Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. Patagonia, “Don’t Buy This Jacket” and Soft Power

Example of the principleSoft Power (#54)

Business

Patagonia, “Don’t Buy This Jacket” and Soft Power

On Black Friday 2011, the outdoor clothing maker Patagonia runs a full-page ad in The New York Times with the line “Don’t Buy This Jacket.” Instead of pushing people to buy, the company asks its customers to buy less. That is exactly what makes it credible.

On the left a teal bar shoves a group of mist-blue dots forward in jerks; when it lets go, they roll back. On the right a gold circle lights up, the dots approach on their own and carry the light onward, until the circle points in a different direction from the one it is moving in, flickers and some dots drift away.
Principle #54

Soft Power: If you win others over through attraction, credibility and example, you need to threaten or pay less, and what you gain that way lasts longer.

3 min read4 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

Companies usually rely on hard means to win customers: discounts, pressure, scarcity, heavy advertising. Soft Power works differently. It wins people over because they find the company and its stance attractive. Joseph S. Nye Jr. coined the term for states, but it also describes why some brands generate a loyalty that no discount can buy. Patagonia is a frequently cited example.

A full newspaper page shows nothing but a jacket with a tear mended in gold – as in Patagonia’s ad “Don’t Buy This Jacket.”
A full newspaper page shows nothing but a jacket with a tear mended in gold – as in Patagonia’s ad “Don’t Buy This Jacket.”

The biggest shopping day of the year

Situation
In the United States, Black Friday, the day after Thanksgiving, kicks off the holiday shopping season. Retailers lure customers with discounts, and shoppers line up. Patagonia, founded by the climber Yvon Chouinard, sells high-quality outdoor clothing and spoke out on environmental issues early on. A few years earlier, the line “Don’t Buy This Shirt” in a catalog essay had already provoked strong reactions.
Link to the principle
On this day, the hard logic of retail is at its strongest: sell more, sell faster, sell cheaper. Anyone who says the opposite on this of all days stands out. But attention alone is not yet soft power. What matters is whether the message is credible.

The ad

Situation
On November 25, 2011, the ad appears in The New York Times with the headline “Don’t Buy This Jacket” above a picture of a Patagonia jacket. The text explains what every garment costs the environment: it causes several times its own weight in greenhouse gases, leaves waste behind and uses a great deal of fresh water. Readers are asked to buy only what they really need. Patagonia says it chose The Times as the most important national newspaper and Black Friday as the start of the holiday shopping season.
Link to the principle
The ad dispenses with every hard sales technique. It appeals not to greed but to values. In doing so, it speaks to people who share those values and binds them more strongly than any discount. Soft power arises when others identify with what you stand for.

Deeds behind the words

Situation
The ad comes with the Common Threads Initiative and its five pledges: reduce, repair, reuse, recycle and reimagine. Patagonia promises to make durable products, offer repairs, help find new owners for used clothing and take back worn-out garments. This later gives rise to the Worn Wear program for used clothing. Around the turn of the year 2018–2019, the company gives itself a new purpose: “We’re in business to save our home planet.”
Link to the principle
Soft power lasts only if deeds follow words. An ad on its own would be an advertising gimmick. Only the repair service, the resale of used clothing and the take-back program make the message credible. In the text itself, Patagonia admits that it has not yet reached its goal. This honesty, too, strengthens its power of attraction.

The paradox

Situation
One might object that the ad is particularly clever advertising: a company that asks customers not to buy may end up selling more precisely because of it. Patagonia itself sees no contradiction in this. The company wants to encourage less consumption while selling products that are useful, durable and not driven by fashion.
Link to the principle
This shows both the limit and the logic of soft power. It cannot be completely separated from self-interest. What matters is whether the stance is genuine and maintained over years. If you use soft power merely as a technique, sooner or later you will be seen through. If you live it, you gain trust that lasts.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. Say what you stand for, even if it costs you something in the short term.
  2. Follow it up with deeds; otherwise it is just advertising.
  3. Admit openly where you have not yet reached your goal.
  4. People who share your values stay longer than people you win with discounts.
  5. Soft power works only if it is sustained over years.
Summary

On Black Friday 2011, Patagonia asked its customers in The New York Times not to buy this jacket and to buy only what they need. With repair, resale and take-back, the company followed up with deeds. In this way it gained credibility and a customer loyalty that no discount can create. The example shows soft power in business, along with its paradox: it is effective only as long as it is genuine.

Sources
  • Joseph S. Nye Jr.: Soft Power: The Means to Success in World Politics. New York: PublicAffairs 2004.
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind Soft Power: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Patagonia, “Don’t Buy This Jacket” and Soft Power.