Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Principles
  3. Fear and Love
49Principle · Group 7

Fear and Love

Feared or loved as a leader

“If you lead, you need a respect that holds even when affection wavers, and you must never become so harsh that respect turns into hatred.”

Affection is a good reason to follow someone, but not a reliable one.

A balance scale drawn in lines: in the left pan a soft mist-blue circle, in the right a teal frame, and in front, a golden dot leading a row of small dots. When only the circle lies on the scale, the golden dot wobbles and one dot in the row drifts away; when only the frame lies on it, the dots fade until the scale tips; at the end, circle and frame lie together in the middle, the scale stands still, and the dots gather behind the golden one.
In short

If you lead, you need a respect that holds even when affection wavers, and you must never become so harsh that respect turns into hatred.

What it’s about: Affection is a good reason to follow someone, but not a reliable one. When you make an unpopular decision, call a top performer to order or stop a project, you lose goodwill for a while. If your authority rests on goodwill alone, you also lose your ability to lead at that very moment. Respect, by contrast, grows out of predictability: rules apply to everyone, commitments are kept, limits are enforced.

In depth

The principle in detail

Three steps through the principle: grasp it, place it, put it to work. Open each topic on its own.

The core messageCore statement and 3 clarifications
In essence

Respect is more reliable than goodwill. It arises when your words have consequences and apply equally to everyone.

It does not say
That fear is a good leadership tool. People don’t need to be afraid of you; they need to know where they stand.
It does not say
That affection doesn’t matter. Having both is best; just don’t rely on affection alone.
It also says
Strictness that people experience as arbitrariness or exploitation destroys all authority.
The explanationThe limit is hatred.
  • The limit is hatred.
  • Strictness turns into hatred when it is arbitrary, when it serves the person who exercises it, or when it attacks people’s dignity, property or family.
  • A hated boss loses the best people first, then the loyalty of the rest.
The question

Do your words have consequences without anyone having to be afraid of you?

The signs3 signs when you heed it · 3 when you overlook it
When you heed it
  • Your rules apply to everyone, including the people you like.
  • You address conflicts calmly and without exposing anyone.
  • Your people know where they stand with you and still come to you with problems.
When you overlook it
  • You put off unpleasant conversations until nobody takes the rules seriously anymore.
  • Or you threaten, raise your voice and flaunt your power.
  • The best people leave first.
The backgroundFrom Niccolò Machiavelli’s book “The Prince” (written in 1513, printed in 1532), Chapter 17. · T4 Political Prudence
  1. 1513
    OriginNiccolò Machiavelli

    The Prince

  2. 1966
    SupplementedDiana Baumrind

    Effects of Authoritative Parental Control on Child Behavior

  3. 2008
    SupplementedAmy J. C. Cuddy, Susan T. Fiske and Peter Glick

    Warmth and Competence as Universal Dimensions of Social Perception

  4. Tradition T4
    TraditionPolitical Prudence

    Thucydides, Niccolò Machiavelli, Baltasar Gracián

    See the tradition on the Origin page
Read more: the full background

From Niccolò Machiavelli’s book “The Prince” (written in 1513, printed in 1532), Chapter 17. Supplemented by Diana Baumrind (1966) and by Amy J. C. Cuddy, Susan T. Fiske and Peter Glick (2008).

The research3 sources: 1 classic, 1 theory, 1 review · 1532–2008 · with limitations of the research
3 sources1532–2008 period1 classic1 theory1 review
Strength of evidence
  1. weak
  2. moderate
  3. strong

The combination of high demands and warmth is well documented in parenting research; its transfer to leadership and Machiavelli’s preference for fear have not been measured.

  1. 1532
    Classic
    Niccolò Machiavelli

    “The Prince” (in German), Chapter 17: being both loved and feared is best; otherwise fear is safer; the prince must at all costs avoid being hated.

  2. 1966
    Theory
    Diana Baumrind

    “Effects of Authoritative Parental Control on Child Behavior”: distinguishes permissive, authoritarian and authoritative parental control and argues for the authoritative kind.

  3. 2008
    Review
    Amy J. C. Cuddy, Susan T. Fiske and Peter Glick

    “Warmth and Competence as Universal Dimensions of Social Perception”: people judge others by warmth and competence, usually warmth first.

