Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. Movie: The Big Short

Example of the principleEmptiness and Fullness (#29)

Business

Movie: The Big Short

In “The Big Short” (2015), a few outsiders realize that the American housing market rests on bad loans. They do not bet where the market is paying attention but precisely at the point everyone considers safe.

A large field of teal dots with dense patches and pale, almost empty patches in mist-blue; a small golden dot bounces head-on off the densest patch. Then it dissolves into a golden line that runs around the dense patches, seeps into the pale ones and fills them with gold.
Principle #29

Emptiness and Fullness: Commit your strength where the other side is weak or absent, and avoid the place where it is strong.

4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

Adam McKay’s film is based on Michael Lewis’s nonfiction book about the financial crisis of 2007 and 2008. It tells the story of people who bet against the market at a time when almost everyone believes in rising house prices. Their advantage is not more money or more power. Their advantage is that they look where others don’t. That makes the film a lesson in the Principle of Emptiness and Fullness, and at the same time a warning about what it means to profit from the weakness of an entire system.

Every eye is on the top of a tower of blocks, while a golden arrow aims at the hollow foundation – as in “The Big Short.”
Every eye is on the top of a tower of blocks, while a golden arrow aims at the hollow foundation – as in “The Big Short.”

One man reads the fine print

Situation
In 2005, Michael Burry (Christian Bale), an idiosyncratic fund manager, reads the documents behind mortgage bonds that hardly anyone else reads. He realizes that many loans have been made to people who will not be able to repay them as soon as the low teaser rates rise. He gets big banks to sell him credit default swaps on these bonds. The banks gladly take his money because they consider the market safe.
Link to the principle
The market’s fullness is its confidence: banks, rating agencies and investors confirm each other. The emptiness is what nobody checks: what is actually inside the bonds. Burry does not attack the market’s opinion. He goes to the point where nobody is standing guard.

Looking where nobody looks

Situation
The bank salesman Jared Vennett (Ryan Gosling) sees an opportunity in Burry’s bets and offers the deal to others too, including the fund manager Mark Baum (Steve Carell). Baum is suspicious and travels to Florida with his team to check the housing market for himself. There they come across empty houses and loans made to people who can never repay them. The rating agencies also turn out to be unreliable: many bad bonds carry good ratings.
Link to the principle
If you want to find an emptiness, you have to check on the ground instead of believing reports. Baum’s team sees with its own eyes what is hidden in the numbers. Only that turns a suspicion into a certainty.

The point everyone considers safe

Situation
Two young investors, Charlie Geller and Jamie Shipley, stumble upon Vennett’s documents. With the help of the former trader Ben Rickert (Brad Pitt), they gain access to the big banks. They bet that even bonds the market considers almost safe will default. That is exactly why such a bet is cheap.
Link to the principle
This is the sharpest form of emptiness: a point the opponent considers its strongest. Where everyone feels safe, nothing is defended. A bet there is cheap because nobody believes it will pay off.

Holding out until the emptiness shows

Situation
For a long time nothing happens. Burry’s investors are furious and want their money back. The banks keep valuing the securities highly even though defaults are rising. Only in 2007 and 2008 does the market collapse. The outsiders win their bets while millions of people lose their homes and jobs.
Link to the principle
Recognizing an emptiness does not mean that it takes effect right away. If you stand against the fullness of a market, you need patience and the strength to hold out until the market turns. Many who were right did not hold out long enough.

Winning where others lose

Situation
The film does not portray the winners as heroes. Ben Rickert reminds the young investors that their bet will only pay off if many people are harmed. Mark Baum visibly struggles with the question of whether he may profit from a system he considers fraudulent.
Link to the principle
Emptiness and Fullness is a tool. It shows you where you can make your move. Whether you should, and what you do with your advantage, it does not answer. That question stays with you.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. Look for the point everyone considers safe. Nobody stands guard there.
  2. Read the documents and look for yourself instead of believing the majority.
  3. Once you have spotted a gap, you need patience until it shows.
  4. Be prepared to stand alone for a long time if you bet against the fullness.
  5. Ask who pays for your advantage.
Summary

“The Big Short” tells the story of outsiders who bet against the housing market before the 2008 financial crisis. They beat the market not with greater power but because they look where everyone feels safe: at the loans behind the bonds. The film shows how the Principle of Emptiness and Fullness works and asks at the same time what it means to profit from the weakness of an entire system.

Sources
  • Michael Lewis: The Big Short: Inside the Doomsday Machine. New York: W. W. Norton 2010.
  • The Big Short. Directed by Adam McKay. U.S. 2015.
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind the Principle of Emptiness and Fullness: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Movie: The Big Short.