Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. Chris Messina, the Hashtag and Emergent Strategy

Example of the principleEmergent Strategy (#80)

Media

Chris Messina, the Hashtag and Emergent Strategy

In 2007, the user Chris Messina suggests grouping posts on Twitter with the pound sign. Twitter shows little interest, users do it anyway, and only years later does the company build the hashtag into its product. One of the best-known features of the internet was never planned.

From above: a straight teal line across a surface; many small dots set off and veer diagonally toward a mist-blue circle that the line does not touch. From their tracks a gold trail condenses, part of the straight line fades, and a frame settles around the gold trail.
Principle #80

Emergent Strategy: Strategy is not only what you plan but also the pattern that emerges in your actions; if you recognize it in time, you can learn from it.

3 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

When you think of Twitter, you probably think of hashtags. They are so taken for granted that people forget they did not come from the product department. They arose from use. The company recognized the pattern only late and then adopted it. This is Emergent Strategy in its purest form: the realized strategy arises from what people do, not from what leadership has decided.

Many scattered messages; a gold thread pulls some marked ones together into an orderly column – as with the hashtag.
Many scattered messages; a gold thread pulls some marked ones together into an orderly column – as with the hashtag.

A suggestion in the summer of 2007

Situation
In the summer of 2007, Twitter is a young, small service with many technical problems. The designer Chris Messina, an early user, comes to the office with a suggestion: the pound sign could be used to group posts that belong together. According to Messina’s own account, people there think little of the idea. On August 23, 2007, Messina publicly proposes the idea in a tweet.
Link to the principle
Twitter’s leadership has other priorities: the service first has to run reliably. The suggestion fits no plan. That is typical. Many ideas that later become important first appear at the edges and go unrecognized by those in charge.

Users do it anyway

Situation
Messina does not feel rebuffed and simply uses the symbol. Other users adopt it. The pound sign becomes a way of making conversations on a topic findable, for example about conferences or events. According to widely cited accounts, coverage of the wildfires near San Diego in October 2007 plays an important role in its spread.
Link to the principle
Here a pattern emerges without any decision. No one ordered it; many keep it going. Henry Mintzberg describes such strategies, which arise from many individual actions, in a grassroots model. At first, they grow like weeds in a garden, in places no one has planted.

Twitter follows suit

Situation
Only gradually does Twitter build the hashtag into its own product. In 2009, the string becomes a clickable link that shows all posts with that term. Later, lists of the most-used terms show what people are talking about right now. For the tenth anniversary in 2017, Twitter recalls Messina’s tweet on its blog as the birth of the hashtag.
Link to the principle
This is the decisive step. A leadership that takes emergent strategy seriously sees the pattern and makes it part of its own course. Twitter did not invent the hashtag, but it recognized that it worked and strengthened it. A company that pursued only its own plan would have ignored the symbol or even banned it.

From tool to culture

Situation
The hashtag spreads beyond Twitter to other platforms. It no longer serves only to organize but also to comment, to joke and to protest. Movements gather under a keyword. In 2017, Twitter writes that a tool for grouping posts has become a means of adding commentary and sparking social movements.
Link to the principle
Emergent strategy comes at a price: it is hard to steer. What arises from use keeps developing through use, including in directions leadership does not want. If you adopt patterns that others have created, you also accept some loss of control.

What leaders can learn from it

Situation
The hashtag is not the only example at Twitter. Forwarding other people’s posts also first arose from use: users copied posts and put the abbreviation “RT” in front of them. In 2009, the company built a dedicated feature for it.
Link to the principle
For leadership in companies, churches and families, this means: look closely at what people do on their own, how they work around, supplement or reinterpret processes. There is often more strategy in that than in the next planning document. The art is to see such patterns early and decide which ones you will strengthen.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. Take suggestions from the edges seriously, even if they fit no plan.
  2. Watch what people do with your offering on their own.
  3. Strengthen patterns that work instead of fighting them.
  4. Be prepared for adopted patterns to keep developing.
  5. Don’t let the daily rush talk you out of a good idea.
Summary

The hashtag was suggested by a user in 2007, initially ignored by the company and spread by users anyway. Twitter recognized the pattern only later and built it into its product. It became one of the defining symbols of digital communication. The story shows a grassroots strategy in Henry Mintzberg’s sense: it arises from many actions and becomes a course only when leadership recognizes it.

Sources
  • Henry Mintzberg and James A. Waters: Of Strategies, Deliberate and Emergent. In: Strategic Management Journal 6 (1985), No. 3, pp. 257–272.
  • Henry Mintzberg: Crafting Strategy. In: Harvard Business Review 65 (1987), No. 4, pp. 66–75.
  • Henry Mintzberg and Alexandra McHugh: Strategy Formation in an Adhocracy. In: Administrative Science Quarterly 30 (1985), No. 2, pp. 160–197.
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind Emergent Strategy: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Chris Messina, the Hashtag and Emergent Strategy.