summary

In the 1970s, members of the Hare Krishna movement gave travelers at U.S. airports a flower and then asked for a donation. Although many rejected the movement, the method worked, because reciprocity is stronger than liking. Robert B. Cialdini made the example famous. It shows the power of the principle and its limit: once people see through it, they steer clear.

Sources
  • Robert B. Cialdini: Influence: How and Why People Agree to Things. New York: William Morrow 1984.
  • Dennis T. Regan: Effects of a Favor and Liking on Compliance. In: Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 7 (1971), pp. 627–639.
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind the Principles of Influence: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: The Hare Krishna Flower and the Principles of Influence.