In Nora Ephron’s 1998 comedy, a small children’s bookstore runs up against a big bookstore chain that opens around the corner. Behind the love story lies a clear lesson about Positioning: a niche holds only if the big player cannot simply offer the same advantage on the side.
A triangle with three corners, in the middle a dot that pulls on three lines at once and trembles without moving. A second dot runs decisively into one corner, dropping small dots along the way, and grows gold there.
Principle #70
Positioning: An advantage arises only when you clearly choose one way of being better than others and deliberately give up other things for it.
3 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
“You’ve Got Mail” is known above all as a romantic comedy. Tom Hanks and Meg Ryan write each other anonymous emails and, in real life, are business rivals. The movie is set on Manhattan’s Upper West Side and is loosely based on the play “Parfumerie” by Miklós László, which Ernst Lubitsch had already filmed in 1940 as “The Shop Around the Corner.” For the topic of positioning, the movie is interesting because it brings two clearly different positions into collision.
A small shop with a gold window stands next to a huge block toward which many dots are streaming – as in “You’ve Got Mail.”
01
Two positions on one street
Situation
Kathleen Kelly (Meg Ryan) runs the children’s bookstore The Shop Around the Corner, which she inherited from her mother. The store is small and personal, and it lives on her knowledge of children’s literature. Joe Fox (Tom Hanks) comes from the family that owns the Fox Books chain. He opens a big store a few blocks away.
Link to the principle
In Michael E. Porter’s terms, two routes face each other. The chain relies on size and a broad range. The small store relies on a narrow target group and on advice. Both positions are clear. The question is which one holds when they collide head-on.
02
What the big player brings
Situation
The new Fox Books store is big, has a broad range and also stocks children’s books. It is only a few blocks from Kathleen’s store.
Link to the principle
A niche position is vulnerable when the big provider delivers part of its value on the side. If customers find almost everything in the big store that they used to find in the small one, the niche shrinks. A focus strategy must therefore offer something the big player cannot or will not copy.
03
Protest instead of profile
Situation
Kathleen’s boyfriend Frank, a newspaper columnist, writes about her store. Media reports and protests outside Fox Books follow. The chain keeps growing nonetheless, while Kathleen’s business goes from bad to worse.
Link to the principle
Attention is not a position. The protest is aimed at the opponent, but it does not sharpen your own offering. The movie does not show Kathleen redefining her profile, for example with readings, advice or an even narrower target group. It shows how goodwill alone is not enough when, in the end, the customers go to the chain anyway.
04
The end of the store
Situation
The small bookstore closes. Kathleen starts writing children’s books herself. In the end, the love story with Joe Fox resolves when she realizes who is behind the emails.
Link to the principle
The closure is not just sad; it is logical. Kathleen’s real strength lies in her knowledge and her love of children’s books. As a writer, she can use exactly this strength without having to compete against the chain’s cost advantages. Sometimes the best position is not the old store but a new field in which your own strength counts.
05
What the movie doesn’t show
Situation
The movie tells its story from the perspective of the romance. Business figures and strategies barely appear.
Link to the principle
That is why it is an illustration, not a case study. It shows the basic question of all positioning very vividly: what do customers come to you for, and what happens when someone else offers them that too?
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Be clear about what you offer that the big player cannot simply throw in on the side.
02
Don’t confuse goodwill and attention with a position.
03
Sharpen your profile before you protest against your opponent.
04
If your field no longer carries you, take your strength with you into a new one.
05
Ask regularly: what do people really come to me for?
Summary
“You’ve Got Mail” shows a small bookstore with a clear niche position up against a chain that offers size and selection. Because the chain delivers a good part of the small store’s value on the side, the store loses. In the end, its owner finds a new field in which her real strength counts.