Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. The Festina Affair and the Security Dilemma

Example of the principleSecurity Dilemma (#61)

Arts, Entertainment & Sports

The Festina Affair and the Security Dilemma

In July 1998, customs officers find large quantities of doping products in the car of a staff member of the Festina cycling team. The affair reveals how teams had been locked in an arms race with one another: anyone who wanted to ride clean feared having no chance against the others.

Two dots face each other; the left one draws a thin ring around itself, the right one answers with a thicker one, and with every ring the dots grow smaller and paler. At the turning point, a golden gate opens in the left ring, a golden line runs to the right dot, and both rings grow thinner.
Principle #61

Security Dilemma: What you do to protect yourself, your counterpart may read as a threat – and then you arm each other into insecurity.

3 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

The Security Dilemma comes from politics between states. But its logic can be found wherever competitors cannot see each other’s cards. Cycling in the 1990s is a dark example of this. Every team armed because it assumed the others were doing the same, and the result was one of the biggest scandals in the history of the Tour de France.

On a steep stage, dots with ever longer tails climb uphill, while a golden one falls behind – like the teams before the Festina affair.
On a steep stage, dots with ever longer tails climb uphill, while a golden one falls behind – like the teams before the Festina affair.

The find at the border

Situation
On July 8, 1998, a few days before the start of the Tour de France, customs officers stop Willy Voet’s car at the French-Belgian border at Neuville-en-Ferrain near Lille. He is a soigneur with the Festina team. In the car they find, among other things, EPO, anabolic steroids and syringes. The police search the team’s offices in Lyon. Shortly afterward, they announce that a document proves the existence of a systematic doping program for the riders.
Link to the principle
What is discovered here is not an individual act. It is an organized arms buildup. A team invests in performance-enhancing products because it wants to secure its place in the competition.

Why everyone takes part

Situation
Under questioning, Voet and team director Bruno Roussel state that the doping was organized within the team and that other teams were involved as well. The Swiss rider Alex Zülle later says he had to dope to meet the sponsors’ expectations. In court in 2000, Voet testifies that he kept the Festina riders’ hematocrit at no more than 54%, while other teams reached levels of up to 64%.
Link to the principle
This is the structure of the Security Dilemma. No team can check what the others are doing. Each assumes the worst and arms in response. Riding clean appears not as a virtue but as unilateral disarmament, paid for with defeats. That the riders thought exactly this way is an interpretation, but the testimony at the trial points in this direction.

The Tour in a state of emergency

Situation
After Roussel confesses, Tour director Jean-Marie Leblanc expels the Festina team. Nine riders and three staff members are taken into custody. The police search other teams, including TVM. In protest against the investigations, the riders stage an hour-long sit-down strike during one stage; a later stage is canceled. Several Spanish teams withdraw. Of 189 starters, fewer than 100 are still in the race at the end of July.
Link to the principle
When a spiral is exposed, it hits everyone. The teams had driven each other into a situation in which no one could win any longer without cheating, and in which everyone faced ruin as soon as one of them was caught.

The exception

Situation
One Festina rider is neither arrested nor implicated: Christophe Bassons. Voet later names him, along with two other riders, as the only ones on the team who did not dope.
Link to the principle
If you refuse to arm in a security dilemma, you carry a high risk. Bassons’s example shows that refusal is possible but comes at a price. Individuals can rarely break the spiral on their own. That takes rules and controls that apply to everyone.

The way out: control instead of trust

Situation
On August 4, 1998, Leblanc admits that the rising speed in the peloton is linked to increasing doping. In December 2000, a French court gives Voet, Roussel and others involved suspended sentences and fines. The scandal helps make the fight against doping more organized.
Link to the principle
Good will alone rarely leads out of a security dilemma. It takes an authority that checks everyone, so that no one has to fear being the only honest one. Here, control replaces the trust that is missing.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. If you assume everyone is cheating, you become part of the problem yourself.
  2. A spiral arises where no one can check what the others are doing.
  3. Opting out on your own is costly, but sometimes it is the only clean way.
  4. Common rules and controls protect the honest.
  5. Ask yourself what you are doing only because you fear the others.
Summary

The Festina affair of 1998 made visible how cycling teams had driven each other into doping. Every team feared having no chance against the others without performance-enhancing drugs, and armed in response. That is the logic of the Security Dilemma outside politics. Good will alone does not lead out of it; only controls that apply to everyone do.

Sources
  • John H. Herz: Idealist Internationalism and the Security Dilemma. In: World Politics 2 (1950), No. 2, pp. 157–180.
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind the Security Dilemma: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: The Festina Affair and the Security Dilemma.