Leipzig on October 9, 1989, and the Principle “The Soft Overcomes the Hard”
On the evening of October 9, 1989, around 70,000 people march around Leipzig’s ring road carrying candles and chanting “No violence” (“Keine Gewalt”). Around 8,000 security forces stand ready. They do not intervene, and the evening becomes the turning point of the Peaceful Revolution.
A gold drop falls again and again onto a hard block of teal lines until an arch and finally a passage form in it. Then a rigid line breaks in the mist-blue storm, while a gold arc bends and straightens up again; in the final image an onrushing circle hits nothing, because the gold circle evades it and deflects it.
Principle #92
The Soft Overcomes the Hard: If you yield without giving up and stay persistent, you will in the end outlast what is rigid and hard.
4 min read4 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
In the Tao Te Ching, Laozi describes an apparent contradiction: the living is soft and supple, the rigid hard and brittle. What can no longer bend breaks. In the fall of 1989, in East Germany (the GDR), a state with tanks, armed militias and a secret police faced a crowd holding nothing but candles. In the end, the state broke – an example of the principle “The Soft Overcomes the Hard.”
A broad stream of small lights moves along a wide arc, a gold one at the front, while the hard blocks at the edge stay where they are – like Leipzig in 1989.
01
A threat at gunpoint
Situation
Since September 1989, more and more people have been marching through Leipzig every Monday after the prayers for peace in St. Nicholas Church. On October 7, East Germany celebrates its 40th anniversary, and in Berlin and Leipzig, the police crack down hard on demonstrators. On October 6, the Leipziger Volkszeitung prints a letter from a commander of the factory militia: they would defend what had been achieved, if need be with weapons in hand. Before October 9, people are warned at their workplaces and in schools to stay away from the city center. Rumors of tanks and an order to shoot are going around.
Link to the principle
The state displays all its hardness. It relies on intimidation and on the expectation that violence will provoke counterviolence and so justify its intervention. Hardness needs a hard opponent in order to work.
02
Candles and prayers
Situation
On the afternoon of October 9, prayers for peace are held in four churches in the city center, including St. Nicholas Church. Afterward, people gather on Karl-Marx-Platz. Around 70,000 march around the ring road. Demonstrators carry candles, and at the end they place some on the steps of the Stasi district headquarters at the “Runde Ecke” (Round Corner). They chant “No violence!” and “We are the people!” (“Wir sind das Volk!”). Leipzig opposition groups have called for nonviolence, including toward the security forces.
Link to the principle
A candle is the opposite of a weapon. If you carry one, you need both hands to shield it from the wind, and you cannot throw a stone. The demonstrators deprive the state of the hard opponent it needs. They offer no resistance for its hardness to strike against. Like water, they flow around the positions.
03
An appeal from the heart of the city
Situation
On the same day, six people from Leipzig draw up an appeal for level-headedness and peaceful dialogue: the conductor Kurt Masur, the theologian Peter Zimmermann, the cabaret artist Bernd-Lutz Lange and three secretaries of the district leadership of the ruling Socialist Unity Party (SED), Kurt Meyer, Jochen Pommert and Roland Wötzel. It is read out in the churches and broadcast over the city’s public loudspeakers. No clear order comes from Berlin. Faced with the size of the crowd, the local leadership pulls back the security forces.
Link to the principle
Nonviolence opens up room for people on the other side. Where stones are flying, everyone has to choose a side. Where candles are burning, even party officials can call for level-headedness without being branded traitors. The soft splits the hard from within.
04
Images that cannot be stopped
Situation
Western journalists are not allowed into the city. The East Berlin civil rights activists Aram Radomski and Siegbert Schefke secretly film the march from the tower of the Reformed Church. Ulrich Schwarz, a correspondent for Der Spiegel, takes the tape to West Berlin that same evening. The next day, West German television shows the images, which are also seen in East Germany. In the weeks that follow, the demonstrations grow. On October 18, Erich Honecker resigns; on November 9, the Wall falls.
Link to the principle
The images show not rioting but candles. That means the state cannot present them as an attack. After October 9, it has the choice between violence against peaceful people before the eyes of the world and retreat. Hardness no longer has any form in which it can take effect.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Don’t give a hard opponent the pretext it is looking for.
02
Hold yourself to nonviolence, even under pressure.
03
Leave people on the other side a way to join you.
04
Make sure that others see what is happening.
05
Trust that persistence works, even when the outcome is uncertain.
Summary
On October 9, 1989, in Leipzig, an armed state faced a crowd carrying candles. The demonstrators denied it the hard opponent it needed and gave people on its side room for level-headedness. The security forces pulled back, the images went around the world, and a month later the Wall fell. This shows what Laozi means: the rigid breaks; the supple endures.