In the early 1980s, a small software company in Texas sets out to challenge IBM with a cloned portable PC. The series shows what disruption looks like from the outside: as a risky bet by outsiders on an offering the market leader does not take seriously.
A flat mist-blue line shows what most people need; a steep teal line rises far above it, with a few bright dots at the top. Below, a small gold dot climbs step by step, dots move toward it until it crosses the flat line and the crowd shifts over to it.
Principle #76
Disruption: Incumbents rarely lose to better rivals; they lose to simpler, cheaper ones they don’t take seriously at first because their best customers don’t want these offerings.
4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
“Halt and Catch Fire” ran from 2014 to 2017 on the U.S. network AMC, with four seasons and 40 episodes. It was created by Christopher Cantwell and Christopher C. Rogers. The title refers to a machine instruction that brings a processor to a standstill. The series tells the story of the computer revolution of the 1980s and the beginnings of the internet from the perspective of people whose names are not IBM, Apple or Microsoft – a story of Disruption.
A large computer tower made of dots, with fine lines scanning it; on the right stands a small gold suitcase PC – as in “Halt and Catch Fire.”
01
A giant that leaves the door open
Situation
In August 1981, IBM launches its Personal Computer. It is assembled from other manufacturers’ components, and its architecture is open. The main thing that is protected is the BIOS, the basic software that starts the computer. The series begins shortly afterward, in Dallas. Joe MacMillan, played by Lee Pace, a former IBM salesman, joins Cardiff Electric, a small company that makes mainframe software.
Link to the principle
Here the incumbent itself creates the conditions for its challengers. IBM builds a standard that others can replicate. Disruption often begins at exactly such points: where a market leader relies on its brand and its large customers and leaves the lower end of the market open.
02
Cloning instead of inventing
Situation
Joe wins over the engineer Gordon Clark, played by Scoot McNairy, who has long since buried his ambitions. They are joined by the young programmer Cameron Howe, played by Mackenzie Davis. The team decodes IBM’s BIOS and builds a compatible portable computer, the “Giant.” Legal risks, internal power struggles and conflicts with company management threaten the project again and again.
Link to the principle
A clone is not a better product in the market leader’s sense. It is the same thing, only cheaper and packaged differently. That is precisely the logic of disruption from below: you don’t have to beat the incumbent at its strength but where its costs and habits make it immobile.
03
The fight over direction
Situation
Within the team, attitudes collide. Joe wants something big that will change the industry. Gordon wants a solid machine that works. Cameron wants software that can do something of its own. Above all, company management wants to stay afloat. Toward the end of the first season, they present the computer at the COMDEX computer trade show in Las Vegas.
Link to the principle
Even for the attacker, disruption is no sure thing. If you enter through an open standard, you have to expect others to do the same. The advantage of being cheaper lasts only as long as no one is cheaper still.
04
The next wave
Situation
In the second and third seasons, Cameron and Donna Clark, played by Kerry Bishé, run the online company Mutiny, an early community for games and conversation. The fourth season revolves around competing search engines in the early World Wide Web. The characters are sometimes the attackers, sometimes incumbents themselves who get overtaken.
Link to the principle
Over four seasons, the series shows that disruption is not a one-time event but one wave after another. Whoever rolls up the market today will be at the top tomorrow and will have to look down.
05
Fiction with a real background
Situation
The company Cardiff Electric is invented. The background is not. In the early 1980s, IBM-compatible computers really did emerge; their manufacturers rewrote the BIOS in a strictly separated clean-room process so as not to infringe any rights. A well-known example is the Compaq Portable, which went on sale in 1983.
Link to the principle
Over the years, the clones took large parts of the PC market away from IBM. The series makes this pattern visible in individual people: in their greed, their courage and their mistakes.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Check where you yourself are opening the door for others to replicate what you do.
02
As an attacker, you need not the best product but an offering the big player doesn’t want to make.
03
Count on others seeing the same gap.
04
Clarify early in the team whether you want to be cheaper, better or different.
05
If you disrupt today, you will be the incumbent tomorrow.
Summary
“Halt and Catch Fire” tells the story of a small company in Dallas that takes on IBM with a cloned portable PC. The series shows disruption from the attackers’ perspective: as a bet on an offering the market leader does not take seriously, with competition on every side. Over four seasons, it becomes clear that every wave prepares the next.