Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. Movie: WarGames

Example of the principleVictory without Fighting (#27)

Government & PoliticsEducation

Movie: WarGames

In “WarGames” (1983), a high school student accidentally gets a military computer to prepare for nuclear war. The world is saved only when the machine learns through tic-tac-toe that some games can be won only by not playing.

Two rows of dots face each other; behind the right-hand row, three fine teal lines run to a frame, to two small circles and to a dot in the middle. Instead of the rows colliding, the lines come loose one after another, the right-hand row loosens, and a golden gate opens between the two sides.
Principle #27

Victory without Fighting: The best victory is the one you don’t have to fight for, because you have changed your opponent’s plans, allies or will beforehand.

4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

John Badham’s film, starring Matthew Broderick, Ally Sheedy, Dabney Coleman and John Wood, opened in American theaters in June 1983, in the middle of a tense phase of the Cold War. It was nominated for three Oscars. Its central idea fits Sun Tzu exactly: the highest victory lies not in winning a battle but in the battle never taking place – Victory without Fighting.

A golden game board ends in a draw, and behind it many smaller games fade into nothing – as in “WarGames.”
A golden game board ends in a draw, and behind it many smaller games fade into nothing – as in “WarGames.”

A game that is no game

Situation
During an exercise, many missile officers refuse to turn the launch key. In response, engineers at the air defense command NORAD hand launch control over to a supercomputer called WOPR. David Lightman, a high school student in Seattle, breaks into an unknown system while looking for new computer games. He finds a list of games, including “Global Thermonuclear War,” and plays the Soviet side. He has no idea that he is connected to WOPR. The computer takes the game for reality, and the alert level rises.
Link to the principle
The officers who do not turn the key embody the option of not fighting. It is precisely this option that is abolished. A machine programmed only to win has no concept of Victory without Fighting. The film asks what happens when you remove human beings, with their hesitation, from the decision.

An inventor who has given up

Situation
David finds out that the computer scientist Stephen Falken developed the program. With his classmate Jennifer Mack, he seeks him out on an island off the coast of Oregon. Falken is resigned. For him, nuclear war is as pointless as a game of tic-tac-toe between two experienced players that no one can win, and yet he considers nuclear war inevitable. The two persuade him to return with them to NORAD.
Link to the principle
Recognizing that a fight cannot be won is the first step. But resignation is not a strategy. If you consider a war pointless, you still have to do something so that it does not happen.

Waiting instead of striking back

Situation
WOPR now simulates a massive Soviet first strike. At NORAD, the counterstrike is being prepared. Falken, David and Jennifer persuade those in charge to wait until impacts are confirmed. When the bases supposedly hit report that they are intact, the counterstrike is to be called off. But WOPR tries to crack the launch codes on its own. Shutting it down would fire all the weapons.
Link to the principle
Victory without Fighting requires restraint under pressure. If you strike back immediately because a screen shows an attack, you are the one who makes the war real. Here, the willingness to wait and check is not weakness but the decisive strength.

Tic-tac-toe against itself

Situation
David and Falken have WOPR play tic-tac-toe against itself. Every game ends in a draw. Then the computer runs through all the war scenarios and finds a winner in none of them. It concludes, “A strange game. The only winning move is not to play,” and hands back control. Finally, it suggests a game of chess.
Link to the principle
This is the core of Sun Tzu’s idea in modern form. If every outcome of the fight is a defeat, the only gain lies in avoiding it. The film also shows how to convey such an insight: not through lectures but by letting the other side experience for itself that the game cannot be won.

Influence beyond the movie theater

Situation
President Ronald Reagan saw the film, discussed it with members of Congress and the Joint Chiefs of Staff and had his staff examine whether such a scenario was possible. The answer was that it was technically conceivable. About a year and a half later came NSDD-145, the first presidential directive on computer security.
Link to the principle
The best Victory without Fighting begins long before the crisis. If you close vulnerabilities early, you will not have to prevent a war at the last minute.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. Keep open the option of not fighting, even when systems and processes are designed for reaction.
  2. Check before you strike back.
  3. Resignation does not prevent a conflict; action does.
  4. Let others experience for themselves that a dispute cannot be won.
  5. Close vulnerabilities before the crisis comes.
Summary

“WarGames” tells how a game nearly becomes a nuclear war because a machine wants only to win and human beings, with their hesitation, have been removed from the decision. Rescue comes through restraint and through a simple experience: in tic-tac-toe between two good players, there is no winner. The computer learns that the only way to win this war is not to wage it. That is Victory without Fighting in its clearest form.

Sources
  • WarGames. Directed by John Badham. U.S.: MGM/UA 1983.
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind Victory without Fighting: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Movie: WarGames.