Google, AltaVista and the Principle of First Movers and Followers
When Google is founded as a company in 1998, the web search market has already been divided up. AltaVista, Yahoo and others have long been there. Google comes late, learns from their wrong turns and overtakes them all.
A field of mist-blue dots: a gold dot is the first to draw a line through it, hits dead ends and sets small rings as markers; a teal dot follows the finished line without detours. Final image: two scale pans made of lines, on the left the first mover’s rings, on the right the detours saved, in balance.
Principle #78
First Movers and Followers: Those who come first can claim standards, names and customers, and those who come later can learn from the first mover’s mistakes; what matters is not the order but what you make of your position.
3 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
In business, the idea that the first one wins persists stubbornly. Web search shows the opposite. The pioneers proved that people want to search the web. But they also showed how to get it wrong. Google made use of both – an example of the Principle of First Movers and Followers.
Two tracks start early and lose themselves in loops; a third starts late and passes them as a straight gold line – like Google.
01
The pioneers
Situation
In the mid-1990s, the first major search services appear. Yahoo starts as a directory of websites. AltaVista, launched by the computer maker Digital Equipment, aims to index every page it can find. Then there are Excite, Lycos and Infoseek. In 1998, the leading names are portals such as Yahoo, Netscape and Excite, along with search engines that want to become portals themselves. AltaVista also supplies its search to Yahoo and Netscape and gets a large share of its queries from them.
Link to the principle
The pioneers have real advantages: name recognition, users, partnerships. They created the market. But they also bear the burden of having to find the direction first.
02
The portal detour
Situation
In 1998, the providers expand their sites into portals, with news, weather, email, shopping and ever more features. In October 1998, AltaVista adds answers from Ask Jeeves, filters and a photo search, among other things. Search itself becomes one offering among many. Many portals even hand their search over to outside providers.
Link to the principle
Pioneers commit to a model early, often before it is clear what customers really want. The portals bet on keeping users on their own site as long as possible. In doing so, they neglected why users had come in the first place: to find something.
03
The latecomer with a better idea
Situation
Larry Page and Sergey Brin, doctoral students at Stanford University, start a research project called BackRub in 1996. They rank pages by the links that point to them, a method they call PageRank. In April 1998, they present their work at a conference in Brisbane. In August 1998, they receive $100,000 from Andy Bechtolsheim, a co-founder of Sun Microsystems. On September 4, 1998, they found Google in a garage in Menlo Park.
Link to the principle
The follower no longer has to explain the market. It can concentrate on the problem the pioneers left unsolved. In 1998, Page and Brin write that search engines that merely match keywords return too many low-quality results. That is exactly where Google takes aim.
04
Plain instead of packed
Situation
Google’s home page stays almost empty: a logo, a search box, plain blue links as results. The simple design quickly wins loyal users. Later, Google even supplies the search results for Yahoo, until Yahoo ends the partnership in February 2004.
Link to the principle
The follower learns from the pioneers’ mistakes and deliberately does the opposite. Where others offer everything, Google offers one thing, but better. That is how it turns its late start into an advantage.
05
Even the business model came from others
Situation
In 2000, Google begins selling text ads tied to search terms, at first priced per thousand impressions. In 2002, Google switches to bids per click. The idea of auctioning ad space for search terms had previously been developed by GoTo.com, later renamed Overture. Overture sues for patent infringement. The dispute ends in 2004 with a settlement in which Google issues shares to Yahoo, by then Overture’s owner.
Link to the principle
Google also took the basic idea of its business model from a pioneer and developed it further. But the settlement also shows the limit: if you learn from pioneers, you have to respect their rights or pay for them.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Being early is not a victory, just a starting position.
02
As a follower, ask which problem the first movers left unsolved.
03
Learn from the pioneers’ wrong turns instead of repeating them.
04
Focusing on the core benefit beats an abundance of features.
05
If you adopt other people’s ideas, clarify the rights.
Summary
AltaVista, Yahoo and other pioneers created the web search market and in 1998 expanded it into overloaded portals. Google came late, with a better method for ranking pages and a plain home page. It learned from the pioneers’ mistakes and even adopted their advertising model. The follower became the market leader.