Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Principles
  3. Co-opetition
63Principle · Group 8

Co-opetition

Coopetition strategy

“If you cooperate with rivals where everyone wins and compete where it comes to dividing things up, you enlarge the pie and still fight for your slice.”

Competitors are not just opponents.

Two dots pull at a small circle in opposite directions until it falls apart into specks. At the turning point, they move side by side and a golden circle grows between them; a dashed line separates baking from dividing; on the right, lines cut the large circle into slices, each larger than the small circle at the start; and a third dot in front of a closed frame marks the boundary with a cartel.
In short

If you cooperate with rivals where everyone wins and compete where it comes to dividing things up, you enlarge the pie and still fight for your slice.

What it’s about: Competitors are not just opponents. They often have problems that no one can solve alone, and costs that are the same for everyone. Co-opetition combines cooperation and competition: you work together with rivals where you create value together, and you compete with them where it comes to dividing it up. Before anyone gets a slice of the pie, the pie has to be baked.

In depth

The principle in detail

Three steps through the principle: grasp it, place it, put it to work. Open each topic on its own.

The core messageCore statement and 3 clarifications
In essence

Competition is rarely a pure zero-sum game. Together you can create value that no one creates alone.

It does not say
That rivals become friends. When it comes to dividing things up, you remain opponents.
It does not say
That every agreement between competitors is allowed. If you fix prices or shut out third parties, you are forming a cartel.
It also says
The boundary between cooperation and competition has to be spelled out; otherwise someone ends up feeling betrayed.
The explanationIf you see rivals only as enemies, you leave shared opportunities unused.

Mistakes happen on both sides.

  • If you see rivals only as enemies, you leave shared opportunities unused.
  • If you are too trusting, you show your partner your core, and they copy it.
The question

Where do you bake together, where do you divide, and have you spelled out the boundary?

The signs3 signs when you heed it · 3 when you overlook it
When you heed it
  • You know the problems you share with your rivals.
  • Any partnership you enter into begins with a clear agreement on what is shared and what is not.
  • After the joint project, you go on competing openly, without resentment.
When you overlook it
  • You talk to rivals only when there is no other way.
  • You put up with duplicate costs because cooperation looks like weakness.
  • Or you share too much, and your partner uses it against you.
The backgroundFrom Adam M. Brandenburger and Barry J. Nalebuff’s book “Co-opetition” (1996). · T6 Business Strategy
  1. 1996
    OriginAdam M. Brandenburger and Barry J. Nalebuff

    Co-opetition

  2. 2000
    SupplementedMaria Bengtsson and Sören Kock

    ‘Coopetition’ in Business Networks – to Cooperate and Compete Simultaneously

  3. Tradition T6
    TraditionBusiness Strategy

    Michael E. Porter, Richard P. Rumelt, Henry Mintzberg, Clayton M. Christensen, W. Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne

    See the tradition on the Origin page
Read more: the full background

From Adam M. Brandenburger and Barry J. Nalebuff’s book “Co-opetition” (1996). Supplemented by the study by Maria Bengtsson and Sören Kock (2000); the word itself is attested as early as 1913.

The research3 sources: 1 theory, 1 primary study, 1 review · 1996–2010 · with limitations of the research
3 sources1996–2010 period1 theory1 primary study1 review
Strength of evidence
  1. weak
  2. moderate
  3. strong

The framework is well developed and widely taken up in research; empirically, our sources contain a single study of business networks, whose finding is documented here only secondhand.

  1. 1996
    Theory
    Adam M. Brandenburger and Barry J. Nalebuff

    “Co-opetition”: applies game theory to business strategy; value net of customers, suppliers, competitors and complementors; enlarging the market while securing a large share for oneself.

  2. 2000
    Primary study
    Maria Bengtsson and Sören Kock

    “‘Coopetition’ in Business Networks – to Cooperate and Compete Simultaneously” (Industrial Marketing Management): companies in networks cooperate and compete at the same time; cooperation tends to take place far from the customer, competition close to the customer.

  3. 2010
    Review
    Harald D. Stein

    “Literature overview on the field of co-opetition”: the book by Adam M. Brandenburger and Barry J. Nalebuff brought the topic to public and scholarly attention.

