In July 1870, Otto von Bismarck shortens a report from Bad Ems so that in France it comes across as an affront. France declares war and is cast as the aggressor. The pattern is an old one: you lure your opponent out of a secure position until they take the first step themselves.
From a grid of 36 small frames, one grows large: a dot rests safely on a steep arc and is lured out onto the open plain by a swinging line. Then a new arrangement of different shapes appears, a golden circle glides over it like a magnifying glass, and inside it the same pattern lights up in gold.
Principle #33
Art of Stratagems: Stratagems are proven patterns of cunning that work again and again because people react similarly in similar situations; if you know them, you can use them – and, above all, recognize them.
4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
In the Chinese collection of the Thirty-Six Stratagems there is one known in English as “Lure the tiger out of the mountain”; Harro von Senger’s German version has the tiger lured down from the mountain onto the plain. On its mountain, the tiger is almost impossible to beat. You have to get it to leave its protected position of its own accord. The Ems Dispatch can be read as an example of this pattern from European politics, and thus of the Art of Stratagems, even though Bismarck did not know the Chinese collection.
A long report made of lines is cut down until only a golden point remains – a dot leaves its safe position, as after the Ems Dispatch.
01
A dispute over a foreign throne
Situation
In June 1870, Prince Leopold of Hohenzollern-Sigmaringen, a relative of the Prussian king Wilhelm I, is offered the Spanish throne. He accepts. France feels encircled on two sides and protests vehemently. Under French pressure, his father, Karl Anton, announces his renunciation on his behalf on July 12, 1870. That could have been the end of the matter.
Link to the principle
At that moment, France had scored a diplomatic success. It stood on safe ground, on its own mountain, so to speak. An open attack by Prussia would have turned Europe against Prussia. If you wanted to achieve something in this situation, you had to get the other side to leave its safe ground by itself.
02
Bad Ems, July 13, 1870
Situation
King Wilhelm I is taking the cure at Bad Ems. On the promenade, the French ambassador, Vincent Benedetti, presses him with a new demand: the king is to give an assurance that no Hohenzollern will ever again be a candidate for the Spanish throne. Wilhelm politely declines and later has an adjutant tell Benedetti that he has nothing further to say to him. Heinrich Abeken of the Foreign Office telegraphs a report to Bismarck in Berlin and leaves it to him whether to publish the incident.
Link to the principle
The new demand was the mistake a stratagem needs. France wanted more than it had already won. Bismarck did not have to invent anything. He only had to seize the opportunity his opponent offered him.
03
The cut
Situation
Bismarck drastically shortens Abeken’s report for the press. The king’s explanations are dropped, so that the exchange seems curt and the refusal to the ambassador sounds like a snub. According to his later account in his memoirs, “Gedanken und Erinnerungen” (“Reflections and Reminiscences”), this happened over dinner with the minister of war, Albrecht von Roon, and the chief of the general staff, Helmuth von Moltke the Elder. The historian Michael Stürmer considers this scene a legend.
Link to the principle
A stratagem often works not through lies but through selection. Bismarck did not falsify a single fact. He left out what softened the tone. The effect arose in the mind of the recipient, who read the text according to his own expectations.
04
Publication and declaration of war
Situation
The pro-government Norddeutsche Allgemeine Zeitung prints the shortened version as a special edition that same day, July 13. In the French translation by the Havas agency, the German word “Adjutant” is carried over literally; in French, “adjudant” denotes a noncommissioned officer, which sharpens the insult. On July 19, 1870, France declares war on Prussia.
Link to the principle
The tiger has left the mountain. France is now cast as the aggressor. That was decisive, because since 1866 the southern German states of Bavaria, Württemberg and Baden had been bound to Prussia by offensive and defensive alliances that obliged them to come to its aid in the event of an attack. They sided with Prussia. In January 1871, the German Empire was founded.
05
What the stratagem does not explain
Situation
Historians warn against seeing the dispatch as the sole cause of the war. In their assessment, Emperor Napoleon III had already decided on war. At the same time, the French public knew nothing of the new demand before the publication, so Paris could have quietly accepted the refusal. Bismarck’s press release closed off that path.
Link to the principle
A stratagem rarely creates a will that is not already there. It steers an existing will in a direction that serves the one using the ruse. That is why stratagems work best against opponents whose pride or impatience you know.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Don’t move the other side by force; lure them with their own ambition.
02
Often it is enough to leave things out rather than invent them.
03
Those who attack first easily lose the support of bystanders.
04
When provoked, ask who benefits if you react.
05
A stratagem steers a will; it rarely creates one.
Summary
In July 1870, Otto von Bismarck exploited an excessive French demand. He shortened the report from Bad Ems so that in Paris it came across as a snub. France declared war and was cast as the aggressor, which brought the southern German states to Prussia’s side. The pattern matches the old stratagem of luring the tiger out of the mountain. It worked because the opponent wanted the conflict himself.