Where the research reaches its limits
  • Niccolò Machiavelli’s claim that fear is safer was made for princes in uncertain times, not for teams, families or churches.
  • Where people stay voluntarily, they can leave, and fear drives them away.
  • There, the principle applies only in its mild form: respect through reliability, not fear through threats.
  • The findings on the authoritative style come from parenting research, mostly from English-speaking countries.
Read more: what research shows

In Chapter 17 of “The Prince,” Niccolò Machiavelli asks whether it is better to be loved or feared. Being both is best; if that is not possible, fear is safer, because ties of gratitude break, while the fear of punishment never lets up. At the same time, the prince must avoid being hated, and to do so he must leave his citizens’ property and families alone. In 1966, Diana Baumrind distinguished between permissive, authoritarian and authoritative parental control; the authoritative style combines high demands with warmth, and later studies mostly associate it with the best outcomes for children. Amy J. C. Cuddy, Susan T. Fiske and Peter Glick describe warmth and competence as the two basic dimensions by which people judge others. What this supports is the combination of high expectations and warmth, not Machiavelli’s preference for fear.

The related principles46 Moral Forces · 47 Unity of Leaders and People · 53 Four Means · 54 Soft Power

To go deeper, see 53 Four Means (force as the last resort after persuasion and gifts) and 54 Soft Power (attraction as a form of affection that also works on a large scale)

47 Unity of Leaders and People shows what can grow on a foundation of reliable respect

46 Moral Forces counts respect and hatred among the forces that weigh more than material means

Read more: the full text

To go deeper, see 53 Four Means (force as the last resort after persuasion and gifts) and 54 Soft Power (attraction as a form of affection that also works on a large scale). 47 Unity of Leaders and People shows what can grow on a foundation of reliable respect; 46 Moral Forces counts respect and hatred among the forces that weigh more than material means.

The action steps5 action steps: Set a few rules that really matter to you, and enforce them equally for everyone.
  1. Set a few rules that really matter to you, and enforce them equally for everyone.

  2. Address violations early and in private: clear about the issue, respectful toward the person.
  3. Keep your commitments, including the inconvenient ones. Predictability earns more respect than strictness.
  4. Test every tough decision against three questions: Is it justified? Does it serve the cause rather than me? Does it leave the other person’s dignity intact?
  5. Show warmth without courting approval. Care and clear limits are not mutually exclusive.
The reflection questions3 questions: Which rule do you let slide for someone you like?
  1. Which rule do you let slide for someone you like?
  2. Which conversation are you putting off right now because you might lose someone’s affection?
  3. How would you notice that others experience your strictness as arbitrary?

Take your time with one question. Write down your answer – or talk it over with someone you trust.

To finish
The picture to rememberThe animation once more, with an explanation
  1. A balance scale drawn in lines: in the left pan a soft mist-blue circle, in the right a teal frame, and in front, a golden dot leading a row of small dots
  2. When only the circle lies on the scale, the golden dot wobbles and one dot in the row drifts away
  3. When only the frame lies on it, the dots fade until the scale tips
  4. At the end, circle and frame lie together in the middle, the scale stands still, and the dots gather behind the golden one
Strategy Check

Do your words have consequences?

Get your profile across all 12 groups in about 10 to 15 minutes.

Start the Strategy Check
In context

Group 7: People, Morale and Power

Guiding question: What moves people to go along or to resist?

Stage 4 of 5: Act with others

Where the 92 principles come from: eight traditions of strategy, from classical war theory to dealing with uncertainty.

More about the origin

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Examples

The principle in practice

From the different spheres of society.

FAQ

Questions about the Principle of Fear and Love

What does the Principle of Fear and Love say?

Leadership needs a respect that does not depend on people’s mood. Affection is welcome but unreliable. The limit is hatred: strictness must never become arbitrary or exploitative.

Where does the Principle of Fear and Love come from?

From Niccolò Machiavelli, in Chapter 17 of his book “The Prince,” written in 1513. He considers both ideal, fear safer and hatred the danger a prince must avoid at all costs.

What are some examples of the Principle of Fear and Love?

In 2003, Alex Ferguson sold David Beckham to preserve the manager’s authority. At Garfield High, Jaime Escalante combined high expectations with care.

How well is the Principle of Fear and Love supported by research?

Evidence: moderate – the combination of high demands and warmth is well documented in parenting research; its transfer to leadership and Machiavelli’s preference for fear have not been measured.

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Fear and Love.