Where the research reaches its limits
  • Co-opetition crosses the line when the cooperation serves to fix prices or shut out third parties; then it is a cartel and illegal.
  • In every partnership, knowledge leaks out, and the benefits are rarely shared equally: whoever organizes the cooperation can secure a large part of the value for themselves.
  • The finding on activities close to and far from the customer was not checked against the original study.
Read more: what research shows

In “Co-opetition” (1996), Adam M. Brandenburger and Barry J. Nalebuff applied game theory to business strategy. Their central image is the value net: every company stands between customers, suppliers, competitors and complementors, and the same player can have several roles at once. Successful companies enlarge the market, which benefits their rivals too, and at the same time secure as large a share as possible for themselves. Harald D. Stein calls their book the decisive step that brought the topic to public and scholarly attention. In 2000, Maria Bengtsson and Sören Kock studied networks of companies that cooperate and compete at the same time. One frequently cited finding: the firms were more likely to cooperate on activities far from the customer and to compete on activities close to the customer. These studies do not measure how much bigger the pie becomes.

The related principles57 Strategic Interdependence · 62 Tit for Tat · 71 Value Chain · 77 Network Effects

The prerequisite is 57 Strategic Interdependence (your success depends on what others do)

62 Tit for Tat keeps cooperation among rivals stable over many rounds

71 Value Chain shows in which activities cooperation pays off and where competition lies

77 Network Effects shows how shared standards enlarge the market for everyone before the fight for market share begins

Read more: the full text

The prerequisite is 57 Strategic Interdependence (your success depends on what others do); 62 Tit for Tat keeps cooperation among rivals stable over many rounds. 71 Value Chain shows in which activities cooperation pays off and where competition lies, and 77 Network Effects shows how shared standards enlarge the market for everyone before the fight for market share begins.

The action steps5 action steps: Write down who you compete with, and for each rival note one problem you both have.
  1. Write down who you compete with, and for each rival note one problem you both have.

  2. Look for the activities that do not set you apart from your rival, such as purchasing, training or shared infrastructure. That is where cooperation is most likely to pay off.
  3. Agree at the outset on what will be shared and what will not, and put it in writing.

  4. Protect your core: share what makes the pie bigger, not what sets you apart.
  5. Check every partnership to see whether it shuts out third parties or fixes prices. That is where co-opetition ends.
The reflection questions3 questions: What problem do you share with a rival that neither of you can solve alone?
  1. What problem do you share with a rival that neither of you can solve alone?
  2. Where are you paying twice because you don’t want to talk to a competitor?
  3. In which partnership has no one ever spelled out where it ends?

Take your time with one question. Write down your answer – or talk it over with someone you trust.

To finish
The picture to rememberThe animation once more, with an explanation
  1. Two dots pull at a small circle in opposite directions until it falls apart into specks
  2. At the turning point, they move side by side and a golden circle grows between them
  3. A dashed line separates baking from dividing
  4. On the right, lines cut the large circle into slices, each larger than the small circle at the start
  5. And a third dot in front of a closed frame marks the boundary with a cartel
Strategy Check

Which rival are you baking a pie with?

Get your profile across all 12 groups in about 10 to 15 minutes.

Start the Strategy Check
In context

Group 8: Interaction, Alliances and Negotiation

Guiding question: How do you act when others are in the game too?

Stage 4 of 5: Act with others

Where the 92 principles come from: eight traditions of strategy, from classical war theory to dealing with uncertainty.

More about the origin

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

FAQ

Questions about Co-opetition

What does Co-opetition say?

Rivals can cooperate and compete at the same time. Together they create value that none of them could create alone, and when it comes to dividing it up, they remain opponents.

Where does Co-opetition come from?

Adam M. Brandenburger and Barry J. Nalebuff popularized it with their 1996 book “Co-opetition.” In it, they apply game theory to business strategy and describe every company as part of a net of customers, suppliers, competitors and complementors.

What are some examples?

The founding of the Associated Press in 1846, Formula One’s Concorde Agreement of 1981 and the relationship between Samsung and Apple. In film, “Pirates of Silicon Valley” shows it.

How well is Co-opetition supported by research?

Evidence: moderate – the framework is well developed and widely taken up in research; empirically, our sources contain a single study of business networks, whose finding is documented here only secondhand.

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Co-opetition.