The Mothers of the Plaza de Mayo and the Principle “The Soft Overcomes the Hard”
Starting in 1977, mothers of disappeared children walk across the square in front of the presidential palace in Buenos Aires every Thursday, wearing white headscarves and carrying no weapons. The military junta can threaten them, abduct them and kill them. It cannot silence them.
A gold drop falls again and again onto a hard block of teal lines until an arch and finally a passage form in it. Then a rigid line breaks in the mist-blue storm, while a gold arc bends and straightens up again; in the final image an onrushing circle hits nothing, because the gold circle evades it and deflects it.
Principle #92
The Soft Overcomes the Hard: If you yield without giving up and stay persistent, you will in the end outlast what is rigid and hard.
4 min read4 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
The Tao Te Ching, the book that Chinese tradition traces back to Laozi, contains an idea that sounds naive at first: nothing in the world is softer than water, and yet nothing can match it when it comes to overcoming the hard. Water wins not by force but by endurance. The story of the Mothers of the Plaza de Mayo in Argentina shows what the principle “The Soft Overcomes the Hard” can look like under a dictatorship.
On a square in front of the palace, white dots circle around the center, round after round, until their track turns gold – like the Mothers of the Plaza de Mayo.
01
The hard regime
Situation
In March 1976, the Argentine military under Jorge Rafael Videla stages a coup. In the years that follow, thousands of people disappear: students, trade unionists, members of the opposition and many who are merely suspected. The military later admits to more than 9,000 missing; the mothers speak of around 30,000. The families learn nothing. Officials send them from one office to the next.
Link to the principle
Against such a regime, counterviolence has no chance. It has weapons, prisons and no inhibitions. If you attack it with hardness, you only hand it a pretext. That is why the principle does not ask how to become stronger but what such hardness cannot break.
02
Walking instead of standing
Situation
On April 30, 1977, Azucena Villaflor and about a dozen other mothers go to the Plaza de Mayo in front of the presidential palace, the Casa Rosada. Gatherings of more than three people are banned. So they do not stand still but walk, in pairs and arm in arm, as if out for a stroll. Soon they are coming every Thursday. In September 1977, on a pilgrimage to Luján, they wear their children’s diapers as headscarves. These become the white scarves bearing the names and birth dates of the disappeared.
Link to the principle
The form is soft in every respect: older women, slow walking, a scarf, a name. It is precisely this softness that makes them hard to attack. A regime that presents itself as the protector of family and order can hardly beat mothers in public for asking about their children. Like water, the mothers flow around the ban instead of running up against it.
03
The blow against the mothers
Situation
On December 10, 1977, Human Rights Day, the mothers publish a newspaper advertisement with the names of their disappeared children. That same night, Azucena Villaflor is abducted from her home in Avellaneda. In those days, the co-founders Esther Ballestrino and María Ponce de Bianco also disappear, as do the French nuns Alice Domon and Léonie Duquet. Villaflor is taken to the ESMA torture center and killed on one of the death flights, like others who were abducted. The naval officer Alfredo Astiz, whose unit carried out the abductions, is later sentenced to life in prison.
Link to the principle
Here we see both the limit and the power of the principle. Softness does not protect against violence. But the violence does not dissolve the movement. The mothers keep walking. What has no fixed form cannot be smashed by breaking off individual pieces.
04
Outlasting
Situation
The mothers come year after year. In December 1980, at the first “March of Resistance,” they walk around the square for 24 hours. In 1983, the military hands power to an elected government. In 1985, the Trial of the Juntas begins, and several senior officers are convicted. Starting in 1986, amnesty laws halt further proceedings. In 2003, Congress repeals them, and in 2005 the Supreme Court declares them unconstitutional. That same year, the remains of Azucena Villaflor are identified and buried in the Plaza de Mayo.
Link to the principle
The mothers did not overthrow the junta. Its end came above all through economic crisis and defeat in the Falklands War. But the mothers outlasted the junta, and without their persistent presence, the reckoning with the past would not have happened as it did. That is the effect of the soft: not a quick victory but holding out longer.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Don’t attack the hard where it is strongest.
02
Look for a form that is hard to smash because it is soft.
03
Get around bans instead of running up against them.
04
Count in years, not weeks.
05
Rely on repetition: what happens every Thursday cannot be overlooked.
Summary
The Mothers of the Plaza de Mayo had no power except their presence. They walked because standing was forbidden, wore white scarves instead of slogans and came back every Thursday, even after their founder had been murdered. The junta collapsed for other reasons, but the mothers outlasted it and, with their persistence, forced a reckoning with the past. This is what Laozi means: the soft wins not by force but by endurance.