Gordon Moore, Moore’s Law and the Red Queen Effect
In 1965, the chemist Gordon Moore predicts that the number of components on a chip will double at regular intervals. His observation sets the cadence for an entire industry. Every manufacturer has to keep up, and if you miss a round, you fall behind.
Parallel teal lines run to the left like belts, each carrying a dot that runs to the right and yet stays in its place. A mist-blue dot stops and is carried out of the image; a gold one runs faster and slowly pushes ahead; finally all the belts stop briefly, and a small frame marks the pause.
Principle #90
Red Queen Effect: In competition, you hold your place only if you keep developing, because the others do too, and if you stand still, you fall behind.
3 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
In most industries, the market sets the pace. For decades, the semiconductor industry has had an explicit cadence that everyone refers to: Moore’s law. It is not a law of nature but an expectation that became an obligation. That makes it a textbook example of the Red Queen Effect.
Five fields of equal size, each divided twice as finely as the one before, the last one glowing gold – like Moore’s law, named after Gordon Moore.
01
A forecast in a trade journal
Situation
In the mid-1960s, Gordon Moore headed research at Fairchild Semiconductor in California. On April 19, 1965, his article “Cramming more components onto integrated circuits” appeared in the trade journal Electronics. In it, he observed that the number of components that could economically be placed on a chip had so far doubled roughly every year. He extrapolated this trend and arrived at around 65,000 components per chip for 1975.
Link to the principle
Moore described a pace that resulted from competition and technical progress. If you wanted to play in this industry, you had to run at this pace.
02
The forecast sets the cadence
Situation
In 1968, Moore founded the company Intel together with Robert Noyce. In 1975, he revised his prediction at a conference: from then on, the doubling would take place about every two years instead of every year. The engineer Carver Mead coined the name Moore’s law for it. In the decades that followed, the prediction became a self-fulfilling prophecy. The industry aligned its research and investment plans with it, and engineers had to deliver breakthroughs year after year to keep pace.
Link to the principle
Here the Red Queen Effect becomes an agreement. Everyone knows how fast the others will run. If you run more slowly, you are not standing still; you are measurably falling behind.
03
Falling out of step
Situation
The history of the industry is full of companies that fell behind at some point. A well-known recent example is Intel itself. In the 2010s, the transition to a new generation of manufacturing technology was delayed by years. In early 2021, the news agency AP reported that the following generation would not be ready until late 2022 or 2023 either, while the Taiwanese contract manufacturer TSMC was already using comparable processes. The company whose co-founder had described the cadence had itself fallen behind.
Link to the principle
Past success offers no protection. As with Leigh Van Valen’s animal groups, the risk does not decrease with age. A single missed round can cost a lead built up over decades.
04
Ever more expensive just to keep up
Situation
Every new generation of chips requires more elaborate factories and machines. The cost of a modern chip factory has risen sharply over the decades. As a result, the number of companies that can keep up at the leading edge of manufacturing technology has shrunk to very few.
Link to the principle
Over time, the Red Queen Effect does not get slower; it gets more expensive. Many drop out of the race not because they don’t want to run but because they can no longer pay the price of keeping up. Those who drop out look for other fields in which they can keep up again.
05
Not a law of nature
Situation
Moore himself never saw his prediction as a law of nature. For years, there has been debate about whether the physical limits of miniaturization are slowing the pace. Gordon Moore died in March 2023. The cadence he described still shapes the industry today, even as its form changes.
Link to the principle
The pace of the Red Queen Effect is not set by nature but by competitors and by what customers expect. As long as everyone is running, you have to run too.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Know the cadence of your industry and measure yourself against it.
02
Don’t rely on being in the lead. A missed round can cost you that position.
03
Be prepared for keeping up to get more expensive from round to round.
04
Decide deliberately which race you run in and which you don’t.
05
Question who sets the pace and whether it is really a law of nature.
Summary
In 1965, Gordon Moore described a regular doubling of the components on a chip. The observation set the cadence for an entire industry. Every manufacturer had to keep up, and even Intel, the company of the man the law is named after, fell behind when it missed a generation. Moore’s law shows the Red Queen Effect as an industry’s cadence: if you don’t keep running, you fall behind.