Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. Rupert Murdoch, Wapping and Resistance to the New

Example of the principleResistance to the New (#50)

MediaBusiness

Rupert Murdoch, Wapping and Resistance to the New

In January 1986, Rupert Murdoch moves four major British newspapers overnight to a new printing plant with new technology. The print unions strike against it for a year and lose. The case shows how hard the winners of an old order fight, and why the new nevertheless prevailed here.

A golden circle is pushed up an arc; at the top, a few teal dots push back hard, and at the bottom a large area of mist-blue dots lies still, and the circle rolls back. On the second attempt, dots break away from the area and help push, a teal dot from the top switches over to the circle, and the circle reaches the crest.
Principle #50

Resistance to the New: If you introduce a new order, you face the winners of the old one as determined opponents and have the future winners only as hesitant helpers; that is why change needs more strength, support and patience than its good reasons would suggest.

4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

Niccolò Machiavelli usually describes resistance to the new from the reformer’s point of view. But the principle has two sides. It explains why reformers fail, and it explains under what conditions they prevail. The dispute over the printing plant in Wapping in East London is a harsh and still controversial example of Resistance to the New.

Overnight, a golden arc leads from old printing rollers over a line of pickets into a new, fenced-in plant – as with Rupert Murdoch in Wapping.
Overnight, a golden arc leads from old printing rollers over a line of pickets into a new, fenced-in plant – as with Rupert Murdoch in Wapping.

Fleet Street and the old order

Situation
Until the 1980s, the major British newspapers are printed in London’s Fleet Street using hot-metal typesetting, partly on machines that are decades old. The print unions, above all the National Graphical Association (NGA) and SOGAT 82, control hiring and working practices. Publishers complain about rigid rules and high costs. For the printers, this order means secure, well-paid work.
Link to the principle
Here you see Machiavelli’s opponents of the new in clear form. The old order has beneficiaries who know exactly what they stand to lose. The new technology, computer-based phototypesetting, would make a large part of their work superfluous. Their resistance is determined because the loss is concrete.

The prepared plant

Situation
Murdoch’s company News International builds a new printing plant in Wapping, a few kilometers east of Fleet Street. The unions are told that a new evening paper, the London Post, is to be produced there. In fact, the company is preparing to move The Times, The Sunday Times, The Sun and News of the World. Members of the electricians’ union EETPU stand ready as the workforce. The model is the publisher Eddy Shah, who in 1983 survived a long strike in Warrington with new technology and a new workforce.
Link to the principle
Machiavelli says that reformers who rely on their own strength prevail, while those who depend on others fail. Murdoch has prepared himself: building, technology, staff, distribution. In Machiavelli’s image, he is an armed prophet.

The break in January 1986

Situation
The unions call a strike. On January 24, 1986, all the strikers are dismissed (between 5,500 and 6,000 employees, depending on the source). From then on, the newspapers come out of Wapping. There, 670 printers do the work that had required around 6,800 people in Fleet Street. The papers are delivered not by rail, where the unions have influence, but by trucks from the haulage company TNT. Margaret Thatcher’s government has passed laws restricting secondary strikes.
Link to the principle
The lukewarm support Machiavelli speaks of exists on both sides. Many journalists go to Wapping; some refuse. Readers keep buying the papers. The opponents are passionate; the majority remains passive. Those who have resources and the law on their side can exploit this passivity.

A year at the gate

Situation
Outside the plant, soon called “Fortress Wapping” because of its fence, barbed wire and police presence, strikers and supporters demonstrate week after week. There are violent clashes and more than 1,200 arrests. One union has its assets sequestered because of an unlawful boycott. On February 5, 1987, after 54 weeks, the unions give up.
Link to the principle
The resistance was fierce and long, just as Machiavelli predicts. It did not stop the new, but it drove up the price: bitterness, violence, ruined livelihoods. The scars of this conflict still shape Murdoch’s image in Britain today.

What came next

Situation
Within two years, almost all national newspapers leave Fleet Street and introduce the new technology, with far fewer staff. Today, the British Trades Union Congress (TUC) describes Wapping as a textbook example of how not to introduce new technology.
Link to the principle
Both readings are true. The change was probably unstoppable, and the resistance did not prevent it. But the way it was forced through destroyed trust for decades. The principle explains why change is hard. It does not say that every way of achieving it is equally good.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. Name honestly who loses out through your change.
  2. Count on the losers being louder and more determined than the winners.
  3. Prepare before you make the change public.
  4. Ask yourself whether you only want to win or also want to keep people’s trust.
  5. A change that has been forced through is not yet a successful one.
Summary

In Wapping in 1986, Rupert Murdoch pushed through the new printing technology against the bitter resistance of the unions. He had prepared, with a plant, staff and distribution, and he had the law on his side. The case shows both sides of the principle: the winners of the old order fight hard, and if you are well prepared, you can still win. The price was high.

Sources
  • Niccolò Machiavelli: Der Fürst (in German). Translated by Philipp Rippel. Stuttgart: Reclam 1986, Chapter 6.
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind Resistance to the New: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Rupert Murdoch, Wapping and Resistance to the New.