Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. Jaime Escalante, Garfield High and the Principle of Fear and Love

Example of the principleFear and Love (#49)

Education

Jaime Escalante, Garfield High and the Principle of Fear and Love

At a school in East Los Angeles that hardly anyone believes in, math teacher Jaime Escalante gets 18 students through the difficult calculus exam in 1982. His tool is a strictness that the students experience as a sign of respect, not as a threat.

A balance scale drawn in lines: in the left pan a soft mist-blue circle, in the right a teal frame, and in front, a golden dot leading a row of small dots. When only the circle lies on the scale, the golden dot wobbles and one dot in the row drifts away; when only the frame lies on it, the dots fade until the scale tips; at the end, circle and frame lie together in the middle, the scale stands still, and the dots gather behind the golden one.
Principle #49

Fear and Love: If you lead, you need a respect that holds even when affection wavers, and you must never become so harsh that respect turns into hatred.

4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

Niccolò Machiavelli thinks a leader should be loved and feared and, if he has to choose, feared rather than loved. In the classroom, that sounds wrong. Yet many people remember precisely the teachers who demanded a lot of them. Jaime Escalante is the best-known example of the Principle of Fear and Love in a classroom: of how high expectations and care together create an authority that holds.

On a blackboard, a curve rises above a shaded area, 18 dots climb up along it, and the top one glows golden – as with Jaime Escalante.
On a blackboard, a curve rises above a shaded area, 18 dots climb up along it, and the top one glows golden – as with Jaime Escalante.

A teacher who wanted to give up

Situation
Jaime Escalante is born in La Paz, Bolivia, in 1930 and teaches math and physics there for 12 years. In the United States, he has to start over: he learns English, works odd jobs and earns another degree. In 1974, he starts at Garfield High School, a school with many children from poor Mexican American families. The students’ prior knowledge is so weak that he almost immediately wants to go back to his old job. He stays because he finds 12 students who want to learn algebra.
Link to the principle
Escalante could have made himself popular by lowering the bar. He does the opposite. He treats his students as capable. That is the starting point of any authority that rests not on fear but on respect.

High expectations as an attitude

Situation
Escalante requires students to answer a question from their homework before they enter the room. He arrives early, stays late and pushes his classes to the limit. When an administrator demands that he simply let the students in, he objects that the school would then be doing nothing more than babysitting. At the same time, he explains to his students where math leads: to careers in engineering and computer science, to a front-row seat in college.
Link to the principle
Here both sides come together. The strictness can be felt, but it has a recognizable purpose, and that purpose is the students’ well-being. This creates what Machiavelli considers the ideal: people fear the high standard and love the one who sets it.

1982: The suspicion

Situation
In 1978, Escalante starts a course to prepare students for the Advanced Placement calculus exam. That year, two out of five pass; in 1981, 14 out of 15. In 1982, 18 pass. The testing service ETS considers the results suspicious because several students made the same mistake on one problem. Fourteen are asked to retake the exam. Twelve agree, and all of them score well enough for their results to be recognized.
Link to the principle
The students’ willingness to retake the exam, after weeks without classes, shows the bond. They don’t do it out of fear of Escalante. They do it because his standard has become their own. Respect that has been internalized holds even without supervision.

Growth with backing

Situation
In 1983, 30 of 33 students pass; in 1987, 83 pass the AB exam and 12 the more difficult BC exam. Principal Henry Gradillas backs Escalante and restructures the curriculum. In 1988, Jay Mathews’s book and the film “Stand and Deliver” come out. Escalante calls the film 90% truth and 10% drama. In reality, he stresses, the success took several years.
Link to the principle
Escalante’s authority was personal, but it needed a framework. As long as the school’s leadership backed him, he could enforce high standards. Strictness needs legitimacy from above; otherwise it is experienced as arbitrary.

When the person leaves

Situation
In 1987, Gradillas goes on sabbatical. Escalante’s program grows to more than 400 students, some classes have more than 50 students, and by 1990 Escalante loses his position as department chair. In 1991, he leaves Garfield; he himself names faculty politics and envy as the reasons. Within a few years, the number of successful calculus students there drops by more than 80%. Escalante dies in 2010.
Link to the principle
Machiavelli says that fear remains while love fades. Here a third truth emerges: authority that depends on one person leaves with that person. If you lead, you have to anchor your standards so that they live on without you.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. Believe in your people more than others do.
  2. Link every demand to a purpose they understand.
  3. Show through your own commitment that you ask nothing you don’t give yourself.
  4. Secure backing before you enforce high standards.
  5. Anchor your standards so that they outlast you.
Summary

At Garfield High, Jaime Escalante showed that strictness and care are not opposites. His students experienced the high expectations as respect for their abilities. That carried them all the way to the retaken exam. When he left, the program collapsed. Authority works when it combines the fear of failure with the certainty that someone believes in you.

Sources
  • Jay Mathews: Escalante: The Best Teacher in America. New York: Henry Holt 1988.
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind the Principle of Fear and Love: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Jaime Escalante, Garfield High and the Principle of Fear and Love.