Christopher Latham Sholes, QWERTY and Path Dependence
The sequence of letters on almost every English-language keyboard dates from the 1870s and comes from the workshop of a printer in Wisconsin. It has outlived the typewriter, the computer and the smartphone, not because it is the best but because everyone had already learned it.
A first gold dot draws a slightly curved line around a small circle across a surface of mist-blue dots; further dots follow exactly this line until it becomes a strong gold track. Then the circle fades, a shorter, straight line appears beside it, only dashed in mist-blue, and the dots still stay in the curve.
Principle #81
Path Dependence: Early, often accidental decisions determine which paths remain open later; that is why beginnings matter more than they seem to at the time.
4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
Look at your keyboard. In English, the top row of letters begins with Q, W, E, R, T, Y; in Germany, it has a Z instead of the Y. Nobody designed this layout for computers. It dates from the early days of the typewriter. In 1985, the economic historian Paul A. David used it to explain what Path Dependence means. Since then, QWERTY has been the best-known and at the same time the most disputed example of this principle.
A typewriter, a keyboard and a phone share the same staggered key pattern; a golden thread connects the top row – as with QWERTY.
01
A printer from Wisconsin
Situation
Christopher Latham Sholes is a printer, newspaperman and tinkerer in Milwaukee. Together with partners, he develops a typewriter and applies for a patent in 1867. He is far from being the first to invent a typewriter. For several years, he keeps changing the arrangement of the keys. On early models, the typebars jam when you type quickly.
Link to the principle
A path often begins with the practical problems of a particular time. Sholes solves the problems of his machine. Whether his solution will suit machines a hundred years later is not a question he can ask himself.
02
Remington buys the rights
Situation
In 1873, the rights go to the gun maker E. Remington and Sons, which brings the first machines to market in 1874. Remington’s mechanics rearrange the keys once more. According to a widespread account, they make sure that the letters for “TYPE WRITER” lie in a single row, so that salesmen can demonstrate the word quickly.
Link to the principle
A sales trick and a technical stopgap shape a layout that is still in use today. That is typical of path dependence: the reasons for an early choice are often small and accidental. Their consequences are large and lasting.
03
Why the keys are where they are is disputed
Situation
For a long time, people said the layout was meant to slow typists down so that the typebars would not jam. The Japanese researchers Koichi Yasuoka and Motoko Yasuoka, by contrast, have shown that telegraph operators transcribing Morse code were among the most important early customers and may have influenced the layout. To this day, its exact origin has not been fully clarified.
Link to the principle
This shows something important: for path dependence, it hardly matters why the first choice turned out the way it did. What matters is what happened afterward. The original reasons have long since disappeared; the result has remained.
04
Typing schools lock in the standard
Situation
Toward the end of the 19th century, touch typing spreads. Typing schools train typists on QWERTY machines. If you can type on QWERTY, you find work. If you buy a machine, you choose the layout the typists know. Later alternatives, such as the keyboard layout patented by August Dvorak in 1936, fail to catch on.
Link to the principle
This is where a choice becomes a path. The more people learn QWERTY, the more valuable it becomes to use QWERTY, and the more expensive any switch becomes. The economist W. Brian Arthur calls this increasing returns: a lead reinforces itself until a system is locked in.
05
A textbook example with a dispute
Situation
In 1985, Paul A. David publishes his essay “Clio and the Economics of QWERTY” in the American Economic Review. He interprets QWERTY as an example of how early accidents can lock in an inferior standard. In 1990, Stan J. Liebowitz and Stephen E. Margolis object. They consider the superiority of the Dvorak keyboard unproven.
Link to the principle
The dispute sharpens the principle. Path dependence does not necessarily mean that the inferior option wins. It means that early decisions narrow the room for later ones. Whether QWERTY is inferior remains open. What is undisputed is that it is locked in.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Take early decisions seriously, even if they seem small.
02
Ask yourself which habits will form around a choice.
03
Watch for the point at which training and familiarity make a switch expensive.
04
Distinguish whether something is good or merely widespread.
05
If you want to change something, do it before everyone has gotten used to it.
Summary
The QWERTY keyboard emerged in the 1870s from the problems of an early typewriter and the interests of its manufacturer. Because typists were trained on it, its lead reinforced itself until it was locked in. It survived every technological change. Whether it is the best layout is disputed, but it shows what path dependence means: early, often accidental decisions determine what is still possible later.
Paul A. David: Clio and the Economics of QWERTY. In: The American Economic Review 75 (1985), No. 2, pp. 332–337.
W. Brian Arthur: Competing Technologies, Increasing Returns, and Lock-In by Historical Events. In: The Economic Journal 99 (1989), No. 394, pp. 116–131.
Stan J. Liebowitz and Stephen E. Margolis: The Fable of the Keys. In: Journal of Law and Economics 33 (1990), No. 1, pp. 1–25.
Koichi Yasuoka and Motoko Yasuoka: On the Prehistory of QWERTY. In: ZINBUN 42 (2011), pp. 161–174.
Back to the basics
Read what lies behind Path Dependence: with explanation, animation, video and research.