Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. Martin Luther, the 95 Theses and Initiative

Example of the principleInitiative (#43)

Faith & ReligionMedia

Martin Luther, the 95 Theses and Initiative

In October 1517, Martin Luther puts 95 theses against the sale of indulgences up for debate. Within a few months, they are circulating in print throughout the Holy Roman Empire, and Luther follows up with writings in German, while Rome responds with proceedings that take years.

Two dots stand on a field of fine mist-blue lines; one of them sets a golden circle, and the lines align with it and close in on the space of the silent dot. Then a small dot in the corner sets a golden circle of its own, and the lines turn toward it.
Principle #43

Initiative: If you act first, you set the agenda and the rules of the game, while those who only react play on someone else’s turf.

4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

Whoever acts first determines the topic. In the early 16th century, the Church had power, law and tradition on its side. A professor of theology in a small Saxon university town had only his arguments. If Luther nevertheless led the debate rather than merely enduring it, that was partly because he seized the initiative and did not give it up again.

From a golden sheet on the door, copies fly off in all directions, while the slow clock at the bottom right has barely started – like Luther’s 95 Theses.
From a golden sheet on the door, copies fly off in all directions, while the slow clock at the bottom right has barely started – like Luther’s 95 Theses.

A letter to the archbishop

Situation
Albert of Brandenburg, Archbishop of Mainz and Magdeburg, has borrowed 21,000 ducats from Jakob Fugger to pay the fees for his offices in Rome. He intends to repay the debt with the proceeds from an indulgence. Half is to go toward the rebuilding of St. Peter’s Basilica in Rome. On October 31, 1517, Martin Luther, professor of theology in Wittenberg, writes Albert a letter and encloses 95 theses on indulgences. Whether Luther also nailed the theses to the door of the Castle Church is disputed among historians.
Link to the principle
Luther does not wait until the Church takes up the topic itself. He raises the question, and in a form that demands an answer: theses are claims that invite a disputation. Whoever asks the questions determines what is being discussed.

The theses take on a life of their own

Situation
Albert does not answer. Luther sends copies to acquaintances. They have the theses printed without his knowledge. Before the end of 1517, editions appear in Leipzig, Nuremberg and Basel. Shortly before Christmas 1517, the Nuremberg councilor Kaspar Nützel probably translates them into German. A scholarly debate becomes a public issue throughout the Empire.
Link to the principle
Luther had not planned this initial spread. Initiative is not always a well-thought-out move. Sometimes a first step sets something in motion that is bigger than the intention. What matters is what you then make of it.

Luther follows up

Situation
In 1518, Luther publishes his “Sermon on Indulgence and Grace,” not in Latin but in German, short and understandable for lay people. In 1518 alone, 15 High German editions and one Low German edition appear, followed by nine more in the next two years. Further writings and pamphlets follow. The flood reaches its peak in the mid-1520s: in 1524 alone, some 2,400 popular prints appear in about 2.4 million copies.
Link to the principle
Now Luther acts deliberately. He changes the language and the audience. Instead of arguing only with theologians, he addresses the people who buy the indulgences. In doing so, he sets not only the topic but also the arena in which it is debated.

Rome responds at its own pace

Situation
In 1518, Rome opens heresy proceedings. In October 1518, Cardinal Cajetan demands in Augsburg that Luther recant; Luther refuses and leaves the city. In 1520, Pope Leo X threatens him with excommunication in the bull “Exsurge Domine”; the excommunication follows at the beginning of 1521, and in April 1521 Luther stands before the Diet of Worms.
Link to the principle
Rome responds with the means it knows: proceedings, interrogation, bull, excommunication. These means take months and years, and they speak Latin. Luther responds with printed works that appear within weeks and speak German. If you only react, you play by the other side’s rules. Here Rome was playing in an arena that Luther had chosen.

The first media movement

Situation
Historians see the Reformation as the first historical event that was shaped in essential ways by printing. Luther’s complete translation of the Bible appears in 1534 and becomes one of the most widely circulated books of its time.
Link to the principle
Initiative works most powerfully when it uses a new means that the other side has not yet mastered. Printing was not new, but nobody had used it so quickly and so purposefully for a public debate before.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. Ask the question before others ask it for you.
  2. Make use of an unexpected beginning instead of regretting it.
  3. Choose the language and the place where you can win.
  4. Follow up while the other side is still deliberating.
  5. Use means that the other side has not yet mastered.
Summary

With his theses, Martin Luther raised a question in 1517 that the Church did not want to ask. The first prints spread it without his doing anything. Then he deliberately seized the initiative: he wrote in German, for lay people, in quick succession. Rome responded with lengthy proceedings in its own language and could no longer keep up. The example shows: if you act first and then follow up, you determine the field on which the dispute is fought.

Back to the basics

Read what lies behind Initiative: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Martin Luther, the 95 Theses and Initiative.