In January 1865, the American Civil War is almost won. “Lincoln” (2012) shows why Abraham Lincoln wants to get the 13th Amendment through the House of Representatives before peace comes: the victory is to leave behind a state in which slavery cannot return.
Two circles pull on a line above a chasm; the left one wins, the right one falls in, and mist-blue dots gather above the chasm into a dark cloud. The image rewinds, and again the left circle wins, but this time a golden line pulls the right one out, together they lay a golden arch across the chasm, and the cloud dissolves.
Principle #3
Better End State: A victory is a success only if the situation afterward is better than before; if you look only at winning, you often lose the peace.
3 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
Steven Spielberg’s film is based on a screenplay by Tony Kushner, who drew loosely on the book “Team of Rivals” by the historian Doris Kearns Goodwin. It tells the story of the last four months of Lincoln’s life. Daniel Day-Lewis plays Lincoln, Sally Field his wife, Mary Todd Lincoln, David Strathairn Secretary of State William H. Seward, and Tommy Lee Jones Congressman Thaddeus Stevens. The historian Eric Foner has objected that the film exaggerates how realistic an end to the war with slavery intact was in early 1865 and ignores the petition movement from which the amendment originated. Even so, the film is an example of the Better End State.
In a semicircle of seat dots, a golden arc closes over two-thirds of the rows – as in “Lincoln” with the 13th Amendment.
01
A victory that could come too soon
Situation
In January 1865, Lincoln expects the Union to win soon. His Emancipation Proclamation of 1863 was a war measure. He fears that courts could declare it invalid after the war and that the returning Southern states could block a constitutional amendment against slavery. That is why he wants the amendment passed while the war is still going on.
Link to the principle
Lincoln asks not only how the war will be won but what will remain afterward. A peace without the amendment would have ended the fighting but left the cause of the war unresolved.
02
Winning votes
Situation
The Senate has already passed the amendment, but the House lacks the necessary two-thirds majority. Lincoln and Seward target Democratic congressmen who lost their seats in the 1864 election and will remain in office only until March. Hired intermediaries offer them federal jobs. The Radical Republicans press impatiently.
Link to the principle
The means are not glorious: jobs for votes. The film shows this openly. It makes clear that Lincoln subordinates them to the end state, and it leaves viewers to judge for themselves whether the purpose justifies them.
03
Peace at the door
Situation
The influential politician Francis Preston Blair urges Lincoln to hold peace talks with the Southern states, and Lincoln reluctantly agrees. But the Confederate envoys have to wait outside Washington until the vote has taken place. When rumors arise, Lincoln declares that there are no negotiators in the city.
Link to the principle
Here the tension becomes visible. An earlier peace would have saved lives. Lincoln holds it up briefly to secure a better peace. The film shows this trade-off without resolving it.
04
Equality before the law
Situation
Thaddeus Stevens believes in the full equality of all people. In the debate, he holds back and declares that the amendment means equality before the law and nothing more, so as not to scare off moderate congressmen. On January 31, 1865, the amendment passes with two votes more than the required majority.
Link to the principle
If you want a better end state, you sometimes have to secure the attainable part and fight for the rest later. Stevens subordinates his larger goal to a lasting step.
05
After the victory
Situation
Lincoln meets the envoys and tells them that slavery cannot be restored. The talks fail, and the war goes on until General Robert E. Lee surrenders at Appomattox on April 9, 1865. On April 14, Lincoln is shot at Ford’s Theatre and dies the next morning. The film ends with a flashback to his second inaugural address, in which he calls for finishing the work “with malice toward none, with charity for all” and for binding up the nation’s wounds.
Link to the principle
The film shows both halves of the better end state: the legal half, the end of slavery, and the human half, reconciliation without revenge. Lincoln himself does not live to see the peace.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Before the victory, ask what should remain afterward.
02
Secure what matters most while you still have the leverage.
03
Examine carefully which means the better state justifies.
04
Be content with the attainable step if it is a lasting one.
05
Think of both: reliable rules and reconciliation.
Summary
“Lincoln” tells how Abraham Lincoln pushes through the 13th Amendment shortly before the end of the Civil War. He could have had peace sooner, but he wanted a peace after which slavery could not return. To get it, he used uncomfortable means and held up negotiations. The film shows the principle of the Better End State with all its tensions: a victory is worth only as much as the state it leaves behind.
Lincoln, U.S. 2012, directed by Steven Spielberg, screenplay by Tony Kushner, starring Daniel Day-Lewis, Sally Field, David Strathairn and Tommy Lee Jones.
Doris Kearns Goodwin: Team of Rivals: The Political Genius of Abraham Lincoln. New York: Simon & Schuster 2005.
Abraham Lincoln: Second Inaugural Address, March 4, 1865.
Back to the basics
Read what lies behind the Better End State: with explanation, animation, video and research.