The principle in detail
Three steps through the principle: grasp it, place it, put it to work. Open each topic on its own.
The core messageCore statement and 3 clarifications
Good strategy has three parts, namely a diagnosis, a guiding policy and coherent actions.
- It does not say
- That an ambitious goal is already a strategy. It feels like leadership but says nothing about how to get there.
- It does not say
- That a well-built strategy is right. Even a careful diagnosis can be wrong.
- It also says
- A guiding policy that rules nothing out does not guide.
The explanation“Our revenue is too low” is not a diagnosis but a symptom.
“Our revenue is too low” is not a diagnosis but a symptom.
“We are spreading ourselves across too many products, none of which stands out” is one.
- A good guiding policy rules out a great deal, and that is precisely where its power lies: everyone who acts can test their decisions against it.
- Twenty good ideas side by side do not yet make a strategy.
- Impact arises only when the steps interlock.
What is actually going on in your situation, and what follows from it?
The signs3 signs when you heed it · 3 when you overlook it
- You can name the real problem in one sentence, even if that sentence is uncomfortable.
- Your team knows what it says no to.
- New initiatives are tested for whether they fit with the ones already underway.
- The strategy consists of target figures and buzzwords.
- Nobody says why things haven’t worked so far.
- Many initiatives run side by side and pull in different directions.
The backgroundFrom Richard P. Rumelt’s book “Good Strategy/Bad Strategy” (2011). · T6 Business Strategy
- 2011OriginRichard P. Rumelt
Good Strategy/Bad Strategy
- 2022Developed furtherRichard P. Rumelt
The Crux
- Tradition T6TraditionBusiness Strategy
Michael E. Porter, Richard P. Rumelt, Henry Mintzberg, Clayton M. Christensen, W. Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne
See the tradition on the Origin page
Read more: the full background
From Richard P. Rumelt’s book “Good Strategy/Bad Strategy” (2011). Developed further in his book “The Crux” (2022).
The research3 sources: 3 theories · 2011–2022 · with limitations of the research
- weak
- moderate
- strong
An influential model based on case examples and consulting experience whose effect has not been tested statistically.
- 2011Richard P. Rumelt
“Good Strategy/Bad Strategy”: diagnosis, guiding policy and coherent actions form the kernel of good strategy; examples range from the 1991 Gulf War and Apple in 1997 to the chipmaker Nvidia.
- 2011Richard P. Rumelt
“The perils of bad strategy” (McKinsey Quarterly): the three parts of the kernel and four hallmarks of bad strategy, namely fluff, failure to face the challenge, mistaking goals for strategy and bad strategic objectives.
- 2022Richard P. Rumelt
“The Crux”: puts even more emphasis on diagnosing the critical difficulty.
- The model says how a strategy must be built, not whether it is right.
- The case examples were chosen in hindsight; failed strategies with the same structure appear less often.
- In very unclear, fast-changing situations, strategy often emerges only through action (80 Emergent Strategy).
- And the model does not ask whether the objective and the means are ethically justifiable.
Read more: what research shows
In “Good Strategy/Bad Strategy” (2011), Richard P. Rumelt, a professor of strategy at the University of California, Los Angeles, identifies three parts as the kernel of every good strategy: a diagnosis that names the few critical aspects of a situation, a guiding policy for dealing with the obstacles and coherent actions that support that policy. That same year, he summarized this in McKinsey Quarterly and described the hallmarks of bad strategy: fluff, the failure to face the challenge, mistaking goals for strategy and bad strategic objectives. In 2022, he developed the idea further in “The Crux.” The model was developed from case examples and consulting experience, not from statistical studies.
The related principles02 Principle of the Objective · 05 Power of Proximate Objectives · 06 Center of Gravity · 24 Simplicity
The principle says how you get to where 02 Principle of the Objective points
05 Power of Proximate Objectives comes from the same work and translates the guiding policy into attainable steps
06 Center of Gravity uses a good diagnosis to find the point on which everything depends
24 Simplicity shows that a guiding policy works only if everyone can understand it and pass it on
Read more: the full text
The principle says how you get to where 02 Principle of the Objective points; 05 Power of Proximate Objectives comes from the same work and translates the guiding policy into attainable steps, 06 Center of Gravity uses a good diagnosis to find the point on which everything depends, and 24 Simplicity shows that a guiding policy works only if everyone can understand it and pass it on.
The action steps5 things you can actually do
Write down the real problem in your area in one sentence and check whether you are describing a symptom or a cause.
Formulate a guiding policy that says how you will deal with the problem, and write down what it rules out.
Cut actions that do not fit the guiding policy, even if they are good in themselves.
- For each remaining action, check which other action supports it. Where none does, ask why.
- Read your strategy as an outsider would: Does it contain a diagnosis, a guiding policy and actions, or only goals and slogans?
The reflection questions3 questions: What is the real problem in your area in one sentence, and is it a cause or a symptom?
- What is the real problem in your area in one sentence, and is it a cause or a symptom?
- What does your guiding policy say no to?
- Which of your current actions is not supported by any other?
Take your time with one question. Write down your answer – or talk it over with someone you trust.
The picture to rememberThe animation once more, with an explanation
- A tangle of lines and dots in teal and mist-blue fills the picture
- A circle moves across it like a magnifying glass and uncovers a single golden dot
- From it grows a golden line that sets a direction, lines that do not point that way fade, and three circles mesh like gears and turn together
How the principle shows up in practice
Apple, 1997
Steve Jobs diagnoses a scattered product lineup, bets on four quadrants with one product each and aligns the company accordingly. Richard P. Rumelt discusses the example in the first part of his book.
The Salt March, 1930
Mohandas Gandhi recognizes that British rule depends on the cooperation of Indians and chooses the salt tax, which affects everyone, as the lever for nonviolent disobedience.
Desert Storm, 1991
The coalition identifies a defense facing south, pins down the Iraqi front and goes around it far to the west. Richard P. Rumelt also discusses this campaign in the first part of his book.
What is actually going on in your situation?
Get your profile across all 12 groups in about 10 to 15 minutes.
Start the Strategy CheckGroup 1: Purpose and Objective
Guiding question: What are you fighting for, and what should be left standing at the end?
Stage 1 of 5: Clarify
- TraditionBusiness Strategy
Michael E. Porter, Richard P. Rumelt, Henry Mintzberg, Clayton M. Christensen, W. Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne
Where the 92 principles come from: eight traditions of strategy, from classical war theory to dealing with uncertainty.
More about the originBackground: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin