In 1582, Pope Gregory XIII corrects the calendar that had been in use since Julius Caesar and had long been inaccurate. The reform is factually correct. Even so, the Protestant countries reject it, the German ones until 1700 and Britain until 1752. What bothers people about the new is often not its content but who brings it.
A golden circle is pushed up an arc; at the top, a few teal dots push back hard, and at the bottom a large area of mist-blue dots lies still, and the circle rolls back. On the second attempt, dots break away from the area and help push, a teal dot from the top switches over to the circle, and the circle reaches the crest.
Principle #50
Resistance to the New: If you introduce a new order, you face the winners of the old one as determined opponents and have the future winners only as hesitant helpers; that is why change needs more strength, support and patience than its good reasons would suggest.
4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
Niccolò Machiavelli names two sources of resistance to the new: the fear of those who benefit from the old order, and the disbelief of people who trust something new only after they have long tried it out. In the case of the calendar, a third source comes into play, one that is common in organizations: distrust of the sender. The story of the calendar reform is a lesson in Resistance to the New: it shows how long even the right idea has to wait when it comes from the wrong camp.
Ten days are missing from a calendar page, and a golden arrow jumps over the gap to the next square – as with the Gregorian calendar of 1582.
01
A calendar that drifts
Situation
The Julian calendar, introduced under Julius Caesar in 46 BC, calculates the year slightly too long. The error is about 11 minutes per year. By the 16th century, it has added up to around 10 days. The beginning of spring drifts, and with it the date of Easter, which is calculated from the start of spring.
Link to the principle
The problem has long been known and is undisputed. Scholars described it over the centuries. But a calendar is an order by which everyone lives: leases, market days, feast days, contracts. Changing it affects everyone. That is exactly why the error persists for so long.
02
The reform of 1582
Situation
In 1582, Pope Gregory XIII issues a papal bull reforming the calendar. It is based on a proposal by the physician Aloysius Lilius and worked out by the mathematician Christopher Clavius. Thursday, October 4, 1582, is followed by Friday, October 15. A new leap-year rule drops the leap day in three out of every four century years from then on. Spain, Portugal, Poland and parts of Italy adopt the reform immediately.
Link to the principle
The reform is technically clever and clearly justified. It is introduced by an authority that carries weight in Catholic countries. There it quickly takes hold. Where this authority is not recognized, the same reform becomes a problem.
03
The wrong sender
Situation
A papal bull has no binding force outside the Catholic Church. The Protestant countries largely reject the reform. The reason is not astronomy. Only a few decades after the Reformation, they fear that by accepting the calendar they would also be recognizing the pope’s authority over their lives.
Link to the principle
Machiavelli writes that the opponents of the new fight with passion, while its supporters are only half-hearted. Here this holds in a special form. Those who thought the calendar was sound on the merits had no reason to risk a political fight for it. Those who rejected it were defending their independence. Passion beats objectivity.
04
Two calendars for over a century
Situation
In the Holy Roman Empire, two calendars exist side by side for more than a century. In the religiously mixed city of Augsburg, the calendar dispute almost leads to civil war in 1584, and contracts there later often bear both dates. Only in 1700 do the Protestant estates of the Empire adopt the new reckoning, under the name “Improved Calendar” and with their own way of calculating Easter. Britain follows in 1752: September 2 is followed by September 14. Reports of riots demanding the return of the lost 11 days are now considered greatly exaggerated or invented.
Link to the principle
What is remarkable is how the Protestants finally accept the reform: not as a papal calendar but as their own improvement. The new prevails once it no longer counts as submission. If you want to overcome resistance, you have to give your opponents a way to accept the new without losing face.
05
Into the 20th century
Situation
The Orthodox countries hold on to the Julian calendar even longer. Russia switches only in 1918, Greece in 1923. Many Orthodox churches still calculate Easter according to the old calendar today.
Link to the principle
More than 300 years lie between the reform and the last adoption by a state. This is Machiavelli’s second source of resistance: people trust the new only once it has long been tested, and communities only once the cost of standing apart becomes too high.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Check whether the resistance is aimed at the idea or at the sender.
02
If necessary, let good ideas be championed by someone your opponents trust.
03
Give others the chance to adopt the new as their own.
04
For deep changes, plan in years, not months.
05
Remember that the cost of standing apart often convinces people more than arguments do.
Summary
The calendar reform of 1582 was right, but it came from the pope. That is why the Protestant countries rejected it for a long time, the German ones until 1700 and Britain until 1752. The new prevailed only once it could count as their own improvement. The example shows that resistance is often aimed at the sender and that it is overcome when opponents can save face.