Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. Wikipedia, Britannica and Disruption

Example of the principleDisruption (#76)

MediaEducation

Wikipedia, Britannica and Disruption

The Encyclopaedia Britannica has been published in print since 1768. In 2012, it ends its print edition. It was not pushed aside by a better encyclopedia but by a free one, written by amateurs and long dismissed by experts.

A flat mist-blue line shows what most people need; a steep teal line rises far above it, with a few bright dots at the top. Below, a small gold dot climbs step by step, dots move toward it until it crosses the flat line and the crowd shifts over to it.
Principle #76

Disruption: Incumbents rarely lose to better rivals; they lose to simpler, cheaper ones they don’t take seriously at first because their best customers don’t want these offerings.

4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

The Harvard economist Clayton M. Christensen described how established companies fail even though they do almost everything right. They listen to their best customers, improve their product and earn good money. That is exactly why they overlook offerings that are worse at first but simpler and cheaper. The story of Britannica and Wikipedia can be read as an example of this pattern of Disruption, in two stages.

On the left, a row of heavy volumes; on the right, a mosaic of tiny tiles grows beyond their height, gold at the top – like Wikipedia versus Britannica.
On the left, a row of heavy volumes; on the right, a mosaic of tiny tiles grows beyond their height, gold at the top – like Wikipedia versus Britannica.

A work with authority

Situation
The Encyclopaedia Britannica first appears in Edinburgh in 1768. For more than two centuries, it is regarded as the benchmark for reliable knowledge. Its articles are written by experts, and the editors check every entry. In the 20th century, salesmen sell it door to door, especially to middle-class parents who want to give their children a good education. Many families pay in monthly installments. In 1990, Britannica sells about 120,000 printed sets, more than ever before.
Link to the principle
A record year is the typical starting point of a disruption. The company is successful, its business model works, its customers are satisfied. There is no reason to change anything fundamental. It is precisely this strength that blinds it to what is emerging at the bottom of the market.

The first wave: the CD-ROM

Situation
In the 1990s, Microsoft launches Encarta, an encyclopedia on CD-ROM. It is less comprehensive than the Britannica, but cheap, and it runs on the family PC. By 1996, sales of the printed Britannica fall to about 40,000 sets a year. Britannica brings out a CD-ROM edition of its own but at its core remains a publisher of expensive printed works.
Link to the principle
Christensen calls this form disruption from below. The new offering is weaker on the classic dimension of performance, here depth and authority. But it scores on price and convenience. For many families, “good enough and cheap” matters more than “the best.”

The second wave: knowledge from everyone

Situation
In March 2000, Jimmy Wales and Larry Sanger launch Nupedia, a free online encyclopedia with expert authors and multistage review. The review process is so laborious that hardly any articles get finished. On January 15, 2001, they launch Wikipedia as a side project that anyone can write for. The German edition follows on March 16, 2001. The English Wikipedia passes 100,000 articles in 2003 and one million in March 2006.
Link to the principle
Nupedia was an attempt to beat Britannica at its own game, and it failed. Wikipedia changed the model: free, open, instantly up to date. At first, the quality was uneven. For Britannica’s customers, libraries and the educated middle class, it was no serious substitute. For schoolchildren and everyday questions, it was enough.

The rise to the top

Situation
In 2005, the scientific journal Nature compares science articles from both works. It finds just under four errors per article on average in Wikipedia and just under three in the Britannica. Britannica disputes the study’s method. In the same year, a falsified biography shows how vulnerable the open model is. Wikipedia responds with stricter rules, for example on creating new articles. In March 2012, Britannica announces that it will stop printing. The 32-volume 2010 edition remains the last.
Link to the principle
This is the second part of every disruption. The newcomer does not stay at the bottom. It improves until it is good enough even for more demanding users. By the time the incumbent notices, its core business has already shrunk. What did not happen also matters: Britannica did not disappear. The company turned to online subscriptions and educational products and as early as 2009 earned about 60% of its revenue from its online business.

What you can learn from it

Situation
Britannica did not sleep through the development. There was a CD-ROM, a website and later apps. But the business model of expert authors, review and a sales price did not fit a market in which knowledge was free and written by everyone.
Link to the principle
Disruption is rarely a technology problem. It is a business model problem. If you tie your strength to authority and price, you cannot simply replicate a free offering without attacking your own foundation.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. Ask yourself who, below you in the market, is making a “worse” offer that is enough for many.
  2. Your record year is no proof that your model will carry you for the next 10 years.
  3. Judge newcomers not only by your quality standard but by the standard of their users.
  4. Count on a weak offering getting better quickly.
  5. Check whether your business model allows a response at all.
Summary

For more than two centuries, the Britannica was the measure of reliable knowledge. First Encarta on CD-ROM, then the free Wikipedia attacked it from below. Both were weaker at first, but cheaper and more convenient. Wikipedia quickly got better, and in 2012 the print edition ended after 244 years. The company survived digitally, but its old core business had disappeared.

Sources
  • Clayton M. Christensen: The Innovator’s Dilemma. Boston: Harvard Business School Press 1997.
  • Jim Giles: Internet encyclopaedias go head to head. In: Nature 438 (2005), pp. 900–901.
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind Disruption: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Wikipedia, Britannica and Disruption.