Barack Obama, the Caucus States and the Principle of Emptiness and Fullness
In the 2008 Democratic primaries, Hillary Clinton is the favorite and strong in the big states. Barack Obama’s team, led by David Plouffe, collects delegates where Clinton is hardly present: in small states and at the caucuses.
A large field of teal dots with dense patches and pale, almost empty patches in mist-blue; a small golden dot bounces head-on off the densest patch. Then it dissolves into a golden line that runs around the dense patches, seeps into the pale ones and fills them with gold.
Principle #29
Emptiness and Fullness: Commit your strength where the other side is weak or absent, and avoid the place where it is strong.
4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
In the Democratic Party’s primaries, what counts is delegates, not victories. In most states, delegates are allocated in proportion to the vote. If you narrowly win a big state, you get hardly more than the loser. If you win a small state by a wide margin, you can build up a bigger lead than in the big one. David Plouffe, Obama’s campaign manager, built the campaign around this arithmetic – an example of the Principle of Emptiness and Fullness.
Large fields are densely occupied; in many small ones golden dots gather until the golden column stands just a little higher – as with Obama in 2008.
01
The favorite
Situation
Hillary Clinton enters the 2008 primaries as the best-known candidate. Many observers expect the race to be decided on February 5, “Super Tuesday,” when more than 20 states vote. On that day Clinton wins big states such as California, New Jersey and Massachusetts.
Link to the principle
Clinton’s fullness lies in the big states, with many delegates, a strong party base and high name recognition. A head-on fight for these states would have tied down Obama’s forces without giving him a decisive lead.
02
Delegates instead of headlines
Situation
Obama’s team does not see Super Tuesday as a battle for big names. It counts the delegates at stake, 1,681 on that day. Each state is assessed by how many delegates can be won there and at what cost. In Idaho, Obama wins 15 delegates and Clinton 3. In New Jersey, a much bigger state, Clinton wins 59 delegates and Obama 48. The lead from Idaho is thus bigger than Clinton’s lead in New Jersey.
Link to the principle
This is Emptiness and Fullness in numbers. A small state that the opponent barely pays attention to weighs as much as a big one she fights hard for. Obama does not take anything from Clinton at her strongest point. He collects where she is not looking.
03
The caucus states
Situation
In some states, people do not vote at polling stations but in meetings, the caucuses. Winning there requires organization on the ground and supporters who are willing to spend hours at a meeting. Obama’s campaign builds structures in these states early, carried by many volunteers who also connect with each other online. On Super Tuesday, Obama wins the caucuses in Minnesota, Colorado, Kansas and Idaho, among others.
Link to the principle
For a campaign that relies on big states, caucus states are sideshows. For Obama, they are the emptiness into which he can carry his strength: many enthusiastic volunteers and good online organization. He sets his own fullness against his opponent’s emptiness.
04
Margins are what matter
Situation
Where Obama wins clearly, he also wins clearly more delegates. In Wyoming, he wins on March 8 with around 61% of the vote and receives 7 of the 12 delegates. Clinton later still wins big states such as Ohio and Pennsylvania. But the lead in delegates is there. On June 3, 2008, Obama has the majority he needs; on June 7, Clinton ends her campaign.
Link to the principle
Emptiness does not stay empty forever. A strong opponent notices the gap sooner or later. What matters is that you use it before the opponent reacts. A good part of Obama’s lead in delegates came from small states and caucuses. Victories in big states could no longer close the gap.
05
What the example does not show
Situation
Obama does not win only because of the small states. His victory in the first caucus, in Iowa on January 3, 2008, changes the whole race, and he also wins big states. Clinton gains many votes in the big primary states. The race stays close to the end.
Link to the principle
Emptiness and Fullness is no substitute for strength of your own. It tells you where to use it. Obama had money, enthusiasm and a network of volunteers. The principle helped him use these forces where they had the greatest effect.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Know the rules of the game precisely. What counts is often not what everyone is watching.
02
Assess every field by what you can win there with your effort.
03
Small fields that the other side ignores can weigh as much as big ones.
04
Carry your own strength into the other side’s gap.
05
Use a gap quickly, before the other side notices it.
Summary
In the 2008 primaries, Hillary Clinton was strong in the big states, and many expected the race to be decided on Super Tuesday. Barack Obama’s team, led by David Plouffe, counted in delegates and won big margins in small states and caucuses, carried by volunteers who also organized online. When Clinton later won big states, it was no longer enough. The example shows how the Principle of Emptiness and Fullness works in a contest with clear rules.