Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. Movie: Moneyball

Example of the principleKernel of Good Strategy (#4)

Arts, Entertainment & SportsBusiness

Movie: Moneyball

A baseball general manager with one of the smallest budgets in the league loses his best players. “Moneyball” (2011) shows how, instead of trying to replace them, he asks anew what actually wins games.

A tangle of lines and dots in teal and mist-blue fills the picture; a circle moves across it like a magnifying glass and uncovers a single golden dot. From it grows a golden line that sets a direction, lines that do not point that way fade, and three circles mesh like gears and turn together.
Principle #4

Kernel of Good Strategy: Good strategy consists of an honest diagnosis, a guiding policy and coherent actions – not of goals and slogans.

3 min read4 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

Bennett Miller’s film is based on Michael Lewis’s book about the 2002 season of the Oakland Athletics. Brad Pitt plays general manager Billy Beane, and Jonah Hill plays his assistant Peter Brand, a fictional character modeled on the real Paul DePodesta. The film sharpens the events: the team’s strong pitchers, who were found through classic scouting, barely appear, and the manager at the time, Art Howe, has criticized how he is portrayed. Still, the film is an example of the Kernel of Good Strategy.

Next to a baseball diamond, a few players are picked from a grid of dots, and the path to first base glows gold – as in “Moneyball.”
Next to a baseball diamond, a few players are picked from a grid of dots, and the path to first base glows gold – as in “Moneyball.”

The starting position: poor and plundered

Situation
After being knocked out of the 2001 playoffs, the Athletics lose three of their best-known players, including Jason Giambi and Johnny Damon, to richer clubs. Beane is supposed to replace them with a payroll of about $41 million, roughly a third of the New York Yankees’. His scouts want to carry on as before: look for talent that looks like a star.
Link to the principle
The film begins with a goal that cannot be reached that way: replace the stars. Beane realizes that he first has to understand why his club will always lose as long as it plays the rich teams’ game.

The diagnosis: the market misprices players

Situation
Peter Brand shows Beane that the league pays players by the wrong yardstick. It pays for looks, power and reputation. What actually wins games is runs, and one thing that matters for scoring them is how often a player gets on base. That is exactly what is cheap on the market.
Link to the principle
This is a diagnosis in the best sense. It explains why the club is losing and at the same time shows where there is an opportunity the rich teams overlook.

The guiding policy: buy runs, not stars

Situation
Beane gives up the search for replacement stars. Instead, he signs players whom others have discarded because they are old, injured or unconventional, but who deliver exactly what produces runs. The scouts protest, and manager Art Howe does not stick to Beane’s lineup.
Link to the principle
The guiding policy is simple and rules out a great deal. It gives every decision a direction, from trades to the lineup.

Actions that have to fit together

Situation
The season starts badly. Only when Beane also imposes his lineup, by trading away players whom the manager uses against his wishes, does the system take hold. The Athletics win 20 games in a row, an American League record. In the playoffs, however, they are again eliminated in the first round.
Link to the principle
The film shows exactly what happens when actions do not fit together: the right guiding policy is of little use as long as scouting, roster and lineup pull in different directions.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. If you play the stronger side’s game, you lose. Ask which game you can win.
  2. Look for what the market misprices.
  3. Make your guiding policy so clear that every decision can be tested against it.
  4. Expect resistance from those who succeeded by the old standards.
  5. A strategy works only when all its parts point in the same direction.
Summary

“Moneyball” tells how Billy Beane turns a hopeless situation into a strategy: he diagnoses that the market misprices players, chooses the guiding policy of buying runs instead of stars and has to learn that this idea works only when roster, lineup and team move in the same direction.

Sources
  • Moneyball, U.S. 2011, directed by Bennett Miller, starring Brad Pitt and Jonah Hill.
  • Michael Lewis: Moneyball: The Art of Winning an Unfair Game. New York: W. W. Norton 2003.
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind the Kernel of Good Strategy: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Movie: Moneyball.