In the reality show “Survivor,” contestants vote each other out of the game one by one. Whoever seems too strong becomes a target because the others ally against them, and that turns the show into a laboratory for the Balance of Power.
Five teal circles of equal size rest on a beam balance made of fine mist-blue lines, calmly in equilibrium; one of them turns gold and grows until the balance tips. The four remaining circles roll toward each other and link up with lines into a block, and the balance comes back into equilibrium, before one circle within the block begins to grow.
Principle #60
Balance of Power: If one party becomes too strong, the others close ranks, and if you overlook this, you build your own opposing coalition.
3 min read4 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
In 2000, the American network CBS launches a show that will leave its mark on television. “Survivor” is based on the Swedish format “Expedition Robinson.” The host is Jeff Probst. A group of strangers is marooned in a remote location, and in the end one person remains and wins the prize money. Who survives is decided not by nature but by the votes of the others. An example of the Balance of Power.
A row of torches, the tallest glowing gold, and all the other players’ voting lines point at it – as in “Survivor.”
01
The rules: voting instead of elimination
Situation
At first, the contestants live in teams, the tribes, and compete against each other in challenges. The losing tribe has to go to Tribal Council and vote one of its members out. Later, the tribes are merged, and everyone plays for themselves. Whoever wins an individual challenge is protected from being voted out for that round. At the very end, a jury of eliminated contestants decides who wins.
Link to the principle
The rules create a system without a referee in which anyone can eliminate anyone, but no one can do it alone. This is the basic situation of the world of states on which Hans J. Morgenthau builds his theory. Power arises only through majorities, and majorities form against whoever has too much of it.
02
The first alliance
Situation
In the first season, the contestant Richard Hatch forms a firm voting alliance with a few fellow players early on. The group votes as a bloc, while the others each decide for themselves. Hatch wins the season. Since then, alliances have been considered the core of the game.
Link to the principle
An alliance that holds together is stronger than many individuals. But that is exactly what turns it into a preponderance of power itself. Whoever leads a dominant alliance calls forth a counter-alliance as soon as the others grasp what is going on.
03
The strongest has to go
Situation
A recurring pattern on the show: as soon as everyone is playing for themselves, the votes turn against the contestant who wins the most challenges or is the most popular. That player could ride the protection of individual wins all the way to the end and win over the jury there. That is why players who otherwise mistrust each other ally for this one vote only.
Link to the principle
This is the balance of power in its purest form. Nobody hates the strongest player. That player is simply dangerous because they would otherwise beat everyone else. The opposing coalition serves a single purpose and falls apart again immediately afterward.
04
Playing smart means not seeming too strong
Situation
Many contestants adapt their behavior to this logic. They hold back in challenges, hide their alliances or push others to the fore so that those others are seen as the threat. Fellow players, in turn, sometimes keep a strong contestant around for a while as a shield on whom all eyes are fixed.
Link to the principle
Where opposing coalitions loom, visible strength is risky. If you are smart, you grow quietly. That is exactly what states do when they deliberately keep their rise inconspicuous so that no alliance forms against them.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Whoever is superior to everyone becomes the common target.
02
Opposing coalitions need no friendship, only a common opponent.
03
Carry your strength in a way that doesn’t throw others into a panic.
04
Pay attention to who else besides you is perceived as a threat.
05
Alliances of convenience fall apart as soon as their purpose is served.
Summary
“Survivor” shows on a small scale what Hans J. Morgenthau describes for states. In a system without a higher authority, the weaker parties ally against whoever becomes too strong. If you want to win, you need alliances, but you must not seem so superior yourself that everyone else joins forces against you.
Sources
Hans J. Morgenthau: Politics Among Nations: The Struggle for Power and Peace. New York: Alfred A. Knopf 1948.
Survivor, reality show, CBS, since 2000, based on the format Expedition Robinson.
Back to the basics
Read what lies behind the Balance of Power: with explanation, animation, video and research.