Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. Movie: Tucker: The Man and His Dream

Example of the principleFirst Movers and Followers (#78)

Business

Movie: Tucker: The Man and His Dream

After World War II, Preston Tucker wants to build the car of the future, with safety features the major manufacturers introduce only years later. He is acquitted, but his company goes under. The film shows why the pioneer with the better product does not automatically win.

A field of mist-blue dots: a gold dot is the first to draw a line through it, hits dead ends and sets small rings as markers; a teal dot follows the finished line without detours. Final image: two scale pans made of lines, on the left the first mover’s rings, on the right the detours saved, in balance.
Principle #78

First Movers and Followers: Those who come first can claim standards, names and customers, and those who come later can learn from the first mover’s mistakes; what matters is not the order but what you make of your position.

4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

“Tucker: The Man and His Dream” was released in 1988. Francis Ford Coppola directed it, and George Lucas was executive producer. Jeff Bridges plays Preston Tucker, and Martin Landau plays his financier Abe Karatz. The film tells a true story, sharpened for effect and with great sympathy for its hero – an example of the Principle of First Movers and Followers.

A streamlined car with a gold headlight in the middle of its front drives past large, dark factory blocks – as in “Tucker: The Man and His Dream.”
A streamlined car with a gold headlight in the middle of its front drives past large, dark factory blocks – as in “Tucker: The Man and His Dream.”

The dream of the car of the future

Situation
Preston Tucker, an engineer from Detroit, makes money during World War II with an armored vehicle and gun turrets for aircraft. When the war ends, he wants to build a completely new car, the Tucker Torpedo. He brings the designer Alex Tremulis and the financier Abe Karatz on board. Karatz raises money through a stock offering. Tucker takes over a huge former war plant in Chicago.
Link to the principle
Tucker is a typical pioneer. He does not want to build a better model of a familiar kind of car but something fundamentally new. For that, he needs capital, factories and suppliers – all things the established players already have.

Innovations ahead of their time

Situation
Tucker’s car is to have disc brakes, seat belts, a pop-out windshield, a padded dashboard and headlights that turn with the steering. The film shows the launch amid great public enthusiasm.
Link to the principle
The pioneer has the better ideas. Many of these innovations later prevail at the major manufacturers. But a good idea alone does not win market share. The followers can wait until it becomes clear what customers want and then build it with their own resources.

Resistance from within

Situation
While Tucker is on a promotional tour, his company’s board tries to take control. It has the car redesigned along more conventional lines and cuts safety and technical features. When Tucker returns, he learns that he no longer has any say and that the planned engine is no good. On the advice of Howard Hughes, played by Dean Stockwell, he buys a manufacturer of aircraft engines and converts a small, powerful helicopter engine. The prototype is built in his workshop and passes its tests.
Link to the principle
Pioneers often fight on two fronts. Not only is the market skeptical, so are their own backers. If you build something entirely new, you have to resist the urge to do it the way everyone else does after all.

The power of the incumbents

Situation
Then Tucker is accused of stock fraud. The film shows how Senator Homer Ferguson of Michigan, home of the major automakers, drives the investigation by the Securities and Exchange Commission. Karatz resigns because his earlier conviction for bank fraud could hurt the case. The press drags Tucker through the mud. How great the influence of the auto companies and the senator really was is disputed among historians.
Link to the principle
Incumbents have advantages that have nothing to do with the product: relationships, political influence, access to the media and suppliers. Lieberman and Montgomery name the first mover’s lead in resources as a source of its advantage. Here, that lead lies with the old players, not with the pioneer.

Acquittal and the end

Situation
In court, Tucker proves that production is running and has his finished cars driven up. He gives a speech about big corporations that stifle small inventors. The jury acquits him on all counts. Even so, the company goes bankrupt. At the end, the roughly 50 cars that were built drive through Chicago.
Link to the principle
Being proven right does not mean winning the market. The pioneer had the better car and the better argument. But he had too little time, money and backing to bring his idea to market.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. A better product alone does not win a market.
  2. Clarify early whether your backers really support your idea.
  3. Be prepared for opposition that has nothing to do with your product.
  4. As a pioneer, you need access to capital, suppliers and the public.
  5. Good ideas often prevail, just not always with their inventor.
Summary

“Tucker: The Man and His Dream” tells the story of Preston Tucker, who after the war wanted to build a car with disc brakes, seat belts and headlights that turned with the steering. Against him stood a distrustful board, a senator from Michigan and a hostile press. He was acquitted, but his company went bankrupt. The big players later adopted many of his ideas. The film shows the burdens of the pioneer and the power of the incumbents.

Sources
  • Marvin B. Lieberman, David B. Montgomery: First-Mover Advantages. In: Strategic Management Journal 9 (1988).
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind the Principle of First Movers and Followers: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Movie: Tucker: The Man and His Dream.