Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. Movie: BlackBerry

Example of the principleExploration and Exploitation (#79)

Business

Movie: BlackBerry

The film “BlackBerry” (2023) tells the story of the rise and fall of the Canadian smartphone pioneer. A company perfects its hit device and overlooks the fact that, with the touchscreen, the world is moving in a different direction.

A scale made of lines: on the left a circle of many teal dots, on the right a small gold cone of light pointing into a mist-blue space. Almost all the new dots fall into the circle until its dots fade; then some deliberately move to the cone of light, a line opens into the dark toward a new circle, and the scale settles.
Principle #79

Exploration and Exploitation: If you only exploit what you have, you lose the future, and if you only search for the new, you lose the present; good strategy deliberately keeps both in balance.

4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

Hardly any film shows as vividly how success can blind you. “BlackBerry,” directed by Matt Johnson, is based on the nonfiction book “Losing the Signal” by Jacquie McNish and Sean Silcoff. It is a dramatized, at times comedic retelling. At its core is a question that James G. March described in theory in 1991 and that lies at the heart of the Principle of Exploration and Exploitation: what happens when a company only keeps improving what it can already do?

On the left, a device full of tiny keys; on the right, a smooth gold surface toward which the dots move – as in “BlackBerry.”
On the left, a device full of tiny keys; on the right, a smooth gold surface toward which the dots move – as in “BlackBerry.”

A device that changes everything

Situation
The film begins in the mid-1990s in Waterloo, Ontario. The engineer Mike Lazaridis, played by Jay Baruchel, and his partner Doug Fregin run the small company Research in Motion. They have the idea for a device that combines a phone, a pager and email. The businessman Jim Balsillie, played by Glenn Howerton, comes on board and brings the idea to market with ruthless methods.
Link to the principle
At the beginning, there is pure exploration. The company is looking for something that does not exist yet, with a small team and a lot of improvisation. The film shows how much energy there is in this phase, and also how little order.

Exploitation to the limit

Situation
The BlackBerry becomes a status symbol in business and politics. The company grows at breakneck speed. In the film, everything now revolves around improving the hit device, keeping the network stable, recruiting engineers and tending the share price. The distinctive keyboard becomes the company’s trademark and its pride.
Link to the principle
Now exploitation dominates. At first, that is right: a breakthrough has to be turned into a reliable product. But the film shows how all the attention flows into maintaining what exists. There is hardly any room left for the question of what comes after the BlackBerry.

The iPhone

Situation
In 2007, Apple unveils the iPhone, a phone with almost no buttons and a large touchscreen. In the film, Lazaridis initially reacts with disbelief and contempt. For him, a real keyboard is what business customers want. The company’s own recipe for success becomes the yardstick for the new.
Link to the principle
Here we see what Barbara Levitt and James G. March called a competency trap in 1988. If you are very good at something, you get good results, so you do more of it and get even better at it. Precisely for that reason, switching to something else never seems worthwhile, until it is too late.

What the film exaggerates

Situation
The film compresses years into a few scenes and exaggerates its characters. In reality, the company did bring out touchscreen devices, but they failed to catch on. Lazaridis and Balsillie stepped down from the company’s leadership in 2012, the company renamed itself BlackBerry in 2013, and in 2016 it announced that it would no longer develop its own phones. The film is not a documentary. What it shows about the real people is dramatized and not a factual account.
Link to the principle
That matters for the lesson. It was not that no one saw the new. The problem was that the new attempts were measured by the old yardstick and pursued half-heartedly. Exploration that comes too late and only as imitation does not make up for years of one-sided exploitation.

A lesson in success traps

Situation
At the end of the film comes the crash of a company that had dominated the market only shortly before. The film refrains from drawing a moral, but the message is clear: success itself narrowed the company’s view.
Link to the principle
For leadership, this means: the more successful you are right now, the more deliberately you have to protect room for the new. This applies to companies as much as to churches or families that cling to forms that used to work.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. Distrust your own recipe for success most when it is working best.
  2. Don’t measure new developments only by your old yardstick.
  3. Protect time and people for the question of what comes after your core product.
  4. Explore early and seriously, not late and as imitation.
  5. Watch whether pride in a feature turns into blindness.
Summary

“BlackBerry” tells how a Canadian company conquers the market with a brilliant idea and loses it because it does nothing but keep improving its hit device. When the iPhone arrives, management measures the new against its own recipe. The film shows the competency trap James G. March warned about: if you only exploit, you keep getting better at it and lose the future.

Sources
  • Jacquie McNish and Sean Silcoff: Losing the Signal: The Untold Story Behind the Extraordinary Rise and Spectacular Fall of BlackBerry. New York: Flatiron Books 2015.
  • Barbara Levitt and James G. March: Organizational Learning. In: Annual Review of Sociology 14 (1988), pp. 319–340.
  • James G. March: Exploration and Exploitation in Organizational Learning. In: Organization Science 2 (1991), No. 1, pp. 71–87.
  • BlackBerry (Canada 2023), directed by Matt Johnson.
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind the Principle of Exploration and Exploitation: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Movie: BlackBerry.