Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. The Jazz Singer, Warner Bros. and the Principle of First Movers and Followers

Example of the principleFirst Movers and Followers (#78)

Arts, Entertainment & Sports

The Jazz Singer, Warner Bros. and the Principle of First Movers and Followers

In 1927, Warner Bros. releases “The Jazz Singer,” the first feature film with spoken dialogue, and becomes a major studio as a result. But its sound discs do not catch on: a few years later, the sound is on the film itself, using the technology of the followers.

A field of mist-blue dots: a gold dot is the first to draw a line through it, hits dead ends and sets small rings as markers; a teal dot follows the finished line without detours. Final image: two scale pans made of lines, on the left the first mover’s rings, on the right the detours saved, in balance.
Principle #78

First Movers and Followers: Those who come first can claim standards, names and customers, and those who come later can learn from the first mover’s mistakes; what matters is not the order but what you make of your position.

4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

The history of sound film shows that a pioneer can win and lose at the same time. Warner Bros. is the first to have the courage to bet on sound and reaps fame and growth for it. But the technical process it relies on is replaced by a better one that others develop. Here, first-mover advantage and first-mover disadvantage lie close together – an example of the Principle of First Movers and Followers.

On the left, a filmstrip with a separate sound disc; on the right, the gold soundtrack runs on the film itself – as with “The Jazz Singer” and Warner Bros.
On the left, a filmstrip with a separate sound disc; on the right, the gold soundtrack runs on the film itself – as with “The Jazz Singer” and Warner Bros.

The bet on sound

Situation
In the mid-1920s, Warner Bros. is a smaller studio. It buys the Vitaphone sound system, in which the sound is recorded on large phonograph discs and played in sync with the film. In 1926, Warner uses it to show “Don Juan,” with a score recorded by the New York Philharmonic. There is no spoken dialogue yet.
Link to the principle
The pioneer takes a risk the big players shy away from. The system is expensive, theaters have to be refitted, and no one knows whether audiences want sound.

The breakthrough

Situation
On October 6, 1927, “The Jazz Singer” premieres in New York, on the eve of the Jewish Day of Atonement, Yom Kippur. Alan Crosland directs, and Al Jolson plays the lead. There is synchronized singing in several musical numbers, but synchronized speech for only about two minutes. The rest of the dialogue appears on intertitles. Even so, it is considered the first feature-length film with spoken dialogue. Sam Warner, one of the brothers and the driving force behind the film, dies the day before the premiere.
Link to the principle
The film becomes the symbol of the beginning of the sound era. It becomes the biggest box-office success in Warner Bros. history up to that time, and in the following years the studio rises to become one of the major players in Hollywood. At the first Academy Awards, the film receives an honorary award. That is the classic advantage of the first mover: prestige, attention and a place in history.

The weaknesses of the disc

Situation
In everyday theater operation, the disc system shows its limits. Every reel of film needs its own disc; for “The Jazz Singer,” there are 15. A wrongly loaded disc or a damaged print throws picture and sound out of sync. Discs show audible wear after about 20 screenings and can break. They cannot be cut, which makes film editing harder. And they have to be shipped with every print.
Link to the principle
Pioneers commit to a technology early, often before the best solution is apparent. Lieberman and Montgomery name this as one of the risks of the first mover: technology and needs change, and the pioneer is stuck with its early choice.

The followers set the standard

Situation
Meanwhile, others are developing sound-on-film, in which the sound runs as a track directly on the filmstrip. Fox introduces its Movietone system in 1927, and RCA its Photophone in 1928. By 1928, the other major studios are also gearing up for sound film. The quality of sound-on-film quickly catches up. Warner Bros. and First National switch to sound-on-film as well. In mid-1931, the studio abandons recording on disc. After that, discs are pressed only for theaters that have not replaced their old equipment, in ever smaller numbers until 1937.
Link to the principle
The followers benefit from the fact that the pioneer opened the market and won over the audience. They no longer have to prove that sound film works, only that their technology is better. In the end, they set the standard, not the first mover.

Winning and losing at the same time

Situation
Warner Bros. loses the battle over the technology but wins the battle for its position in the market. The studio remains one of the major players in Hollywood.
Link to the principle
This is the most important lesson: the first-mover advantage does not depend on the first technology but on whether you switch in time when a better one comes along. Warner did, and kept its lead even though its disc disappeared.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. As a pioneer, you win attention, but not automatically the standard.
  2. Don’t tie yourself to your first technology; tie yourself to your customer.
  3. Switch in time when followers come up with a better solution.
  4. As a follower, take advantage of the fact that the pioneer has already won over the market.
  5. Check which weaknesses of the first mover become apparent only in everyday use.
Summary

In 1927, Warner Bros. took a chance on the first feature film with spoken dialogue, “The Jazz Singer,” and rose to become a major studio. But its Vitaphone disc system had weaknesses in synchronization, durability and editing. Followers such as Fox and RCA set the standard with sound-on-film. Warner switched by 1931 and kept its position. Being the pioneer brought fame; the followers set the standard.

Sources
  • Marvin B. Lieberman, David B. Montgomery: First-Mover Advantages. In: Strategic Management Journal 9 (1988).
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind the Principle of First Movers and Followers: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: The Jazz Singer, Warner Bros. and the Principle of First Movers and Followers.