Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. Samsung, Apple and Co-opetition

Example of the principleCo-opetition (#63)

Business

Samsung, Apple and Co-opetition

According to a 2011 report, up to a quarter of the components in the iPhone 4 come from Samsung. In the same year, Apple and Samsung sue each other over patents. The two corporations are business partners and bitter opponents at the same time.

Two dots pull at a small circle in opposite directions until it falls apart into specks. At the turning point, they move side by side and a golden circle grows between them; a dashed line separates baking from dividing; on the right, lines cut the large circle into slices, each larger than the small circle at the start; and a third dot in front of a closed frame marks the boundary with a cartel.
Principle #63

Co-opetition: If you cooperate with rivals where everyone wins and compete where it comes to dividing things up, you enlarge the pie and still fight for your slice.

4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

Most people think in clear camps: friend or foe, partner or competitor. The relationship between Apple and Samsung fits into none of them. It shows what Adam M. Brandenburger and Barry J. Nalebuff mean by Co-opetition: one company can be both a supplier and a rival to another at the same time. The art lies in keeping the two roles apart.

Inside a slim casing sits a golden component from the neighbor, while above it two arrows clash – like Samsung and Apple.
Inside a slim casing sits a golden component from the neighbor, while above it two arrows clash – like Samsung and Apple.

A supplier inside the iPhone

Situation
The iPhone 4 comes onto the market in the summer of 2010. In August 2011, the tech site Ubergizmo reports, based on an infographic whose origin it does not name, that up to 25% of its components come from Samsung. It names the flash memory, the RAM and the application processor, the chip that controls the entire device.
Link to the principle
Brandenburger and Nalebuff describe a company within a net of customers, suppliers, competitors and complementors. In this net, Samsung occupies two positions at once for Apple. As a supplier, Samsung helps make it possible to build the iPhone at all. Every iPhone sold brings Samsung revenue.

A rival in the same market

Situation
At the same time, Samsung sells its own Galaxy smartphones and tablets, which compete directly with the iPhone and iPad. In the spring of 2011, Apple sues Samsung for patent infringement. The charge: Samsung copied the design and the user interface. Samsung countersues in several countries. Courts in Australia and Germany temporarily stop sales of the Galaxy Tab 10.1; later the bans are lifted or narrowed.
Link to the principle
So the same corporation is a partner in the factory and an opponent in the store and in court. That is not a contradiction but co-opetition in its purest form. Cooperation lies where both win: in components produced in large volumes. Competition lies where the customer is at stake.

Why neither pulls out

Situation
Samsung is organized into divisions that operate like independent companies. The semiconductor division sells to Apple; the mobile division fights against Apple. According to the 2011 report, Samsung’s own mobile division even competes with Apple for Samsung’s flash memory. For Apple, Samsung, as one of the largest chipmakers in the world, is hard to avoid.
Link to the principle
Neither of the two can afford a break. Apple needs memory and chips in enormous quantities and of high quality. Samsung needs a major customer to keep its factories running at capacity. This mutual dependence keeps the cooperation stable, even though the rivalry is fought out in the open.

The risk of closeness

Situation
The patent dispute drags on for years. In August 2012, a jury in California awards Apple about $1 billion in damages; the amount is later changed several times. Only in June 2018 do the two corporations settle the dispute in the United States. During this period, Apple shifts production of its processors to the Taiwanese manufacturer TSMC. The chip in the 2017 iPhone X comes from there.
Link to the principle
Co-opetition has a price. If you work with a rival, you give them insight into your plans, volumes and technology. Smart companies limit this risk: they spread orders across several suppliers and protect what truly sets them apart.

Partners and opponents at once

Situation
Even so, the supply relationship does not end. For the 2017 iPhone X, Samsung supplies the OLED displays. In the smartphone market, the two remain the great rivals.
Link to the principle
The relationship holds because the two roles are clearly separated. Samsung profits from Apple’s success and at the same time fights against it. Apple makes use of Samsung’s strength and at the same time fights against it. If you think only in terms of friend and foe, you miss this possibility.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. For every player, ask which roles they play for you, not just which one.
  2. Work with rivals where both of you win.
  3. Protect what truly sets you apart.
  4. Don’t make yourself dependent on a single partner who is also your opponent.
  5. Don’t let a dispute in one place destroy cooperation in another.
Summary

According to a 2011 report, Samsung supplied a large share of the components in the iPhone 4 and at the same time fought Apple in court over patents. Both roles existed side by side because they were clearly separated: cooperation on components, competition for customers. Apple limited the risk by shifting orders, but it did not break off the relationship. This is what co-opetition looks like in the everyday life of large corporations.

Sources
  • Adam M. Brandenburger and Barry J. Nalebuff: Co-opetition. New York: Currency Doubleday 1996.
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind Co-opetition: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Samsung, Apple and Co-opetition.