A drone circles over a house in Nairobi. Inside, two suicide bombers are getting ready; outside, a girl is selling bread. The film shows how people in many places at once have to make life-and-death decisions with incomplete knowledge, and how seductive numbers that feign certainty can be.
A golden dot stands in a grid of mist-blue squares; only the three squares around it are clear, and a teal arc runs down like an hourglass while it waits and the fog stays. Then the dot takes a small step, several squares clear, and above one square a range made of two short lines appears instead of a single mark.
Principle #19
Fog of Uncertainty: Because you never know the whole situation, you have to decide with judgment instead of waiting for a certainty that will not come.
4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
“Eye in the Sky” (2015), directed by Gavin Hood from a screenplay by Guy Hibbert, unfolds almost in real time. The camera cuts between a command room in England, a conference room in London, a drone cockpit in Nevada and a street in Kenya. Everywhere people are sitting in front of screens. Everyone sees a lot; no one sees enough. That makes the film a powerful image of the Fog of Uncertainty.
A path circles over a house, thin threads lead to distant places, and a small golden dot glows in front of the wall – as in “Eye in the Sky.”
01
From arrest to strike
Situation
From the British headquarters in Northwood, Colonel Katherine Powell (Helen Mirren) leads an operation against three senior members of the terrorist group al-Shabaab who are meeting in Nairobi. The plan is for Kenyan forces to arrest them. Then the Kenyan agent Jama Farah (Barkhad Abdi) manages to look inside the house with a tiny camera drone. He sees two bombers being fitted with explosive vests.
Link to the principle
A new piece of information changes the whole situation. An arrest turns into the question of a missile strike. What was clear a moment ago no longer is. And the new information is itself incomplete: When and where do the bombers plan to strike? No one knows.
02
A girl by the wall
Situation
Next to the house, a girl named Alia sets up her bread stand. The drone pilot Steve Watts (Aaron Paul), at a base in Nevada, sees her on his screen and hesitates. Farah tries to buy all her bread so that she will leave. In doing so, his cover is blown and he has to flee.
Link to the principle
The fog lies not only over the enemy but also over the consequences of your own actions. How many people will the attack kill if no one intervenes? How great is the danger to the child if someone does? Neither question can be answered with certainty.
03
The decision moves up the chain
Situation
In London, Lieutenant General Frank Benson (Alan Rickman) sits with ministers and officials. The group cannot agree. The question is passed on to the British Foreign Secretary, who is on a trade trip in Singapore, and from him to the U.S. Secretary of State. Everyone wants to know who will ultimately be responsible.
Link to the principle
A typical reaction to uncertainty is to hand the decision off. If you pass it on, you hope for someone who knows more. But higher up, the picture is no clearer, only farther away. The film shows how this wastes time that no one on the ground has.
04
A number that reassures
Situation
The politicians demand an estimate of how likely the girl is to die. Powell pushes her analyst to find parameters that produce a lower value. He arrives at a range of 45% to 65%. Powell has him confirm only the lower figure and passes it on. The strike is approved.
Link to the principle
This is the film’s most haunting scene. A number is supposed to create certainty where there is none. Stating the range honestly would have made the uncertainty visible. Picking out the favorable figure makes it invisible. That is how judgment turns into justification.
05
The price
Situation
The first missile destroys the house and injures Alia. Because one suspect survives, a second follows. Alia’s parents take her to the hospital, where she dies. In the briefing room in London, a government official accuses Benson of killing from a safe distance. He replies that he himself has been at the scene of five suicide bombings.
Link to the principle
The film does not take an easy position. It shows that in the fog every decision, including doing nothing, puts people at risk. But it also shows how easily you can make the numbers look better in order to be able to live with a decision.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Be prepared for a new piece of information to overturn the whole situation.
02
Don’t hand off a decision just because it is uncomfortable.
03
Give ranges instead of single numbers when you are unsure.
04
Be wary of numbers that come out exactly as you want them to.
05
Doing nothing is also a decision with consequences.
Summary
“Eye in the Sky” shows a group of people who see almost everything with state-of-the-art technology and still don’t know enough. They pass the decision on, look for reassuring numbers and in the end pay a high price. The film makes you feel what Carl von Clausewitz meant by the fog: more images are no substitute for judgment.