The 1970 film portrays General George S. Patton as a commander for whom movement is everything. His thrusts go around the enemy instead of hitting it head-on, and his willfulness also shows what a maneuver depends on.
Two blocks of dots face each other, a large teal one and a smaller golden one; the golden block crashes into the other head-on, both lose dots, and then the picture rewinds. In the second run, part of the gold stays put while the rest flows past the side in an arc; a dashed line shows the severed connection to the rear, and the teal block breaks up into single mist-blue dots without any collision.
Principle #38
Maneuver: Use movement to put yourself in a better position instead of pitting your strength head-on against your opponent’s.
3 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
“Patton” is a war film, but above all it is a portrait. It was directed by Franklin J. Schaffner, with George C. Scott in the title role. The film won seven Oscars, including Best Picture and Best Director. Scott received the Oscar for Best Actor and refused it. For the principle of Maneuver, the film is interesting because it shows not only successes but also the conditions under which movement becomes possible or fails.
A golden line turns north at a right angle and reaches the encircled town – like Patton’s thrust in the film “Patton.”
01
North Africa: first order, then movement
Situation
After the American defeat at the Kasserine Pass in Tunisia, Patton takes over II Corps in the film. He enforces the discipline and order the troops have lacked. At El Guettar, he leads the corps to success against German armored units.
Link to the principle
A maneuver needs troops that are able to move. Movement without order turns into chaos. The film first shows Patton not as an artist of movement but as someone who creates the preconditions for it.
02
Sicily: the detour via Palermo
Situation
For the landing in Sicily, Patton’s plan is rejected in favor of the plan of the British general Bernard Montgomery. Patton is supposed to support Montgomery. In the film, he instead drives northwest, takes Palermo and races the British to Messina.
Link to the principle
Where the direct route has been assigned to others, Patton looks for open space. That is maneuverist thinking: going where resistance is weaker and from there putting the opponent in a bad position. But the film leaves open how much of it is strategy and how much ambition.
03
The price of willfulness
Situation
In a field hospital, Patton slaps a soldier he accuses of cowardice. The incident causes public outrage, and Patton has to apologize. For the landing in France, Dwight D. Eisenhower sidelines him and puts him at the head of a fictitious army group in England, meant to deceive the Germans about where the landing will take place.
Link to the principle
A maneuver needs room to act, and that room is granted by superiors and allies. If you squander it through your own behavior, you stand still, however gifted you are. At the same time, Patton himself becomes part of a larger maneuver: his name ties the enemy’s attention to the wrong place.
04
Across France
Situation
After the landing in Normandy, Patton leads the Third Army across France in rapid thrusts. The advance grinds to a halt when fuel is allocated to Montgomery’s troops instead.
Link to the principle
Movement has a cost. A maneuver lives on supplies, and whoever distributes the supplies helps decide its success. Here the principle of Maneuver touches the principle of Logistics.
05
The turn toward Bastogne
Situation
In the winter of 1944, German troops attack in the Ardennes and encircle the U.S. 101st Airborne Division in Bastogne. In the film, Patton’s staff plans a bold operation to relieve the encircled troops.
Link to the principle
An army that was just fighting eastward wheels in a new direction and strikes the enemy in the flank. This succeeds only because the staff has thought ahead. Maneuver is not just speed; it is prepared mobility.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
First create the order that makes movement possible.
02
Look for open space when the direct route is blocked.
03
Don’t squander your room to act through your own behavior.
04
Think about supplies before you set off.
05
Plan changes of direction before you need them.
Summary
“Patton” shows a general who relies on movement rather than positional warfare: in Sicily via Palermo, in France with rapid thrusts, in the Ardennes with the turn toward Bastogne. At the same time, the film shows what a maneuver depends on: order, supplies, preparation and the room to act that others allow you. If you disregard these conditions, you become an obstacle to your own movement.